Crowd Watch Mk 3

[Timmah]

Strong opinion there...

Manly 14,593 = Pass, NQ 178 less = Fail, Titans 188 less = Fail
Eels 16,803 = Excellent, Wests 576 less = Pass

So this seems to be your system

>16800 - Excellent
<14500 - Fail

So the difference between a fail and excellent mark is 2300? Really?

Except for Souths who are borderline Pass and Excellent for 18904....

There's no set scale, each club has clearly been rated in ability.

Hypothetically - Canberra getting 18,000 would fall to "excellent", while for Canterbury or Newcastle it would be "pass".

 

[ouwet]

I'm guessing he's using a subjective size of appeal of club ie 16k for Sharks would be excellent, 25k for Broncos would be a fail. Combination of performance during season, size of club/supporter base, stadium capacity & historic crowds would prob be the criteria needed.

Yep... Just my opinion.