Aku or Vatuvei would both be deserving winners of this. They're both awesome wingers who chew up so many metres for their sides. Aku provides more individual brilliance with his clean breaks from anywhere. I've never seen a winger score so many tries from dummy half. I would consider Manu to be safer though, definetely better under the high ball and less error prone.
Manu is put in far better attacking positions by his team. Look at today as an example. The three tries he scored were all from close range, where someone of his size will score nearly every time. Aku made his mark on the game when nothing was doing, breaking straight through the middle of a set defence. I can't help but think Aku would be miles ahead in the tryscoring if given similar opportunities as Manu. With this being only his second full season, I think Uate will prove to be a class above Vatuvei and all the other NRL wingers over the next few years.
