Do you want Brad Arthur as coach

[Avenger]

I would wait until their three year rolling win rate dropped below 40%. In the case of Kearney, at the time he was arseholed we would've had to win 19 of his next 30 for his 3YRWR to get above 40%. No chance with our squad at the time.

You still would have made excuses for him.

 

[the phantom menace]

Every coach has missed the finals. Finishing ninth is well within the normal range of expected results for almost every club. How could you sack a merkin for it?

Because it's his 10th-plus year in charge, there are concerns about recruitment and retention and the ability for merkins to but into what he's built and come or stay with the club (for unders), and his extension KPI should have been about getting in the finals?

 

[the phantom menace]

I would wait until their three year rolling win rate dropped below 40%.

Then why the f**k is one of your two meaningless look-I-can-count threads titled "losses until 50%" instead of losses until 40%, you dopey clown?

 

[Poupou Escobar]

You still would have made excuses for him.

You would never have hired Cleary from the Tigers.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

the ability for merkins to but into what he's built

He doesn't build the team, that is the responsibility of the recruitment/retention staff. As far as developing players, he did that and other clubs poached them off us. That happens at every successful club, and we have been successful for a few years now.

and come or stay with the club (for unders)

Again, this is above his pay grade. Do merkins take unders to go to the Roosters because of Robinson or Politis? How many merkins have left Penrith for weaker clubs?

 

[Poupou Escobar]

Then why the f**k is one of your two meaningless look-I-can-count threads titled "losses until 50%" instead of losses until 40%, you dopey clown?

Because after we lost a couple of games some smartarse asked for a losses until 50% thread. So I gave them one. You are free to keep enjoying it.

 

[the phantom menace]

He doesn't build the team, that is the responsibility of the recruitment/retention staff. As far as developing players, he did that and other clubs poached them off us. That happens at every successful club, and we have been successful for a few years now.

Tiresome. You'd love it if your posted musings were half as teflon to any criticism as you are trying to make the role of a rugby league head coach.

Again, this is above his pay grade. Do merkins take unders to go to the Roosters because of Robinson or Politis? How many merkins have left Penrith for weaker clubs?

I don't know, you tell me... they're your rhetorical questions, adding zero to anyone's discussion here.

 

[the phantom menace]

Because after we lost a couple of games some smartarse asked for a losses until 50% thread. So I gave them one. You are free to keep enjoying it.

Who was the smart arse who asked for your threads, exactly? Asking for some friends...

 

[Poupou Escobar]

Tiresome

lol

 

[Incorrect]

You would never have hired Cleary from the Tigers.

Well to be realistic, we wouldn't have had the chance, Penrith poached him, we weren't aware he was available.... We'll never know

 

[Avenger]

You would never have hired Cleary from the Tigers.

You wouldn’t have hired Webster from the same team if we boned BA.

 

[hineyrulz]

You wouldn’t have hired Webster from the same team if we boned BA.

He would have brought Kearney back. Give him the chance to get to 40%

 

[IFR33K]

He would have brought Kearney back. Give him the chance to get to 40%

*30%


got to crawl before you walk.

 

[Gary Gutful]

If we miss the 8 then BA should be rissolled, boned, arseholed, abolished, eradicated, felled, discharged, dismissed and sent packing!

 

[Gary Gutful]

In the case of Kearney, at the time he was arseholed we would've had to win 19 of his next 30 for his 3YRWR to get above 40%. No chance with our squad at the time.

Big Face's 3 year rolling plop rate was still at 85%

 

[Avenger]

If we miss the 8 then BA should be rissolled, boned, arseholed, abolished, eradicated, felled, discharged, dismissed and sent packing!

But he won't and I don't think you're serious either.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

You wouldn’t have hired Webster from the same team if we boned BA.

And I still wouldn't. One season tells us nothing about a coach.

 

[JokerEel]

And I still wouldn't. One season tells us nothing about a coach.

True Fitzgibbon last year was a good coach this year not so much...

 

[JokerEel]

Even with a poor season questions need to be answered of BA MON and our CEO on why we were poor in recruiting last year.

Chasing an old run down replacement hooker instead of chasing Lussick sooner. (Maybe they did but him coming now kid of shows they didn't).

Not having direct replacements for ICE Marata or Kaufusi was crazy Lucky Hopgood came across as 1 good buy!

 

[King-Gutho94]

And I still wouldn't. One season tells us nothing about a coach.

Good luck to the warriors they have had a good draw with a lot of luck.

Johnson may fall off a cliff again next year. He hasn't won a final since 2011 Prelim against Melbourne so I guess we will find out come September if he is actually good enough in big games.