Do you want Jamie Lyon at Parramatta?

[Suitman]

God forgives, Parra Pete doesn't....Forget him.... He walked out on his mates, and put the Club up to ridicule. How can you forgive that????

I really, really, do not understand that attitude, but it is your opinion, so I respect it.

Suity

 

[The Colonel]

For all you know, Brian Smith could have been completely at fault.

Then if that was the case why deny it? Come out and say if Brian was the problem. Whenever it has been suggested he denies it. Either he isn't sure or he was poorly advised.....

 

[ParraDude_Jay]

If Brain Smith was the problem, why did he go to a Manly game and pose with their jersey. Also what proof do we have that BS was the reason... NONE

What proof do you have that he wasn't the reason... NONE

I didn't accuse Brian Smith of anything, I just think it's unfair to judge Jamie when not one of us knows the circumstances behind it. You can just as easily flip the coin and say Brian was at fault, but nobody is even considering that may be the case.

The Manly incident, OK I can't explain that other than I really think Cleal had him practically brainwashed. He's not the same person he was in 2004, the time in St. Helens has changed him. He's playing his best ever football and I can't see why people aren't willing to let him have a chance. Not that my opinion or yours matter in the big picture, it's really up to Hagan, Fitzy and Jamie.

 

[Suitman]

I'm not Smith bashing.

I'm saying that people can sit here and hate Jamie for what happened and not one person even considers that Smithy might be at fault. It's all "f**k you Lyon you little sh*t" etc. which is pathetic because all he was doing is looking out for himself and I don't blame him.

And for the record, I don't hate Brian Smith, I respect him for what he's done for our club. I merely think he's been here too long.

Read your PM's.

Suity

 

[The Colonel]

St Helen's not even as big as Wollongong.

Still as far from Wee Waa as you can get.

And who's odd's are they Colonel??? Oh that's right, yours.

Suity

And its your opinion he won't. I hope I'm wrong if he does come.

 

[Suitman]

[/color]


And its your opinion he won't.

Get your facts right Colonel.
I have never said that.

Suity

 

[The Colonel]

Get your facts right Colonel.
I have never said that.

Suity

Alright - if he comes and things aren't the way he wants them to be, in your opinion will he walk or stay?

 

[Stagger eel]

What proof do you have that he wasn't the reason... NONE

I didn't accuse Brian Smith of anything, I just think it's unfair to judge Jamie when not one of us knows the circumstances behind it. You can just as easily flip the coin and say Brian was at fault, but nobody is even considering that may be the case.

The Manly incident, OK I can't explain that other than I really think Cleal had him practically brainwashed. He's not the same person he was in 2004, the time in St. Helens has changed him. He's playing his best ever football and I can't see why people aren't willing to let him have a chance. Not that my opinion or yours matter in the big picture, it's really up to Hagan, Fitzy and Jamie.

and you can probably add a couple of blokes from our playing staff..

 

[Suitman]

Alright - if he comes and things aren't the way he wants them to be, in your opinion will he walk or stay?

That is a most rediculous question.
How would I know?

One thing I do know is that I am not going to judge him on his past.

Suity

 

[fish eel]

He has stayed at St Helens........I'm sure everything there isnt exactly how he wants it.

 

[forward pass]

Alright - if he comes and things aren't the way he wants them to be, in your opinion will he walk or stay?

I can't imagine he would ever do that again!! We would look like a complete and utter goose !

 

[The Colonel]

That is a most rediculous question.
How would I know?

One thing I do know is that I am not going to judge him on his past.

Suity

Don't skirt the question.

Ridiculous? Hardly. In this case he has already walked out once. Will he do it again if things don't go his way? Yes or No. History suggests that to be the case......

People are already making assumptions that his time in St Helens has changed him. How different is that to any of my opinion?

 

[The Colonel]

He has stayed at St Helens........I'm sure everything there isnt exactly how he wants it.

You could also argue the only reason he stayed was because he couldn't go where he really wanted to.

 

[Suitman]

Ridiculous? Hardly. In this case he has already walked out once. Will he do it again? Yes or No.

Don't skirt the question.

Still ridiculous.
I answered the question. I wouldn't have a f**king clue.

If you want to know the answer, ask Jamie, because frankly, I don't think you'd know either.

Suity

 

[The Colonel]

Still ridiculous.
I answered the question. I wouldn't have a f**king clue.

If you want to know the answer, ask Jamie, because frankly, I don't think you'd know either.

Suity

The clues are already there Suity.....

 

[Suitman]

People are already making assumptions that his time in St Helens has changed him. How different is that to any of my opinion?

That was a conveniently edited post.

Ask the people who are saying that.

Suity

 

[Suitman]

The clues are already there Suity.....

So you already know that he would if he could?

Suity

 

[The Colonel]

That was a conveniently edited post.

I'll skip that bit.

Ask the people who are saying that.

Suity

You're having a go at opinions. Why can't you?

 

[fish eel]

You could also argue the only reason he stayed was because he couldn't go where he really wanted to.

well, he could have gone home and put his feet up for a couple of years.

To many ifs buts could counldnts in my view.

If he comes back, which I think the odds are still long on, I'd take his willingness to come back to Parramatta as a positive sign and will judge him on his future actions.

 

[The Colonel]

So you already know that he would if he could?

Suity

He's done it before, but thats right you don't judge on past mistakes? Yet players like Burt and Graham are continually judged on their past....