What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Does this make Parra the 2009 premiers???

hellteam

First Grade
Messages
6,536
Eels don't need it you c**k-gobbler, the eels deserved it. How can you tell me all those consecutive wins and the top form of the eels in 2009 didn't project them from the bottom of the table to the top taking out just about every team in the nrl. They came from nothing, and managed to only just loose to a bunch of cheaters in the finals. Therefore eels should be premiers. You can spit out those sour grapes you've been chewing on since your team was knocked out of the 09 finals ;-)

They finished 8th during the year.... Once again though, you don't understand that it's not an Olympic 100m race and would like to claim this as your premiership as you haven't won anything for 30 years, probably your whole life time. I know that must be sad, but the majority of Eels (and all Manly) fans would see that you are being idiotic, and are probably embarrassed that you are claiming it.

And as for the preliminary final, we would have lost to anyone that night, Tonie Carroll was playing halfback! But we lost to the Storm (3 years in a row actually), they were cheating, but in no way do I feel that we 'automatically' should go down in the record books of being in the grand final.

And Manly and Brisbane both did better than the Eels during the season only to be knocked out by the same cheaters in the finals you f**king moron.

In fact three teams were illegitimately knocked out by the Storm last year. And because the Eagles finished the highest on the ladder out of those teams and thus were the best of them throughout the year, they have more right to be crowned premiers than you.

That's right. In fact, if the NRL decided the premiership would HAVE to go to someone (which they wouldn't, but for arguments sake), the fairest thing to do would be to take away all the points from the Storm games, and see who came first on the ladder. And that definitely wouldn't be the Eels.
 

Eels Dude

Coach
Messages
19,065
They probably wouldnt want it, but Manly do deserve it. They won the premiership, and were not beaten by another team in the finals series.

Parramatta though are a different story. They finished 8th, and (like the Broncos) were eliminated by Melbourne. That is not enough to win the title. I think and i stated reasons on another thread, that the only option is to give the title to St George, who were the premiers, anyway (even including Melbourne).


Um ok.... interesting use of logic. You either have to agree that Manly deserve the premiership in '07 and the Eels in '08... or conclude that they BOTH don't. You can't simply say Manly deserve the trophy in '07 and the Eels don't. For the record, I think neither team should be awarded it.
 

Didgi

Moderator
Messages
17,260
Melbourne won the Grand Final. Their Grand Final win hasn't been stripped, their title of premiers for those two years has been stripped.

Melbourne fans can still say they won 3 grand finals, but would be stupid to do so seeing as everyone now knows they cheated.
 

Latest posts

Top