What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Dynamic Gidley top of Tigers' wish list

hybrid_tiger

Coach
Messages
11,684
Dynamic Gidley top of Tigers' wish list

PETER BADEL
23 April 2006
Sunday Mail, The

WESTS Tigers are gunning for Newcastle attacking dynamo Kurt Gidley as they intensify their search for a replacement for departing halfback Scott Prince.

After months of speculation about Prince's possible successor, the premiers have hatched plans to snare Gidley, who remains a free agent for next year.

The Tigers have identified several candidates for the No.7 jumper, including Roosters rookie Jamie Soward, Dragon Mathew Head and Parramatta utility John Morris.

But Gidley is the top target, with Tigers recruitment chief Warren McDonnell confirming he contacted Gidley's manager Darryl Mather a fortnight ago.

"We've made an expression of interest in Kurt," McDonnell said.

"We're looking for a halfback with a kicking game, a football brain and a bit of pace.

"Kurt is a very good player. I have a list of halfbacks available and Kurt is one guy coming off contract at the end of this season."

Gidley's signing would be a massive coup for the Tigers.

The 23-year-old was NSW's 18th man for the 2004 Origin series and is often touted as Andrew Johns's successor at Newcastle.

Should the Tigers succeed in luring Gidley, he would form a devastating scrumbase combination with five-eighth Benji Marshall.

The Knights are favourites to snare Gidley's signature, but the Country Origin representative has not ruled out testing his value on the open market.

"I've never been on the open market before so it's nice to know there's some interest," Gidley said.

"I've grown up in Newcastle, my brother's here, so obviously they are my first preference.

"But I'm in no rush (to re-sign). I don't want to say too much, I'm leaving everything up to my manager."

Tigers assistant coach Royce Simmons said the joint venture needed an established playmaker to replace Prince, who will join the Gold Coast next season.

"Unless you have a superstar coming through you have to go to the open market to replace a bloke like Princey," Simmons said.

"Kurt is a very talented player, there's no doubt about that.

"He's played in Newcastle with a lot of grand final players and internationals around him and he's slowly got better and better.

"He's had a great education from (Knights coach) Michael Hagan and Andrew Johns."

I really hope this doesn't happen.

While I don't think Gidley is a bad player in any sense, I don't believe he is as good as Prince. I am really hesitatant to sign him because I think Johns makes him look better than he actually is. Am I overeacting?

IMO we would be better off throwing the kitchen sink at Mathew Head.

Thoughts?
 

Davester

Juniors
Messages
1,230
hybrid_tiger said:
I really hope this doesn't happen.

While I don't think Gidley is a bad player in any sense, I don't believe he is as good as Prince. I am really hesitatant to sign him because I think Johns makes him look better than he actually is. Am I overeacting?

IMO we would be better off throwing the kitchen sink at Mathew Head.

Thoughts?

Agreed!
 

Eddie.

Bench
Messages
4,188
I think Kidley is a very handy footballer. However, is he a fulltime Halfback?? - not convinced. Knights fans seem bag Kidley like we bag Fitzhenry.
 

hybrid_tiger

Coach
Messages
11,684
Eddie. said:
I think Kidley is a very handy footballer. However, is he a fulltime Halfback?? - not convinced. Knights fans seem bag Kidley like we bag Fitzhenry.

God, he can't be 1/10th as bad as the Fitz. :oops:
 

Johns Magic

Referee
Messages
21,654
hybrid_tiger said:
So he's no good then? Strengths? Weaknesses?

I'll watch him closely over the next few weeks, but I don't think we should be targetting him.

Watch the Warriors match and the Storm match this year. His "playmaking" revolves around running across field and then throwing a wayward cutout pass to his brother, and he couldn't kick his way out of a paper bag.
 

Stranger

Coach
Messages
18,682
hybrid_tiger said:
So he's no good then? Strengths? Weaknesses?

I'll watch him closely over the next few weeks, but I don't think we should be targetting him.

Strengths - Kick chase, defence, Johns
Weakness - Everything else.

Kiddley is a player that has to be spoon fed what to do... he has the talent to do it, but if hes not told to, he doesnt have the creativity to do anything.
 
Messages
3,877
hybrid_tiger said:
IMO we would be better off throwing the kitchen sink at Mathew Head.

As much as I love Heady, I'm trying to imagine a defensive line with both Benji Marhsall and Matt Head in it...

:shock:

Would not be pretty.
 

Johns Magic

Referee
Messages
21,654
He looks good outside Johns because all he has to do is tackle and run off him.

He'd make an awesome centre, but he's no playmaker in any sense of the word. His playmaking abilities have gone backwards over the last few years. One trick pony.
 

MrSharky

Juniors
Messages
1,933
Attacking Dynamo LOL :lol: :lol: :lol:






icon6.gif
 

hybrid_tiger

Coach
Messages
11,684
HMS Cheesemaker said:
As much as I love Heady, I'm trying to imagine a defensive line with both Benji Marhsall and Matt Head in it...

:shock:

Would not be pretty.

Scott Prince isn't the greatest defender in the world.

Don't think it would be a problem. His attacking abilities and what he brings to the table with his kicking game would outshine any defensive frailties.
 

Jono078

Referee
Messages
21,201
IMO he would excell at the Tigers, they play an expansive game which would suit Gidley, and his defence is really good for a 5/8th/halfback.
 

hybrid_tiger

Coach
Messages
11,684
Jono078 said:
IMO he would excell at the Tigers, they play an expansive game which would suit Gidley, and his defence is really good for a 5/8th/halfback.

What about his kicking game? Does he run to the line alot?
 

Johns Magic

Referee
Messages
21,654
If Marshall takes iver the playmaking he'll go alright.

Jono, as if the Knights' attacking game isn't expansive.
 

Stranger

Coach
Messages
18,682
He has a good kicking game if ur looking to pin a team down...

The grubber behind the line works... other than that :lol: good luck.
 

Latest posts

Top