What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Early tip: Sandow won't see out his contract

strider

Post Whore
Messages
79,038
TV is effective. That's why every club have video sessions after ges and go through what happens during a game.

true - but there isn't really an alternative (ie watching live) "after" a game :lol:


I could also throw up a statement like - live is better, you don't see coaches sitting in a closed room with a tv during a game .... but again thats a simplistic comment - there are good and bad to both live and tv
 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
154,479
Guys, I've been reading this thread for the last 4 or 5 pages. I haven't come in here to gloat or anything like that, I actually feel sorry for Parramatta at the moment because truth be told it's how Souths have been for about the last 400 years.

I have a good friend who is a staunch Parra fan and I console him every week, basically telling him that the only way is up, there are positive signs but you just have to look for them.

You can't all just sit here bagging out Sandow, when he has the go forward and some confidence in him by the coaching staff to play however he wants, then there isn't many halves better than him on his day. Simple fact of the matter is that he is playing behind a struggling pack who are consistently failing to bend the line. Mannah busts his hump every week and so does Fui, but other than that the rest are just plodders.

Sandow also doesn't have someone in the halves who is dominant to be the sane one in the partnership, to pull him into line and help him with structure. The most important thing you guys need to realise is how can a midget carry 16 other blokes?

You guys aren't too far off, it's stupid little mistakes that cost you dearly, like pushing miracle passes inside your 20 on the 2nd-3rd tackle.. What for? Get into the grind and play it out, too often when Parra get 6-12 points down they panic and start pushing passes and the mistakes flow and that 6-12 point start turns into 18-24 point start and it's all she wrote.

I tell my Parra mate all the time, there are many similarities with Parra and (Souths) hang on to the young blokes like Tanginoa, Terepo, Loko, Williame etc. and develop them (Sutton, Merritt, Farrell, Champion, Tyrell, Peats, Luke etc.) Mix them in with a couple of older players like Fui, Reni etc. (Geddes, Stuart, Cusack etc.) and then every year try and get a marquee signing, Norman, the pommy forwards, Hoppa (G.I., Sam Burgess, Asotasi) and give the young guys time to develop and it will come good. Just have to keep the faith and everything ends up turning around.

Not all Souths fans are loud mouths, I hope it all turns around soon. I think next year you guys will probably be around the edge of the 8, just have to keep building.
Fantastic post mate, i think it will be the Bunnies year this year.
 

Maroubra Eel

Coach
Messages
19,044
Also, up until 2006 I went to just about every Eels game in NSW and Canberra.

I reckon I learn more watching on TV, which isn't to say there aren't some things you miss watching on TV.

But there's a reason the game gets such massive TV audiences and such relatively poor crowds. In a lot of ways it's better on TV.

That said, I will be in Sydney for the weekend of the next Manly game and I will be attending, because I do miss the atmosphere, even when we lose.

Maybe we can catch up at the game.
 

Gary Gutful

Post Whore
Messages
53,158
If we want to really know how the move to Wenty will affect Sandow then we need keep him there for more than 42 games.
 

84 Baby

Referee
Messages
29,946
I reckon it's a move like Stuart was planning with Kelepi. Keep him out of first grade to keep him fresh for the future
 

84 Baby

Referee
Messages
29,946
In all seriousness, comparing Sandow with Mullaney, they may play different positions and their overall abilities are chalk and cheese, but their broad strengths and weaknesses are almost identical. Essentially their size. So how does Mullaney keep his spot and Sandow loses his?
 

Twizzle

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
153,947
never been a fan but thats no secret

the only role I see him playing for us is as an impact player off the bench, he can run the ball OK and possible set up some plays from dummy half and his passing game is better than KK or Roberts

he is not a half back, he is not an organiser and doesn't strike me as an intelligent person who can read the play and organise a team

he is only capable of organising his own game and he does have a dash of speed off the mark

if we had to keep him, 14 is the only position I could see him with any future in the NRL, but hey thats just me
 

Chipmunk

Coach
Messages
17,415
never been a fan but thats no secret

the only role I see him playing for us is as an impact player off the bench, he can run the ball OK and possible set up some plays from dummy half and his passing game is better than KK or Roberts

he is not a half back, he is not an organiser and doesn't strike me as an intelligent person who can read the play and organise a team

he is only capable of organising his own game and he does have a dash of speed off the mark

if we had to keep him, 14 is the only position I could see him with any future in the NRL, but hey thats just me

I dont think I disagree with any of this.
 

Chipmunk

Coach
Messages
17,415
Sandow is very similar player to Denis Moran back 10 years ago.

Sandow probably has a bit more ability and creativity than Moran. If I recall though Moran could at least tackle a bit though to counteract that. They're certainly comparable players
 

Springs

First Grade
Messages
5,682
He has built a career off intercepts, chip-and-chases and shoulder charges. He hasn't got anything apart from that. Flashes of individual brilliance don't make a halfback.

I thought it was unbelievable how many people thought he was our saviour. How anyone thought a Roberts/Sandow halves combination would get us off the bottom is beyond me.
 

Latest posts

Top