Eels in the media

[Tooooks]

Kent reckons Marata should have been charged and suspended for breaking Brandon Smiths jaw...
——————————

The worry of involving only ex-players, and not somebody with a deeper understanding of the rules, revealed itself again this week when Parramatta’s Marata Niukore escaped suspension for breaking Brandon Smith’s jaw.

Match review co-ordinator Michael Robertson said the committee judged it a “front on, ball-and-all tackle” and that the injuries sustained were irrelevant to the lack of charge.

“We can elevate a charge based on injuries but we can’t charge on injuries itself,” he said, which is fair enough.

But it overlooked the most crucial aspect of the tackle.

It broke Smith’s jaw.

Too often the players err on the side of the players, at the omission of the rules.

If fracturing a jaw when the tackler’s shoulder comes into contact with the face of the ballrunner is not the definition of a “careless” high tackle, it is hard to imagine what it is.

The committee went through their checklist; no swinging arm, he wasn’t launching the shoulder, and the first point of contact, they believed, was simultaneous between shoulder and chest.

The ex-players applied all the logic of ex-players but missed the most vital part: Niukore’s shoulder came into contact with Smith’s face.

His head recoiled on impact and his jaw was broken and needed repair to the point Smith is now having dinner through a straw.

The damage speaks for itself.

It should not matter, in the case of a careless charge, whether contact was simultaneous.

https://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/s...s/news-story/7a49e82d723a9a98ec87dea7b1c97adb

He’s not wrong. Imagine if Marata’s jaw was broken when he was shoulder charged in the face. We’d all be livid.

 

[Soren Lorenson]

Did the fact that B Smith is a f**ken short arse get considered? Is a taller player supposed to crouch to tackle a shorter player so their heads line up? It was a nasty result, but shit, these things happen in RL.

 

[eels_fan]

He’s not wrong. Imagine if Marata’s jaw was broken when he was shoulder charged in the face. We’d all be livid.

Brandon Smith ran into Marata’s shoulder. His body position was open, his shoulders were back, not leading.

 

[84 Baby]

Did the fact that B Smith is a f**ken short arse get considered? Is a taller player supposed to crouch to tackle a shorter player so their heads line up? It was a nasty result, but shit, these things happen in RL.

Remember that time Kevans was suspended because he viciously chest bumped a player’s head

 

[T.S Quint]

they said on NRL360 (ie that show we all whinge about, but watch constantly), that some dude from the MRC said that tackle was the most thought about incident from the weekend ... but in the end they found that - there was arm separation so not a shoulder charge, no swinging arm, unclear if first contact was chest or shoulder

Personally, I think they then decided to whack Niukore with a crusher to some way make up for not charging him over that one

The fact that he wasn’t charged, NAS only escaped with a small fine and the Melbourne guys weren’t even cited for their crushers makes it seem like they are not taking head injuries as seriously as they should. It’s actually at the point where it’s the players staying down I’m after the tackle who are copping the abuse rather than the offenders themselves, which just seems wrong.

The Storm should also be in trouble for letting a player play on for two tackles after clearly being concussed (I can’t remember which player it was). The trains we came out, said “Nah, he’s right” but then stopped the play two tackles later, which killed all of our momentum.

 

[Soren Lorenson]

The Storm should also be in trouble for letting a player play on for two tackles after clearly being concussed (I can’t remember which player it was). The trains we came out, said “Nah, he’s right” but then stopped the play two tackles later, which killed all of our momentum.

It was Darren Schlong

 

[Poupou Escobar]

they said on NRL360 (ie that show we all whinge about, but watch constantly), that some dude from the MRC said that tackle was the most thought about incident from the weekend ... but in the end they found that - there was arm separation so not a shoulder charge, no swinging arm, unclear if first contact was chest or shoulder

Personally, I think they then decided to whack Niukore with a crusher to some way make up for not charging him over that one

I think they probably saw it as neither intentional nor careless, much like how a head clash isn't illegal (except when it's Napa doing it intentionally) but can do a lot of damage.

 

[84 Baby]

I reckon on the 2 high tackle instances, Marata’s was fineworthy and NAS should’ve got the suspension. One was lazy with a bit of bad luck for Bmith, the other was malicious and there was nothing Marata could do to protect himself. Even Gus said at the time we should get angry about it. You don’t get angry over a fair hit

 

[Poupou Escobar]

Yeah first point of contact was NAS's' shoulder and Niukore's head. It looked intentional.

 

[84 Baby]

Yeah first point of contact was NAS's' shoulder and Niukore's head. It looked intentional.

It could have been laziness on NASA’s part but there’s still a huge difference between a lazy swinging arm and a lazy head high shoulder “charge”

 

[Delboy]

Looked at the so called crusher that Nikore got charged on, was innocuous and probably less harmful than the Storm ones that were on report and escaped punishment.

Asofa Solamona was deliberate and dangerous and really strange it was a fine, no doubt Bellyaches rant was helpful. Pretty much Nikore got charged because they couldn’t find anything on the Smith tackle to fault him, and crushers are subjective. Storm are gifted at influencing the officials, upset they didn’t get anything in the game ( from the stands they were lucky to get away with heaps), without Cams reffing they were treated without favour, so Bellyache let rip to ensure next game it returns to normal.

Frustrating that the media hacks use the game to attack Parra, but really not unexpected, they will suck up Broncos and Storm given News Ltd interest and normal service will be resumed.

 

[Obscene Assassin]

I reckon on the 2 high tackle instances, Marata’s was fineworthy and NAS should’ve got the suspension. One was lazy with a bit of bad luck for Bmith, the other was malicious and there was nothing Marata could do to protect himself. Even Gus said at the time we should get angry about it. You don’t get angry over a fair hit

Christian Welch can consider himself lucky, with NAS trying to take off Marata's head his high shot on Marata (in the same tackle) has gone completely unnoticed. Deserved a penalty and to go on report and a fine.

 

[emjaycee]

He’s not wrong. Imagine if Marata’s jaw was broken when he was shoulder charged in the face. We’d all be livid.

We'd be livid if the shoulder charge was not reported or there was no citing.
Marata didn't shoulder charge BSmith.

 

[Joshuatheeel]

The crow, still a very good country coach:



has won a few comps over the last few years and is constantly “rebuilding” his side.

 

[Gary Gutful]

Is there really a team called the Warilla Gorillas?

 

[Joshuatheeel]

Is there really a team called the Warilla Gorillas?

Yep, definitely is, in group 7, same comp as gerringong.

Most famous juniors are David Boyle and Beau Henry.

 

[Gronk]

Door ajar for Parra pair to stay with Warriors into finals series https://www.nrl.com/news/2020/09/08...air-to-stay-with-warriors-into-finals-series/

 

[Noise]

Door ajar for Parra pair to stay with Warriors into finals series https://www.nrl.com/news/2020/09/08...air-to-stay-with-warriors-into-finals-series/

As long as they can't play against us if we face them in the finals.

 

[Eelementary]

https://www.liverpoolchampion.com.a...ve-mahoney-a-chance-to-play-penrith/?cs=12826

 

[Eelementary]

Reed Mahoney a chance to play on Friday night. Article above.