What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Eels' inquiry into alleged attempt to fix election

Joshuatheeel

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
20,152
. Bill Moss, the former Macquarie Bank high flyer whose nomination as an independent to the Parramatta board was shot down in flames, says the vote-rigging revelations encircling the Eels "makes you wonder what else has been going on" at the club.

The Parramatta Leagues Club and NRL board convened for an unscheduled meeting on Friday, the day the Herald published claims linking former chairman Roy Spagnolo and former group chief executive Bob Bentley to the fraudulent issuing of memberships in the lead-up to last year's club elections.

It has also emerged that other former directors are also under the microscope of an Office of Liquor, Gaming and Racing investigation over allegations of activity, unrelated to the membership tampering scheme, that contravenes the Registered Clubs Act and the Clubs NSW code of practice.

Advertisement

The findings of that inquiry could result in the ex-directors not only facing possible sanctions from the industry regulator but disciplinary action from Parramatta that could extend to them being expelled from the club.

Moss, a financial heavyweight and ardent Parramatta supporter who was snubbed by Eels members at the club's annual general meeting in May, said the uncovering of widespread backdating of memberships in the weeks before last year's election helped explain the farcical events of the AGM.

The elevation of a figure of Moss' calibre to the board had seemed a no-brainer but the resolution for an independent director to be added to the Parramatta board, an initiative of chairman Steve Sharp, fell victim to factional opposition not to mention heckling. Extraordinarily, even a bid to introduce a code of conduct for directors bit the dust.

With at least 46 unauthorised members in the room that night — many of them unfamiliar faces not seen before at the club — and 75 per cent approval needed for resolutions to pass, Sharp did not have the numbers.

"It probably does explain a lot of the AGM, although to prove that you'd have to match who turned up at the AGM and is it these people and how many of them and how many voted? But it could well explain the events of the AGM," Moss said. "I've never known a code of conduct to be voted down

"It's disappointing. When you see this going on, it makes you wonder what else has been going on."

The gamesmanship behind the scenes has continued at Parramatta this week, with the laughable scenario of Sharp's PLC and NRL board and Spagnolo's Parramatta District Rugby League board jostling to have a meeting before one another.

Friday's PLC get-together was originally set down for next Wednesday but was brought forward this week when Spagnolo fast-tracked the next meeting of the body he chairs from late next week to next Monday.

The reason for the race to sit first was believed to be Spagnolo's desire to nominate PDRL director and ally Lyn Wallace to the more prominent PLC board as soon as possible, a move that complies with the club's complicated constitution. With another month now until the next meeting of PLC directors sources say Wallace's ascension could come unstuck if, as is being anticipated, OLGR chooses to file a complaint against the Eels' former administration in the coming weeks.

It is a messy situation that Moss believes can be alleviated in the long run by Sharp's push for constitutional reform at the Eels.

"He is actually someone who is trying to reform the club both on and off the field," Moss said. "He's the guy that's been pushing for an independent director and a code of conduct and this is just showing that where he's been pushing is where the club should go."

http://m.smh.com.au/rugby-league/pa...matta-eels-agm-bill-moss-20140912-10g3nw.html
 

Chipmunk

Coach
Messages
17,365
So just a quick question here, the Parramatta District Club gets to appoint 4 members to the board, is this correct?

And it's highly likely that the NRL will be insisting that 3 independent directors will be appointed at the next AGM.

So, will this mean that the Leagues Club will eventually have an AGM and not be able to appoint anyone to its own board???
 

Avenger

Immortal
Messages
33,952
The constitution was made messy to keep a certain person in power for too long. Bit like Putin going from the KGB head to Prime Minister to President. Fitzy needed to go, but guido here just makes me want to scream.

Article%20Lead%20-%20narrow6119339010fqyt1410456119480.jpg-300x0.jpg
 

bartman

Immortal
Messages
41,022
I think its the other way around under the constitution, a rule that 3 of the 7 directors of the Football club have to be serving as elected directors of the Leagues club? There's a bit of a stalemate because Spagnolos mob still hold the numbers on the Fooball club board, and there aren't enough common directors of both to have three that satisfy the rule (because Spagnolo's colleagues that did get elected on the League club board seem to keep resigning).

Hopefully the NRL get involved, and end the farce that is the special relationsip between the two Boards. Reform the constitution, get us professional, and nomimate some independent and skilled directors. A Leagues club election for some directors will still happen, and given the potential for OLGR punishments for ex-directors might wipe out Spagnolo's foothold on the Football club Board - maybe we can finally move toward having it all combined under the one umbrella?
 

bartman

Immortal
Messages
41,022
I for one am glad all the avid 3P cheerleaders from back in the day have essentially abonded these forums through shame....
 

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
http://email.mmr.com.au/t/ViewEmail...EF23F30FEDED/492A7C3ED01935821C65CA3F48968C2E

Statement from the Parramatta Leagues Club Group

Dear Members,

It's unfortunate that I have to write to you today in this fashion after such a wonderful season on and off the field in 2014, but it's important to us that Members of the Parramatta Eels football club are informed directly of any important issues.

The Board of the Parramatta Leagues Club (PLC), which owns the Parramatta National Rugby League (PNRL), has moved to address serious allegations of membership and election tampering of both the PLC Election in 2013 and the Parramatta District Rugby League Election (PDRL) in 2012.

On Friday, the Board of the PLC issued two resolutions at a Board meeting in Parramatta.

The first resolution involved the forming of a disciplinary committee which will investigate the allegations made on Friday regarding membership tampering. Members who are alleged to have been involved in the tampering will be asked to appear in front of the PLC Board to explain their actions.

In addition, the disciplinary committee will be asked to investigate new evidence tabled at the PLC Board meeting regarding the intimidation, bullying and harassment of former directors, PLC staff and PLC members. The investigation has found evidence that indicates that this behaviour was carried out with the knowledge of the previous PLC Board of Directors and the previous CEO.

The second resolution at Friday's PLC Board meeting was to request that Mr Roy Spagnolo OAM stand down from the PDRL, effective immediately, pending the outcome of the multiple investigations.

The membership tampering before the PLC election in 2013 is also currently part of a wider investigation into the former administration by the Office of Liquor, Gaming and Racing (OLGR).

The Board will do everything we can to ensure that our club will be managed with a commitment to openness and integrity and for the benefit of Members not individuals.

That's my commitment and I urge everyone who shares this vision to join me in ushering in a new era of stability and professionalism for this great club. We have made some great strides in 2014 and we intend to continue on this path in 2015.

Regards,

Steve Sharp
 
Messages
17,642
"The Board will do everything we can to ensure that our club will be managed with a commitment to openness and integrity and for the benefit of Members not individuals."

The only solution is to let the NRL take over in its entirety. That's the only way to move forward. Neutral board!!
 

Latest posts

Top