What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Eels Next Coach

Who will be Eels Next Coach

  • Hannay

    Votes: 30 29.4%
  • Hollbrook

    Votes: 12 11.8%
  • Ryles

    Votes: 33 32.4%
  • Morris

    Votes: 5 4.9%
  • Cheika

    Votes: 22 21.6%

  • Total voters
    102
  • Poll closed .
Messages
11,824
Probably good to have Brian Smith (or someone like him) around for two years in a HOF role, to support any appointment of a debutante assistant as our head coach...

That's presuming the Board isn't as dumb as it seems, and they have seen the need to get rid of both Arthur and O'Neill for the club to improve from where things are currently at.
 

JokerEel

Coach
Messages
13,425
This was not supposed to be prophecy.



Veteran coach Brian Smith has made a shock pitch to return as head coach of Parramatta.
Smith, who coached the Eels on 243 occasions between 1997 and 2006, feels he has unfinished business. The 70-year-old joined Josh Hannay, Jason Ryles, Dean Young and Trent Barrett in attempting to become the long-term replacement for Brad Arthur.


Given that former Bulldogs and Sea Eagles head coach Barrett is expected to be overlooked, the three rookies were expected to contest the post. However, this masthead can reveal that Smith secretly entered the mix, providing Parramatta powerbrokers with a point of difference in their search.
Smith, the third-most experienced NRL coach in history with 601 appearances, was keen to add to the tally. Still a respected figure after his service to the club, he was given the opportunity to present his vision for Parramatta’s future.

The former Steelers, Dragons, Eels, Knights and Roosters mentor felt he could get the best out of the current side, which sits in last position. In a lengthy meeting with Parramatta powerbrokers, he outlined his blueprint, which included bringing the club’s former physical performance manager, Hayden Knowles, back into the fold.
Only last year, Arthur surpassed Smith as Parramatta’s most-capped coach. At the time, Smith told this masthead: “Fantastic; that’s great for him. Any coach that goes that distance with one club, it’s an outstanding achievement.”
Brian Smith during his Parramatta coaching days.

Brian Smith during his Parramatta coaching days.CREDIT:FAIRFAX

During that interview, he also reflected about his own experiences at the club, stating: “You go through some phases with that, with the expectation. Traditionally, Parramatta has been a club with a lot of resources and I was excited with my opportunity when I went there. It was a great opportunity and I loved it most of the time.”
Smith still has a burning desire to win a premiership, the one prize that has eluded him throughout his career. He oversaw grand final appearances with the Dragons in 1992 and 1993 and the Roosters in 2010, but the biggest lament was an Eels defeat in the “unloseable” 2001 decider.

Advertisement

A successful return to Parramatta would allow Smith to reclaim the mantle as Parramatta’s most-capped coach. However, sources with knowledge of the situation, not authorised to speak publicly, have told this masthead that club officials are poised to overlook Smith.
While Smith is held in high regard for all that he achieved during his decade in charge of the club, Arthur’s long-time successor will be one of Ryles, Hanny and Young.
Brian Smith consoles his Eels players after their loss to Newcastle in the 2001 grand final.

Brian Smith consoles his Eels players after their loss to Newcastle in the 2001 grand final.CREDIT:STEVE CHRISTO

While there was an expectation that the successful candidate would be informed immediately after Thursday’s clash against South Sydney, a final decision could still be up to a week away.
The Eels are continuing to do their due diligence on the contenders. Zac Lomax, like the current members of the squad, is eager to know who will be appointed, but there is no suggestion that he won’t honour his Parramatta contract.

Eels chief executive Jim Sarantinos addressed the team’s underperformance – and the coaching situation – in a recent letter to members.
“Our NRL on-field performance this season has been disappointing and well below expectations,” Sarantinos said.
“We know it’s not what you expect from us, and it’s certainly not what we expect from ourselves. We understand your disappointment, and we share it.
“I can assure you that the current coaches and playing group are committed to turning things around. They’re putting in the hard yards at training, and their desire to win is undeniable …

“We’re currently in the midst of a comprehensive process to appoint a new head coach. This is a critical appointment, and we’re taking the time to ensure we appoint the right person – someone who embodies our values, will establish the right culture and can lead our football program into a new era.”


Let Smith coach the Rest of the season just so he can knock BA off for the most capped coach 😂
 

Hindmarshisgod2

Juniors
Messages
1,427
If the club had half a brain, they'd get Smith involved in some capacity....I'd prefer head coach buti know it won't happen, at least have him involved in identifying juniors or something along those lines... the guy is on Bennett level for mine...he just has an eye for the game that cannot be learnt...

But I know we won't, and I know we'll end up with some rookie coach and relive the Kearney years...
 
Messages
15,497
If the club had half a brain, they'd get Smith involved in some capacity....I'd prefer head coach buti know it won't happen, at least have him involved in identifying juniors or something along those lines... the guy is on Bennett level for mine...he just has an eye for the game that cannot be learnt...

But I know we won't, and I know we'll end up with some rookie coach and relive the Kearney years...

Getting Brian Smith involved in pathways and development for Parramatta would be a step in the right direction. He certainly does know how to develop players (on the whole).
 

eels_fan

First Grade
Messages
7,584
The talk/rumour amongst some in the media is that Hannay will be announced but only as a 1 year deal.

If that’s the case, anyone involved in the decision should be pushed off the leagues club roof, as we won’t sign or re-sign a single player
 

84 Baby

Referee
Messages
29,749
Yeah I’d try to get him more as Caylo’s replacement. Get him developing the likes of Talagi, Guymer & Mrthur
 
Messages
11,824
Yeah I’d try to get him more as Caylo’s replacement. Get him developing the likes of Talagi, Guymer & Mrthur
Talagi had a chance to lock in (or negotiate) an Eels deal for 2025, and hasn't taken it... and Matt Arthur might be tempted by any offers for an early release just like his brother.

So that only potentially leaves Guymer to be developed!
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,719
The talk/rumour amongst some in the media is that Hannay will be announced but only as a 1 year deal.

If that’s the case, anyone involved in the decision should be pushed off the leagues club roof, as we won’t sign or re-sign a single player
LOL as if.
 
Top