Eels Next Coach

[chiefy1]

Noise is right - they are dinosaurs.

Another disrespectful clown

 

[King-Gutho94]

Madge has been an utter failure since the 2014 GF more then what BA was.

59 wins from 153 games at 38%. For zero finals wins.

Madge got a squad gift wrapped to him before he arrived with Sam Burgess, Issac Luke and Greg Inglis already there. Adam Reynolds came in at the right time thanks to us poaching Sandow.

He had Shane Richardson as the HOF.

That squad at Souths between 2012-2014 should have won a comp they butchered it in 2013 when they leading a busted Manly 14-0 after 10 mins in a preliminary final and got flogged.

They got to play a weak arse Bulldogs side who came 7th and only winning 13 games in a GF.

Within 3 years of winning a premiership he lost the playing group and had to be sacked after missing finals 2 years in a row.

Anthony Seibold of all people came in and took the same squad in 2018 to a preliminary final. Hence why he got the massive offer to join Brisbane.

Then the Tigers debacle cleary may have left them in a mess but Madge just dug them further.

Madge was the peanut who thought signing the Joey and Luicano Leilua on massive money in 2020

Yeah that ended well for the tigers.

He re-signed Nofaluma and Brooks on massive coin as well long after Cleary left in 2018.

Yeah let's go get another BA 2.0.

The only difference I see between the two are one had the luxury of coaching 2 Hall of famers in Burgess and Inglis and the other didn't.

 

[Noise]

Wow, that's f**king disrespectful mate. Who the f**k are you to be above those legends of the club ?
I've always respected you noise, but this type of comment isn't on, even if it is to support your views.

They are legends of the club. But the last thing we need is to take advice from 80s footy players, particularly when they want a guy who hasn’t won a finals match since 2014 and been fired twice in 8 years

 

[chiefy1]

They are legends of the club. But the last thing we need is to take advice from 80s footy players, particularly when they want a guy who hasn’t won a finals match since 2014 and been fired twice in 8 years

This site has been brainwashed by pau pau escobar lol

 

[Twizzle]

https://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sport/nrl/nrl-2024-parramatta-legends-of-1980s-unite-in-push-for-michael-maguire-to-be-next-eels-coach/news-story/659f6f575d73d26eaf91dad0d5a39fb9?amp

I've already said twice, provide a credible link and I'll add the options, so maybe try reading instead of whinging

 

[JokerEel]

Don't forget, Maguire took over the Tigers after the massive exodus of Tedesco, Moses and others and still managed to finish 9th, and only 1 point out of the finals with a - 11 for and against. The club needed a complete rebuild but Madge still did an very good job to only just miss the 8.
Nobody has since finished higher with the Tigers so go figure boys.
Even Cleary couldn't do better in his time at the Tigers and had Moses and Teddy in his team. Wake up to yourselves everyone! Pou pau little ba boy. Wake up....


At least once Maguire makes the finals he doesn't flop like the bush coach. Maguire has a 56% win rate as opposed to the bushie 4 from 12 at 33%. Brad is a conman when it comes to capitalising in the finals arena

Before you post anything on Maguire, do your research.

Man I just answered the question after I did my research

 

[Noise]

This site has been brainwashed by pau pau escobar lol

I reckon Pou probably wants Madge simply because most people here don’t.

 

[JokerEel]

I reckon Pou probably wants Madge simply because most people here don’t.

@Poupou Escobar who do you want as our next coach???

 

[King-Gutho94]

@Poupou Escobar who do you want as our next coach???

Whatever is the less popular opinion

 

[Poupou Escobar]

People who want Cheika are trolls
They want the club to fail.

Everyone who disagrees with me is a troll.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

Noise is right - they are dinosaurs.

They are dinosaurs but head coaching is about humans, and they haven't changed since the eighties.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

Madge has been an utter failure since the 2014 GF more then what BA was.

59 wins from 153 games at 38%. For zero finals wins.

Madge got a squad gift wrapped to him before he arrived with Sam Burgess, Issac Luke and Greg Inglis already there. Adam Reynolds came in at the right time thanks to us poaching Sandow.

He had Shane Richardson as the HOF.

That squad at Souths between 2012-2014 should have won a comp they butchered it in 2013 when they leading a busted Manly 14-0 after 10 mins in a preliminary final and got flogged.

They got to play a weak arse Bulldogs side who came 7th and only winning 13 games in a GF.

Within 3 years of winning a premiership he lost the playing group and had to be sacked after missing finals 2 years in a row.

Anthony Seibold of all people came in and took the same squad in 2018 to a preliminary final. Hence why he got the massive offer to join Brisbane.

Then the Tigers debacle cleary may have left them in a mess but Madge just dug them further.

Madge was the peanut who thought signing the Joey and Luicano Leilua on massive money in 2020

Yeah that ended well for the tigers.

He re-signed Nofaluma and Brooks on massive coin as well long after Cleary left in 2018.

Yeah let's go get another BA 2.0.

The only difference I see between the two are one had the luxury of coaching 2 Hall of famers in Burgess and Inglis and the other didn't.

All this just supports the fact that coaching is only part of the puzzle, and Maguire is a good enough at that part.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

I reckon Pou probably wants Madge simply because most people here don’t.

I don't want Maguire, I just take issue with the idea that he's not a realistic option.

 

[Poupou Escobar]

@Poupou Escobar who do you want as our next coach???

I already said I don't know enough to make that call. Just like the rest of you. I'm probably leaning toward Holbrook, but he did get sacked for a reason. Whatever that is.

 

[Pazza]

I already said I don't know enough to make that call. Just like the rest of you. I'm probably leaning toward Holbrook, but he did get sacked for a reason. Whatever that is.

what ever happened to holbrook... it wasnt his fault

 

[Noise]

I don't want Maguire, I just take issue with the idea that he's not a realistic option.

Oh he’s definitely a realistic option. I just don’t like that option.

I’ll be happy with Cheika, Hannay or Holbrook (prob in that order).

 

[Wally21]

I already said I don't know enough to make that call. Just like the rest of you. I'm probably leaning toward Holbrook, but he did get sacked for a reason. Whatever that is.

No one is asking you what the right call is, we are merely stating opinions. What’s your opinion on next coach??

 

[King-Gutho94]

All this just supports the fact that coaching is only part of the puzzle, and Maguire is a good enough at that part.

He is a decent coach but I just don't feel what we need right now is someone like him.

He is too similar to BA.

I think rep coaching are more his style anyway which he is doing now.

His intensity for a short period of time to get the best out of a talented squad in a short span is ideal.

His last 2 club stints have worn the players out pretty quickly.

At rep level 10 day camps for 3 weeks is ideal for a Madge type coach.

Plus what happens if NSW win origin the NSWRL would want madge locked in long term anyway.

If NSW lose his credibility and credentials take another hit especially if it was known he was talking to us throughout the series.

We can't be waiting to end of July and still yet to name a coach.

That's just madness.

 

[Delboy]

Looking at the prospects for coach, don’t have a real reason but think Josh Hannay would do a pretty decent job. Been around a coup” elf clubs and the Maroons, plus he seems pretty switched on.

Anyway, not sure what we will end up with given the mercurial HOF is part of the process, and he can’t even get our own recognised juniors to sign or extend.

 

[Tmars]

OMENRLWORLD-CUP

‘Never seen it before’: Moses’ big praise as ‘unbelievable’ Cheika considers NRL role​

HUDDERSFIELD, ENGLAND - NOVEMBER 04: Lebanon coach Michael Cheika and Mitchell Moses of Lebanon chat to media following the Rugby League World Cup Quarter Final match between Australia and Lebanon at John Smith's Stadium on November 04, 2022 in Huddersfield, England. (Photo by Jan Kruger/Getty Images for RLWC)Source: Getty Images

Mark St John from Fox Sports@markdfstjohn
November 5th, 2022 3:07 pm
Lebanon skipper Mitchell Moses has backed coach Michael Cheika to thrive in the NRL if he chooses that career path after his side’s 48-4 World Cup exit at the hands of the Kangaroos.
They may have been comprehensively beaten, but Moses praised Cheika for getting his Lebanon players up for the fight of their lives against a formidable opponent in Australia.
“He was unbelievable,” Moses said.
Watch every match of the Rugby League World Cup LIVE & Exclusive to Fox Sports, on Kayo. New to Kayo? Start your free trial now >


“The way he can get you up for a game, I’ve never seen it before to be honest.


“You hear about all the stories about how he gets teams up for games and I witnessed it first-hand and loved working under him.
“I think he has got a big future in the NRL if he wants a go at it. I think he could definitely coach a team one day if he sticks at it and if he wants to I guess.
“I definitely got a lot out of that and I think if you speak to anyone in the camp they will definitely agree with me.
Greg Alexander has no doubt Cheika could succeed as a full-time NRL coach.
“He said he wouldn’t be surprised if Michael Cheika wanted to coach in the NRL that he could handle it,” Alexander said.