God-King Dean
Immortal
- Messages
- 46,614
Look at the ladder boys:
1. St George Illawarra
March premiers.
There's no pleasing some people.
1. St George Illawarra
March premiers.
There's no pleasing some people.
Look at the ladder boys:
1. St George Illawarra
March premiers.
There's no pleasing some people.
On a plus note, some of Quinlan's passes were pin point and very easy to catch. There was a cut out pass he threw that had number 7 written all over it, he could possibly make the switch if needed.
Has anyone noticed Quinlan's body language on the field ? He's like Mr. Casual, he does a run and gets up from the tackle with this bored look on his face or overruns a play ( backing up but no off-load ) then runs back onside with that same bored look. It's very disconcerting, very hard to remain calm about his apparent calmness.
Anyway we haven't played too well for the last 2 weeks so these are my coaching tips.
Make Widdop co - captain. On field Creagh runs the show in defence, he barks out the orders and the boys do what he says. Widdop controls the attack, including keeping Williams in line. At this stage Williams is too inexperienced to be given free reign. You don't want to stifle the kid completely but until he learns the importance of field position and maintaining momentum he needs to let his dance partner, Widdop lead ( the same way Cronk lead Widdop at the Storm ).
Forwards.
Our bench sucks. New bench - Stockwell or Cooper,Ah Mau, Harrison plus a utility be that Quinlan, Witt or god help us, Style.
Gives us a bit of size and power off the bench. Harrison has been overlooked but I think he's perfectly suited to the new rules, he has great line speed, defends well and his backing up is almost as good as Quinlan or Nightie's.
Starting pack - Frizell, Rein, Hunt up front, Creagh, Thompson, Merrin in the back row. We have to start well and adding Thompson can give us a bit more aggression early on.
Harsh reality - it might be hard to make room for Quin when Duges comes back. If you do put him on the bench it can't be as a second hooker so other option is Witt to 7 to be moved to 9 when Quin comes on ( to 7 ).
Yes, presumably Dugan will be back next week so for Quinlan it'll be more a question of where he can be slotted in if selected. He can play anywhere in the backline. I don't think he should be dropped if it can be avoided.
When is Witt coming back? Williams' position under threat from Witt (and perhaps even Quinlan).
Stanley is too slow at dummy half. I feel he cost us a lot of go forward on Friday night. Rein is the man for the job but it is the habit of modern coaches and the interchange to have two hookers. Maybe Witt can fill that role.
Rein's turnaround in form has been very good to see. Plus he did a truckload of tackles on the goal in the first 20 minutes, saved us being further behind imo.
My recollection is we resigned Quinlan late last year for a further 2 seasons and I believe we will find a place for him this year. Duges will be back this week and I expect Quinlan to go to the bench and Kyle to Cutters, Williams will be given another week.
I am sure at some point Quinlan will get a shot at 7. It might very well be if Witt gets another shot at 7 and moves to 9 to give Rein a breather and Quinlan comes on at half. IMO he will bea relevation at half.
The break he made which included a great pass inside then getting back off the ground to take the ball 2 passes later was special and really should be counted as a try assist. Hopefully that will give him some confidence to hit the line at pace, doesn't need to smash into them just step toward a hole
Just re Quinlan, he had one average game.
He plays above his weight, and in a most difficult position.
There will be a space for him on the 17.
I would worry more about his effort than his apparent "calm" demeanour.
He is a valuable asset.
I'm always perplexed when players decide to sit back and refuse to meet the attack in defence. Every bloody person with knowledge about the game knows that it never works, yet teams still always fall into it? The Broncos weren't that particularly brilliant that it kind of made us do so, it was just that we were defensively shit house. Amazes me how a team just decides to forget how to defend after 3 years of quality brick-laying under Bennett. Defence is all about attitude and commitment.
Ruck defense is an area that we need to address pretty quick smart. I can cope with it for the moment because no doubt learning how to attack again has been a main focal point for us for late. If we can get the defense right again, we can be a force in this comp. Need time though.
Ideally I would want Quinlan in the 17, I was just wondering how best to juggle the roster to fit him in. I'd much rather him on the bench than Kyle. And I'm only kidding about his calm demeanor, I think it's just a quirk of his and was wondering if anyone else noticed.
Can you really coach defence tho? Tackling and defensive alignment isn't that complex really, it's all about attitude and fitness isn't it?
Attack yes, it's all about practice and repetition and we've definitely seen improvement there. The players just need to have their minds on the job to stop teams just running through them.
Can you really coach defence tho? Tackling and defensive alignment isn't that complex really, it's all about attitude and fitness isn't it?
Attack yes, it's all about practice and repetition and we've definitely seen improvement there. The players just need to have their minds on the job to stop teams just running through them.
Definitley...You can coach a team how to mark your man, defend in a line and as a team and come up in defence. It's no fluke we had the best defence under Bennett