forevermakingthreadafterthread

[Rabbits20]

I didn't want him in the side? Yes your right.

I'm not a fan of Goodwin too. But who did I name as our best on Friday night?

Farah didn't deliver plan and simple. He did well in the CS but this game I thought he would of changed my opinion on him but he went missing.

I think you're a bit harsh on Farah.

 

[Rsag85]

He's better than Kelly there.

Kelly has zero creativity and a poor kicking game.

Farah has creativity and his kicking game at least finds the grass and not constantly down the throat of the FB.

Why not give the young kid from the Bears a run at halfback

 

[Rsag85]

I think you're a bit harsh on Farah.

Your being way to harsh on Turner.

 

[Rsag85]

See.

I was heated after the game but saw the game again and I made my judgement.

 

[Rabbit toes]

Let's drop the guy (who's a centre NOT a forward ) that made the most metres for Souths. #sheenius

 

[DiegoNT]

No mass changes. We had injuries that made us completely shuffle our side, and senior players frankly didn't stand up when needed. If we don't have that re shuffle and those senior players lift we will be more competive. We rely on our centres and wingers to help start the go forward. We lost a centre to injury and a winger to cover fullback. For 65 minutes we basically played with no winger. Talaki helped out immensely. But in that middle part of the game our senior back in Goodwin had to really stand up and he didn't. Sure he got a few consolation tries towards the end, but when the game was still alive we needed him to step up he didn't. Sutton also didn't come alive until the game was dead. Sam Burgess was a let down. People avoid the criticism but it has to be said. Many in here point at Clark and tyrrell, but they were more productive then Sam. Tyrell played 35 minutes, made 80m and 20 tackles, Clark played 35 minutes and made 80m 33 odd tackles, Sam played 71 minutes and made 105m 30 tackles with 5 misses. Productivity wise Clark and Tyrrell did more work per minute. Considering they replace each other the Clark/tyrrell combo made 160m and 50 tackles compared to Sam making 105m and 30 tackles with 5 misses in the same amount of time.
Turner played out of position and had to cover for inglis, you cannot drop a player for those circumstances. Musgrove was great. Tom missed a lot of tackles, for all the shit tyrrell and clark receive the are never going to miss 6 tackles in the middle.

 

[DiegoNT]

A pack tweak may be needed. Chricton fired in reserves, tom fizzled in 1sts Rochow is perhaps unsuited to a bench role, Sam's impact was stifled

8. Tyrell
9. Farah
10. Sam
11. Turner
12. Sutton
13. Rochow

14. Cook
15. Chricton
16. Musgrove
17. Clark

 

[Rabbit toes]

A pack tweak may be needed. Chricton fired in reserves, tom fizzled in 1sts Rochow is perhaps unsuited to a bench role, Sam's impact was stifled

8. Tyrell
9. Farah
10. Sam
11. Turner
12. Sutton
13. Rochow

14. Cook
15. Chricton
16. Musgrove
17. Clark

I've said it before but I hate seeing Sam as battering ram prop. And rochow is no where near ready for starting lock.

What about musgrove starts. Sam to lock. Chricton starts Sutton to bench. Rochow out and cherrington in?

 

[Rabbits20]

Oi Shadow I've been laughing a lot and nearly spat my lunch out.

I rang a couple of mates too.

I can't stop laughing at the best value in our side is Tyrrell and Clark.

Thanks for giving me the best medicine Diego that is laughter!!!!

 

[Rabbits20]

Goodwin did stand up. He couldn't do much more tbh.

Keep playing the ones not up to it and our opposition are laughing!!!

 

[Rabbits20]

Why not give the young kid from the Bears a run at halfback

I don't think Levido is up to it either.

He didn't do much in our trial against Manly.

 

[Rabbits20]

Your being way to harsh on Turner.

not at all.

Ask alien, I'm sure he knows.

 

[DiegoNT]

I've said it before but I hate seeing Sam as battering ram prop. And rochow is no where near ready for starting lock.

What about musgrove starts. Sam to lock. Chricton starts Sutton to bench. Rochow out and cherrington in?

Sam plays no differently at 8 or 13. Only difference is that at 13 he is expected to play 80 minutes while at 8 he can excused to come off and have a breather

 

[Rabbits20]

Sam plays no differently at 8 or 13. Only difference is that at 13 he is expected to play 80 minutes while at 8 he can excused to come off and have a breather

Sam has more opportunity to roam at 13 and he can run wider.

We have had this discussion before and I'm not going through it again.

 

[Rabbit toes]

Sam has more opportunity to roam at 13 and he can run wider.

We have had this discussion before and I'm not going through it again.

No one asked you to

 

[rabbitohs95]

IMO we should sign Matt Scott. We need another forward leader Sam can't do it all himself. We need a bloke to mentor the twins and Musgrove.

 

[DiegoNT]

IMO we should sign Matt Scott. We need another forward leader Sam can't do it all himself. We need a bloke to mentor the twins and Musgrove.

Def don't need Scott. Isn't getting any younger, won't come cheap, already paying to much for middle forwards.

We've gone in a direction after our premiership and it hasn't worked. We can't keep going in that direction.

 

[foreverinourshadow]

IMO we should sign Matt Scott. We need another forward leader Sam can't do it all himself. We need a bloke to mentor the twins and Musgrove.

good to see r95 has his thinking cap on and does not want mediocrity.....Shadow...

 

[foreverinourshadow]

Def don't need Scott. Isn't getting any younger, won't come cheap, already paying to much for middle forwards.

We've gone in a direction after our premiership and it hasn't worked. We can't keep going in that direction.

i prefer matt scott over tyrrell or clark and turner at least scott has been a far better performer than the 3 ive mentioned and what about goodwin he is getting long in the tooth just like matt scott is but id take goodwin and scott over a combined clark,tyrrell.and turner any day of the week or year or decade just ask r20 he knows i am correctamundo.......Shadow....

 

[foreverinourshadow]

Def don't need Scott. Isn't getting any younger, won't come cheap, already paying to much for middle forwards.

We've gone in a direction after our premiership and it hasn't worked. We can't keep going in that direction.

so whats the answer diego any ideas?or do we stay with what we have already?it seems many on here want to stick with tyrrell and clark and turner im telling you its mediocrity to have these 3 in our top 17 week in and week out its a joke and i am sure the top teams are giggling behind our backs how mediocrity souths have been since 2014...i want a top 4 finish not a lower 8 finish....Shadow...Your asleep at the wheel souths....wake up....