forevermakingthreadafterthread

[Rabbits20]

Cook looked better with that same poor pack

As I said I'd put Farah at half and play Cook at hooker!!!

 

[Rabbits20]

Copy and paste


It's annoying I know. Let's look at the facts of round 1. 6 try's to 4. Hunt goes off and doesn't return, Gi gets injured during the match. Down to 2 players on the bench for the back end of the game. Reynolds wasn't playing. Only one try was turned into six points. Missing George as well.

Massive clean out? Some people have no idea what there talking about.

Well we will see who's right as the season progresses.

There are some who clearly don't cut it anymore.

I stand by my views.

 

[Rabbits20]

Lol can't dish things out then not expect to get it back. Life lesson

Alien didn't dish it out.

I'll always stick up for alien!!!

 

[Rsag85]

Turner still shouldn't be missing crucial tackles arm slapping!!! He looked pedestrian.

Turner also didn't run with any venom. He struggles to break the line.

Talakai I really like but imo he's not a centre. He's not quick enough and he is a turnstile defensively. Didn't you see all the defensive mistakes he made in the CS and the other night???? Talakai would be best used off the bench to make some charges.

Dylan Walker will run rings around him if he's picked next week.

If your going to pin point any one what about Farah who didn't deliver against his former club?
17 players out there not just two or three you keep singling out

 

[Rsag85]

Well we will see who's right as the season progresses.

There are some who clearly don't cut it anymore.

I stand by my views.

What I said was true or false??

 

[Rabbits20]

i know one thing for sure george burgess will be playing in rd2......how plain dumb to leave him out in rd1....souths and madge have lost the plot no contest.........oi madge use my team and r20"s team in rd2 and you might go well mate for crikes sake.....Shadow...

I don't think Madge will pick George unfortunately. Apparently he was poor for Norths yesterday too.

I think Madge will pick Clark over George.

 

[Rsag85]

As I said I'd put Farah at half and play Cook at hooker!!!

I don't if he will deliver in that role as well

 

[Rabbits20]

If your going to pin point any one what about Farah who didn't deliver against his former club?
17 players out there not just two or three you keep singling out

Farah tried his arse off. He doesn't have the speed Cook has though but he makes up for it with his good kicking game and crafty play around the ruck.

Cook should have come on much earlier though, not when the game was over.

It's obvious you hate Farah. Let's be honest he was still in our best 5 players.

 

[Rabbits20]

I don't if he will deliver in that role as well

He's better than Kelly there.

Kelly has zero creativity and a poor kicking game.

Farah has creativity and his kicking game at least finds the grass and not constantly down the throat of the FB.

 

[Rsag85]

He's better than Kelly there.

Kelly has zero creativity and a poor kicking game.

Farah has creativity and his kicking game at least finds the grass and not constantly down the throat of the FB.

That's why you have walker and Sutto doing the main part of the kicking

 

[Rabbits20]

What I said was true or false??

You made some reasonable points there but I feel the likes of Kelly, Tyrrell, Clark, Turner aren't up to it and Talakai should be used in the back row off the bench.

 

[Rabbits20]

That's why you have walker and Sutto doing the main part of the kicking

But that didn't happen the other night did it???? I know what I saw.

Drop your Farah hatred from blinding what should happen.

Kelly is a liability and not a first grader. Parra are laughing at us right now. Brown for Kelly!!! I know who won there.

 

[Rsag85]

You made some reasonable points there but I feel the likes of Kelly, Tyrrell, Clark, Turner aren't up to it and Talakai should be used in the back row off the bench.

 

[Rsag85]

But that didn't happen the other night did it???? I know what I saw.

Drop your Farah hatred from blinding what should happen.

Kelly is a liability and not a first grader. Parra are laughing at us right now. Brown for Kelly!!! I know who won there.

Drop my Farah hatred? Really you have been putting down a number of players lol funny.

Game plan has to change without the likes of Reynolds and GI in the side

 

[Clifferd]

Alien didn't dish it out.

I'll always stick up for alien!!!

Lol

 

[Rabbits20]

We look like we are falling into the same trap we always do. Replacing Tyrell or clark will do nothing? Who do you replace them with? For the price these guys are reported to be on, you aren't going to get better players. Could try rookies, but that is always a huge gamble. Look at the knights. They've had to clear away duds, and replaced them with youngsters. They aren't tipped to win a game this season. I think we've shown with musgrove that when we have a young guy ready we will play him, but until they are ready it's a gamble. Clark and Tyrrell would be the best value for money players in our squad. Between the 2 of them they'd probably be on half the money George Burgess is on, yet while he languishes in nsw cup, Tyrrell and Clark combined over the 80 minutes to contribute 60 odd good tackles and a a handy 150 metres. We're we need better value for money is our big name players. George and Tom have been poor for years, Walker has to get better now his been upgraded, aj as well, even Sam has to be better. People praising Sam last night must have watched a different game. He made less runs and metres per minute then Tyrrell and Clark, made less tackles total then Clark even though he had more minutes and he came up with 5 missed tackles. This is from our million dollar player. It's easy to kick Tyrrell and Clark, but they are both playing like 150k a year players. Luke Kelly played like a back up half that was both drafted into the squad at the last minute, and drafted into the team at the last minute. What we need is for the twins to play to their pay packet and for Sam to play like a million dollar elite player

You go with a forward pack without Clark or Tyrrell. That's what a sensible coach who wants to keep his job would do!!!!

8. Musgrove
9. Cook (Farah at half)
10. Tom
11. Sutton
12. Crichton
13. Sam

14. Turner
15. Rochow
16. George
17. Cherrington

18. Talakai

If Turner or Rochow don't perform you give Talakai a bench spot!!!!!

Clark and Tyrrell the best value for money. Sorry mate but you've lost it.

Best value for money is Cook and Crichton currently. Also as we got Farah cheap he's very good value.

We tried selling Tyrrell but no one would take him for obvious reasons!!!!

Tom and George can at least bend the line.

Tyrrell and Clark don't bend the line. We can keep completing at 85percent with them in but we won't be winning!!!!

Kelly played shithouse. Extremely disappointing. Most of his kicks were shit and shallow. He has zero creativity and doesn't know how to guide a team around. Kelly would be the worst half in the comp. Heck, even McCrone is better!!!!!!!

Turner doesn't cut it either. Play Crichton instead. Crichton is stronger.

 

[Rabbits20]

Drop my Farah hatred? Really you have been putting down a number of players lol funny.

Game plan has to change without the likes of Reynolds and GI in the side

Yes but I love Clarky and Tyrrell has a big heart but I've been honest about them!!!!

 

[Rsag85]

Farah tried his arse off. He doesn't have the speed Cook has though but he makes up for it with his good kicking game and crafty play around the ruck.

Cook should have come on much earlier though, not when the game was over.

It's obvious you hate Farah. Let's be honest he was still in our best 5 players.

I didn't want him in the side? Yes your right.

I'm not a fan of Goodwin too. But who did I name as our best on Friday night?

Farah didn't deliver plan and simple. He did well in the CS but this game I thought he would of changed my opinion on him but he went missing.

 

[Rabbits20]

You know I'm right.

You said a couple of pages ago we need better than Tyrrell, Turner and Clark.

 

[Rabbits20]

Need better go forward guys like Tyrell, Turner and Clark don't deliver in this area

See.