forevermakingthreadafterthread

[Rabbits20]

1. Firstly i suggest a massive clean out is required we lack 1st grade quality players in our top 17 team

2. We need to be far more aggressive and far more successful in the players market our fans and sponsors expect it

3. If we lose a few players early as witnessed in round 1 we just dont have enough 1st grade depth players at the club

4. Why are we in this predicament i believe madge and the souths selectors are favoring too many duds for instance remember (mcinnes) re-read questions 1,2,3

5. Leaving greg inglis injured out on the paddock after he put his arm up is the most disrespectful situation i have ever witnesed by souths as a six decade member/fan its a disgrace,greg was busted, and all you thought about madge was winning at all costs by leaving greg on the paddock. Shame Shame Shame on you south sydney you owe this man more than an apology

6. And lastly drastic changes have to be made if we are to be a (Regular Top 8 Side) i am not happy with mediocrity are you?So what players should we be going after to replace the under achievers that are not up to 1st grade standards for 2018 please name your list of achievers and under achievers i shall put mine up shortly.WE NEED CHANGE NOW WAKE UP SOUTHS YOU HAVE FALLEN ASLEEP AT THE WHEEL SINCE 2014!!!!

Shadow...

1. Kelly, Tyrrell, Clark and Turner. George and Tom must lift too!!!! Talakai must be used in the back row off the bench.

2. We needed to keep Brown. We should have chased a guy like Vaughan or Matagi.

3. Our depth is thin. I agree there.

4. We are overpaying a few players which is a problem.

5. Yes very bad decision by Madge.

6. We need to try and get Dylan Walker back to someone similar to him.

Ofehengaue seems on the outs at the Broncos. Let's chase him. He's an upgrade on Tyrrell or Clark.

 

[Rabbits20]

What we really need is a supporter clean out.

Fair dinkum no wonder we were kicked out of the comp.

One loss and and everyone is acting like panicky idiot no1 from the posidon adventure.

Get behind your team and Club South Sydney Supporters!

SSTID

I always go to the games and I will keep on going and paying my membership year after year.

What we don't want though is mediocrity that is self inflicted!!!!!!! That's what you'll be seeing this season unless changes are made.

 

[Rabbits20]

Cook must get more game time!!!!!

 

[Rabbits20]

Well said mate!
The comments by some on here are very unSouth Sydney like.
The club doesn't need "supporters" like this.

We don't need players who are past it either and get ragdolled and don't get dumped for their poor performances.

Tyrrell, Clark and Turner.

If we re-sign Turner shortly the club has well and truly lost it!!!!

 

[Rabbits20]

Shadow it's far too early for this. It's been one game! We had a good pre season, we were just off on Friday.

If we're still playing shit mid season we could talk about this but at the moment it's just far to early and stupid to talk about this.

Not stupid at all. Lots were talking like this at the game!!!!!

Do you honestly think Tyrrell and Clark plus Turner are all if a sudden going to break the line and pose a threat to the opposition????? I know the answer!!!!!!

 

[Rabbits20]

IMO we should sign Matt Scott. We need another forward leader Sam can't do it all himself. We need a bloke to mentor the twins and Musgrove.

Thanks R95.

It's appreciated.

Correct that Sam can't do it all himself.

Another strong forward would make a big difference.

 

[Rabbits20]

i prefer matt scott over tyrrell or clark and turner at least scott has been a far better performer than the 3 ive mentioned and what about goodwin he is getting long in the tooth just like matt scott is but id take goodwin and scott over a combined clark,tyrrell.and turner any day of the week or year or decade just ask r20 he knows i am correctamundo.......Shadow....

Yep.

Scott and Sam with Musgrove chiming in as he does makes us stronger already plus Crichton over Turner.

 

[Rabbits20]

I'd go for Ofehengaue too Shadow. He's on the outs at the Broncos and is an upgrade on Tyrrell.

 

[Rabbits20]

You need to watch the games and know the facts, instead of naming a list of dud players every single week and posting annoying threads and post every single moment you get. And we all know your name don't need to waste your time ending every post with Shadow.

This is a very good thread.

We could beat Manly and the Knights but after that we have Roosters, Cowboys, Panthers, Bulldogs and Broncos. They'll be laughing if Tyrrell is there.

 

[Rabbits20]

I think he could be good for a few years until the twins develop. We have a bit of cash to spend as well considering we re-signed all our big name players before the new cap rises.

Who would you scout out Diego? I'm curious to see your answer.

Good luck getting an answer out of him lol.

I'd go Ofehengaue too R95.

 

[Rsag85]

This is a very good thread.

We could beat Manly and the Knights but after that we have Roosters, Cowboys, Panthers, Bulldogs and Broncos. They'll be laughing if Tyrrell is there.

Your right Tyrell shouldn't be there but you can't blame a lost on a group of players. A lot of factors played a part which you are missing the point

 

[rabbitohs95]

Good luck getting an answer out of him lol.

I'd go Ofehengaue too R95.

I'm sure he'll come up with something intelligent and measured. He usually does.

I wouldn't mind Ofahengaue, bit inconsistent.

 

[Rabbits20]

I'm sure he'll come up with something intelligent and measured. He usually does.

I wouldn't mind Ofahengaue, bit inconsistent.

Intelligent and measured, I'm on the floorlaughing!!!!

 

[Mitchd86]

I'm not a Souths fan however after drafting Rochow in fantasy I was keen to watch more of their games closely.

Turner and Tyrell are seriously the most average NRL players I have ever seen. Rochow was good with the mins he got.

The side is way way structured and clunky. As a Bulldogs fan I feel like I'm watching them play twice per week at the moment. I think Souths need huge changes to their forwards.

8. Musgrove
9. Farah
10. Rochow
11. Sutton
12. Crichton
13. Burgess.

 

[Rabbits20]

I'm not a Souths fan however after drafting Rochow in fantasy I was keen to watch more of their games closely.

Turner and Tyrell are seriously the most average NRL players I have ever seen. Rochow was good with the mins he got.

The side is way way structured and clunky. As a Bulldogs fan I feel like I'm watching them play twice per week at the moment. I think Souths need huge changes to their forwards.

8. Musgrove
9. Farah
10. Rochow
11. Sutton
12. Crichton
13. Burgess.

Thanks for sharing your input on Turner and Tyrrell. You're correct mate.

That pack already looks better.

 

[Rabbits20]

Mitchd86 knows his stuff.

 

[alien]

Farah didn't deliver plan and simple. He did well in the CS but this game I thought he would of changed my opinion on him but he went missing.

He can't do much when our forward pack is getting beaten. Our forward pack used to be one of our biggest strengths, and now they get dominated by Wests Tigers' pack, of all teams! It's not good enough! I believe a part of that problem is Madge's selections, but some players need a rocket up their arse!

 

[Rabbits20]

He can't do much when our forward pack is getting beaten. Our forward pack used to be one of our biggest strengths, and now they get dominated by Wests Tigers' pack, of all teams! It's not good enough! I believe a part of that problem is Madge's selections, but some players need a rocket up their arse!

Correctamundo!!!

 

[alien]

Let's drop the guy (who's a centre NOT a forward ) that made the most metres for Souths. #sheenius

So defense doesn't matter? That run-away try that Moses scored was from a mistake in defense by Talakai. I don't think he is a terrible player, but I believe Goodwin and Hunt are better centres at the moment.

 

[alien]

No, I just want you to speak up more!!!

Post how you really feel about Turner!!!!!!

Don't hide how you feel bro. Who cares who disagrees, I don't. I respect views of people but even if they don't like it I'll keep speaking up.

I said that I wanted Sutton and Crichton to be the starting second rowers, and Turner wasn't in my 17.