Former Panthers in the NRL

[jane the pain]

Both said great things about there time in Penrith,Moylan admitting he did wrong with the out drinking fiasco.
Lewis saying his time at Penrith was a great time,he's off contract at season end would love to see him come back to see out his career would do so much for this young team

I wouldn't given the way Luke carried on when he left.

 

[Aliceinwonderland]

I wouldn't given the way Luke carried on when he left.

Me neither. I have a long memory, (as many others do) He carried on like a pork chop.

 

[jane the pain]

Me neither. I have a long memory, (as many others do) He carried on like a pork chop.

Petulant brat more like it.

 

[Aliceinwonderland]

Petulant brat more like it.

An ego as big as all outdoors too.

 

[Kilkenny]

Matt Moylan lost the support and respect of a lot of our fans around the well documented issues but I certainly would'nt support his being booed. No need for it and probably bites us on the you know what if he has a blinder.

 

[Abacus]

Matt Moylan lost the support and respect of a lot of our fans around the well documented issues but I certainly would'nt support his being booed. No need for it and probably bites us on the you know what if he has a blinder.

Why take the fun out of going to the footy? Its the 1 way most fans of showing their displeasure that a player chose another team. Even if he has a blinder, so what. Still boo him from the moment he runs out until he disappears back into the sheds. It'd be un-Australian not to boo him.

 

[Aliceinwonderland]

Why take the fun out of going to the footy? Its the 1 way most fans of showing their displeasure that a player chose another team. Even if he has a blinder, so what. Still boo him from the moment he runs out until he disappears back into the sheds. It'd be un-Australian not to boo him.

I agree. One of the funniest things I've seen is the laughter even by players on the bench (bikes) when Cartwright was sin binned. A great moment in league.

 

[Kilkenny]

Why take the fun out of going to the footy? Its the 1 way most fans of showing their displeasure that a player chose another team. Even if he has a blinder, so what. Still boo him from the moment he runs out until he disappears back into the sheds. It'd be un-Australian not to boo him.

Just me I guess. I definitely don't want him to have a blinder for two reasons. One it means we probably lose the game and two, more importantly, would never hear the end of it from Umina Panther.

 

[Matthew Ellis]

It's interesting how many players who looked good at Penrith last year went to shit when they left. Latu, Cartwright (wasn't good last year but is miles worse this year), TMM (was good in his midseason transfer year but is having a shcocker so far), Mitch Rein (plenty of Penrith fans said he was far better than Wall last year and now Titans fans hate him for his terrible passing), Moyza improved recently but in his first couple games he was looking like one of the worst spine players in the comp.

Both said great things about there time in Penrith,Moylan admitting he did wrong with the out drinking fiasco.
Lewis saying his time at Penrith was a great time,he's off contract at season end would love to see him come back to see out his career would do so much for this young team

We'd have to drop CHN. Considering he'd walk into the Tigers team we'd probably lose him long term.

 

[mxlegend99]

I can get behind booing people like Matt Lodge and Russell Packer. Or booing ab

It's interesting how many players who looked good at Penrith last year went to shit when they left. Latu, Cartwright (wasn't good last year but is miles worse this year), TMM (was good in his midseason transfer year but is having a shcocker so far), Mitch Rein (plenty of Penrith fans said he was far better than Wall last year and now Titans fans hate him for his terrible passing), Moyza improved recently but in his first couple games he was looking like one of the worst spine players in the comp.


We'd have to drop CHN. Considering he'd walk into the Tigers team we'd probably lose him long term.

Gotten worse:
Latu was bad last year. Sorse this year. Thinks hes a hslf
Carty was mostly bad last year. But has hit new low this year. Im scared for his mental state.

Gotten better
Hiku helped create 7 tackle busts for us on Friday night. His best game for us.
Moylan was mostly average last year with a few strong games. Has improved this year. He's not playing badly at all.

Hard to compare
Rein barely played for us last year. Although he was better than Wallace while Wallace was busted
Tmm easily improved last year after leaving. But his whole club has collapsed this year. Maybe he got 'busy' during the off-season

The only one who sould boost us is Moylan, but we have Maloney who has so far been the better player so we thankfully are ahead at the moment there. Although Maloneys form has taken a dive through the Origin period. Hopefully with the series 100% behind him the next time he plays for us he and Cleary can focus on adding a premiership to their series win.

 

[franklin2323]

Matt Moylan lost the support and respect of a lot of our fans around the well documented issues but I certainly would'nt support his being booed. No need for it and probably bites us on the you know what if he has a blinder.

My area was all talking about giving it too him during the game

 

[OldPanther]

I can get behind booing people like Matt Lodge and Russell Packer. Or booing ab

Gotten worse:
Latu was bad last year. Sorse this year. Thinks hes a hslf
Carty was mostly bad last year. But has hit new low this year. Im scared for his mental state.

Gotten better
Hiku helped create 7 tackle busts for us on Friday night. His best game for us.
Moylan was mostly average last year with a few strong games. Has improved this year. He's not playing badly at all.

Hard to compare
Rein barely played for us last year. Although he was better than Wallace while Wallace was busted
Tmm easily improved last year after leaving. But his whole club has collapsed this year. Maybe he got 'busy' during the off-season

The only one who sould boost us is Moylan, but we have Maloney who has so far been the better player so we thankfully are ahead at the moment there. Although Maloneys form has taken a dive through the Origin period. Hopefully with the series 100% behind him the next time he plays for us he and Cleary can focus on adding a premiership to their series win.

For reference Moylan is top 5 for try assists and 1st for line break assists.

 

[martielang]

I'm not normally one for booing players but if there was ever an exception to the rule it has to be Moylan.

If only to see Oldpanther & Umina jump onto the field & try to protect the poor little guy.

 

[umina panther]

I'm not normally one for booing players but if there was ever an exception to the rule it has to be Moylan.

If only to see Oldpanther & Umina jump onto the field & try to protect the poor little guy.

Nah Moylan is fair game imo. Carty is a different situation

 

[franklin2323]

Nah Moylan is fair game imo. Carty is a different situation

Until Carty goes and gets treatment then he should be treated as any other player

 

[OldPanther]

I'm not normally one for booing players but if there was ever an exception to the rule it has to be Moylan.

If only to see Oldpanther & Umina jump onto the field & try to protect the poor little guy.

I'd be booing if I could go. Carty is the one I don't like being booed.

 

[Matthew Ellis]

Moylan was mostly average last year with a few strong games. Has improved this year. He's not playing badly at all.

Like I said he's gotten better recently but for his first 7 or so games he was making a shocking amount of errors. He far was below average, he playing similar at a level similar to Aiden Sezer. At one point he lead the error count for the comp despite not playing a couple games. I think he made 6 errors in a match once.

I'd be booing if I could go. Carty is the one I don't like being booed.

Like I said he's improved, he looks like he's having one his red hot runs he goes on sometimes but in his first couple games he was pretty bad.

 

[mxlegend99]

For reference Moylan is top 5 for try assists and 1st for line break assists.

Pretty decent. Although if he were still here he would have twice as many of both passing to Kikau and Blake

 

[OldPanther]

Like I said he's gotten better recently but for his first 7 or so games he was making a shocking amount of errors. He far was below average, he playing similar at a level similar to Aiden Sezer. At one point he lead the error count for the comp despite not playing a couple games. I think he made 6 errors in a match once.

Like I said he's improved, he looks like he's having one his red hot runs he goes on sometimes but in his first couple games he was pretty bad.

Yeah you're right. He was still plagued by the leg injury.

 

[OldPanther]

Pretty decent. Although if he were still here he would have twice as many of both passing to Kikau and Blake

Easily.