Foul play like George Rose'.....

[Noa]

..surely in future needs to be penalised with a stint in the foul-play bin.

5 or 10 minutes, I dont care.

 

[DoggiesBro]

disgusting effort, deadset though even with matai and co carrying on tackling ppl without the ball etc they are dirty but you cant expect much diff from manly.

 

[some11]

Anyone know what constitutes a send-off anymore?

 

[kickback]

He be off ! On report is not enough it's a GF

 

[Noa]

Anyone know what constitutes a send-off anymore?

Thats the thing, if youre unsure if its a genuine send-ff have the fall-back option.

1 man down for 10 minutes in todays game is a massive penalty.

 

[Weaponhead]

Disgraceful cheap shot. Full of intent. Should've gone

 

[Spanner in the works]

Should've gone for ten. I AM SO SO SICK OF THE DIFFERENT RULES THAT APPLY TO DIFFERENT TEAMS, DIFFERENT PLAYERS AND DIFFERENT ROUNDS. f**kING OVER IT.

 

[Feej]

But it's Manly......

 

[Jason Maher]

The refs need to be given the option of using the bin for foul play.

 

[anzac7]

At least 5 minutes (or 10 if they don't have it) If he fully connected then the no.9 is out cold and serious damage with that whopper coming down on ya .. it was a send off offence.. that was much worse than the high shot on the Manly number 16 a little later on which also got put on report (so free interchange)... can't even compare the TWO!

 

[Weaponhead]

rrefereeing has been terrible. predictably all calls going one way.

rose should have been sent
mateo strip not called
watmough incorrect play the ball not called
cherry Evans obstruction not called

so predictable

 

[newmanj]

The NRL have no credibility. It was so predictable that this would happen, with every decision going to Manly.

Its wrong.

 

[MightyBronco]

2 weeks suspension for a non manly player.

 

[Billythekid]

If that doesn't get you a stint on the bench than what does?

 

[Reece75]

cheap shot and shit refereeing

 

[Chook Norris]

precisely my thoughts. On report in the GF? who the bloody hell cares. At least a sin-bin

 

[Wilson1]

precisely my thoughts. On report in the GF? who the bloody hell cares. At least a sin-bin

Refs should ref the grand final to the same standard as they do the regular season. If it's on report in the season its on report in the final.

 

[CC_Roosters]

Yes absolutely. The report system is a get out of jail free card for the refs and the governing body should review it asap

 

[Chook Norris]

Refs should ref the grand final to the same standard as they do the regular season. If it's on report in the season its on report in the final.

that's true. But it was an elbow to the head with deliberate intention.. there was clear malice and it deserved more than a report as it would've in most matches

 

[Glen]

No need for the bin if they just send that fat grub off. We just need refs with more guts