What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Four Broncos cleared of sex assault allegations

Stained_Class

Juniors
Messages
642
I look forward to hearing commentary like this come Saturday Night.

"Thaiday!!! He's straight through the gap, offloads to Hunt, he gets it away to Boyd. Thaiday backing up in support. Boyd won't need it though he'll go all the way himself !!! The Broncos score!!! Thaiday, Hunt and Boyd have combined beautifully!!!! "

Video ref please!
 

adamkungl

Immortal
Messages
42,971
I look forward to hearing commentary like this come Saturday Night.

"Thaiday!!! He's straight through the gap, offloads to Hunt, he gets it away to Boyd. Thaiday backing up in support. Boyd won't need it though he'll go all the way himself !!! The Broncos score!!! Thaiday, Hunt and Boyd have combined beautifully!!!! "

Need to check with the video ref...
 

bobbis

Juniors
Messages
798
From whats been told so far there's no evidence of actual sexual assault, so unless they're charged the Broncos won't stand down 2 internationals and a state rep. Bennet also won't be doing the firing given hes got between 1 and 3 games left. Before banishing them to the ESL we should at least wait for a few more facts to emerge.

Really you've got to question their intelligence, no matter whether its assault or not, the 3 of them getting their knobs out in a very public place to have a go at some woman is just stupid. When you're a public figure you need to realise anything scandalous is news worthy.
 

Frank_Grimes

First Grade
Messages
7,023
EXACTLY.

It doesn't matter if charges are laid or not.
They went out drinking and have gotten themselves into a very bad situation. They have disrespected their fans, their teammates, their coach, their club and the NRL as a whole. All this during a red hot finals series that will now be marred by this event forever.
The 3 of them deserve to have their heads bashed together for being so irresponsible, and in my opinion, don't deserve to be a part of the game for the rest of the year.

All that is known fact about the whole debacle is that they were there and they were drinking. Yes, it is incredibly stupid for them to be out drinking at all during the finals. Yes, they all will have lost a great deal of respect from fans (myself included) and team mates regardless of whether charges are laid. But Brisbane are conducting their own investigation into the matter and will no doubt sack all three if they find that they have broken player conduct standards.
 

DJShaksta

First Grade
Messages
7,226
All that is known fact about the whole debacle is that they were there and they were drinking. Yes, it is incredibly stupid for them to be out drinking at all during the finals. Yes, they all will have lost a great deal of respect from fans (myself included) and team mates regardless of whether charges are laid. But Brisbane are conducting their own investigation into the matter and will no doubt sack all three if they find that they have broken player conduct standards.

Thats what I'm saying FG.
I don't care for the legal rammifications of this incident, the police will sort that out.
I am saying they disgraced their club, their teammates and fans, etc. And they should be punished for it.
FFS its Benny's last year at the club he pretty much built and these 3 farkwits go and do this.
 

Noa

First Grade
Messages
9,029
Rule 1 of getting your knob gobbled with a mate in a night-club cubicle ettiquite, never pull out a phone to film it.

Only a s**t would let that happen and this sheila obviously had to much class for that.




PS. What a bunch of fools.
 

sharko

Juniors
Messages
911
It is a rule for one club and a rule for the other..the Broncos players should be stood down as these are serious accusations of which the police are investigating.
Everybody lined up to convict Bird and banish him from football, including Gallop but they are using a difeerent set of standards here because it is semi final..a poor show all round!
 

Mr Angry

Not a Referee
Messages
51,816
Broncos quartet facing axe

By Dan Koch
September 16, 2008
BRISBANE'S charge towards an unlikely premiership was thrown into turmoil on Monday, with four senior players facing the axe over allegations of sexual assault.
Karmichael Hunt, Darius Boyd and Sam Thaiday are alleged to be the players helping police in their investigations into the claims, following a reported incident in a Brisbane nightclub on Saturday.

The club has opened an internal investigation into the player's conduct after what was a booze-fuelled night of controversy at the weekend.

Saturday evening's Broncos-Melbourne finals blockbuster, which will double as Wayne Bennett's Brisbane farewell, has been overshadowed by revelations three Broncos players were being investigated by Queensland Police over the alleged sexual assault of a young woman in the toilet of a Brisbane nightclub. While police and the Broncos have refused to confirm the identities of the players involved, star full-back Karmichael Hunt told reporters at training early on Monday that he had been out drinking on Saturday night.
It can be revealed that Bennett addressed the entire Broncos squad before Monday's training session, ordering the players to close ranks and declaring the subject off limits at the club's training headquarters at Red Hill.
However, it seems unlikely the drama will fade away after police interviewed the players on Monday afternoon, shortly before the club announced the start of its own investigation into the evening.
"As soon as the Broncos were made aware of the allegations, an internal investigation team was formed," Broncos chief executive Bruno Cullen said.
"The main focus of the internal investigation team is to co-operate fully with the Queensland Police and collectively ensure all the relevant facts are recorded."
Cullen said the players were co-operating with the police investigation, which is still several days away from a conclusion.
On past experience, however, the club's independent investigation is unlikely to drag on. The club acted quickly and decisively on the findings of its investigation team's look into repeated breaches of the players' code by Brett Seymour and Neville Costigan in 2006.
The pair had their contracts terminated immediately, as did Ian Lacey and John Te Reo at the end of the 2007 season for their involvement in a brutal assault on a Brisbane street.
Fears the club could again wield the axe for Saturday night threw betting agencies into turmoil, with bookmakers across the country suspending grand final betting and all wagers involving the Broncos.

http://www.foxsports.com.au/story/0,8659,24352181-23214,00.html

4 players??
 

lockyno1

Post Whore
Messages
53,348
Thats what I'm saying FG.
I don't care for the legal rammifications of this incident, the police will sort that out.
I am saying they disgraced their club, their teammates and fans, etc. And they should be punished for it.
FFS its Benny's last year at the club he pretty much built and these 3 farkwits go and do this.

And guess what it is the FANS that suffer the most. I want to win, and to be honest I could not care about anything else. All these allegations are, are unproven at the moment. Lets sort it out after the season in due course. Yes they were dumb (should not be drinking in the finals) but they do not deserve to be stood down when the evidence has only begun to be investigated.
 

DJShaksta

First Grade
Messages
7,226
And guess what it is the FANS that suffer the most. I want to win, and to be honest I could not care about anything else. All these allegations are, are unproven at the moment. Lets sort it out after the season in due course. Yes they were dumb (should not be drinking in the finals) but they do not deserve to be stood down when the evidence has only begun to be investigated.

If they have broken the clubs code of conduct then they deserve to be stood down.
If dragging the clubs name through mud because you have been accused of having groupsex with your teammates and a girl in a toilet cubicle is ok by the clubs code of conduct let them play I guess.

If all you care about is winning its good that you aren't in control of the Bronco's, or any Rugby League club for that matter. A clubs image and a clubs values are more important than any players.
 
Messages
3,070
By not dropping them, Brisbane are saying its ok to go out and get drunk, then participate in groupsex acts in a toilet cubicle of some seedy nightclub.

I will preface my question by saying that i havnt formed a view on this alleged incident because I dont possess all the facts.

The alternative question though is this :

By dropping the 3 players in question as suggested by DJS above, and IF suppose the allegations were subsequently proven false or even vexatious could the broncos be then saying that its OK (giving a green light) to all & sundry to automatically adversely effect their players careers simply by making a false statement ?
 

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
Missing me are you?

you've been vewy vewy quiet, Chucky

you're up anyone who gets on the piss at other clubs and start wanking on about the Broncos yet now it seems the cats got your tongue

i'm hardly surprised though
 

lockyno1

Post Whore
Messages
53,348
If they have broken the clubs code of conduct then they deserve to be stood down.
If dragging the clubs name through mud because you have been accused of having groupsex with your teammates and a girl in a toilet cubicle is ok by the clubs code of conduct let them play I guess.

If all you care about is winning its good that you aren't in control of the Bronco's, or any Rugby League club for that matter. A clubs image and a clubs values are more important than any players.

Innocent till proven otherwise. Who knows it could well be a girl making a story up just to get her two minutes of fame.
 

Noa

First Grade
Messages
9,029
If they have broken the clubs code of conduct then they deserve to be stood down.
If dragging the clubs name through mud because you have been accused of having groupsex with your teammates and a girl in a toilet cubicle is ok by the clubs code of conduct let them play I guess.

If all you care about is winning its good that you aren't in control of the Bronco's, or any Rugby League club for that matter. A clubs image and a clubs values are more important than any players.


Just a guess but if that was a sackable offence I reckon every team would be down a couple of players just about every week.

Instead of people and sponsors (and lets be honest the boss of these companies probably arent above this type of thing) expressing their mock outrage lets just accept this stuff happens and move on.
 

Rockin Ronny

Juniors
Messages
1,769
It is a rule for one club and a rule for the other..the Broncos players should be stood down as these are serious accusations of which the police are investigating.
Everybody lined up to convict Bird and banish him from football, including Gallop but they are using a difeerent set of standards here because it is semi final..a poor show all round!

Agreed.
they convict Birdy on allegations - but are happy to let this one slide.

We need Gallop to come out now and say "um ahh" a few times. That'll sort things out.
 

Mr Saab

Referee
Messages
27,762
you've been vewy vewy quiet, Chucky

you're up anyone who gets on the piss at other clubs and start wanking on about the Broncos yet now it seems the cats got your tongue

i'm hardly surprised though


Really...how is this for you then..

If they are guilty of anything then they should all be sacked.

Happy?
 
Top