I dunno wibs. That particular side was the last season of the Lang era and they made the prelim final.
Most of the core group were playing in the preceding 7 seasons of The Lang Years and did pretty well
There was always that certain special something missing though
View attachment 30616
Screenshot courtesy of rugbyleagueproject
Yeah, Campbell did well with them, and then he and Lang took Penrith to a premiership. Dykes on his day was good, and most the forwards were good workers.
But that squad is out the other side of the Peachey, Rogers, Barnett etc flashy era and Gallen is about to start his career with a squad that goes terribly for a half dozen years or so.
I think the preceding squads (especially the '99 and 2001 teams) could easily have won with a bit of luck.
There are some premiership squads that get by with one or two stars, but you look at our squad since 2016, or any other winner from the last few years except maybe Cowboys in 2015 (who had one genuine super star and a bunch of ok to good players), and they have great players all over the place (2016 we have Maloney, Barba, Ennis, Gallen, Graham, Lewis, Fifita as established stars and Bird and Holmes as up and coming stars, support players like Prior who would become an Origin rep).