We should be comparing him to Hunt, see who has most upside, question will be does Tooks has same motor as Hunt
I'd have to agree there is more upside to Tooks. But you don't pick an 11 minute rookie over a player in his fifth year of NRL, with representative honours, based on upside.
As I said, that might change towards the back end of the year. But not now.
It's interesting you raise the point of who to compare him to as I've been thinking lately about our middle stocks and squad composition.
For me, we have a few players of similar physique and I'd play them as an either/or proposition, rather than together.
BHU/Hunt - neck and neck for mine but, at full fitness, BHU is no.1.
Herb/Toby - I have Tobes ahead. Considerably, actually.
Tommy/Tuku - Tommy based on last year but, based on last night's little cameo, he needs to watch his back.
Dale/Cam - Tough one.
I leave Jack out as I don't see anyone else similar to him.
At this point I have Tommy and Tuku duking it out for the last bench spot.
In time I can see them more competing with Royce, but not at the moment.
As the captain said, I think it's telling the club hasn't re-signed Tommy just yet.
The forgotten man is JC.
I have him snapping at the heels of Herb and Tobes.
I'd not be in a hurry to take up Herb's option just yet.
It's going to be interesting watching the pack morph over the next season or so.