What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

In Hindsight; Shackleton vs Gulavau & Kingston

Would you rather Shackleton or both of Kingston and Joey G?

  • Shackelton

    Votes: 26 55.3%
  • Kingston & Galavau

    Votes: 21 44.7%

  • Total voters
    47

yy_cheng

Coach
Messages
18,734
i think the shack will be a very good player and very good fit for our team. suity whos the winger playing prop?

FUi started out as a winger.

I still recall Pearson standing in the middle of the field one off the ruck and passing it on. So funny.
 

Fee

Juniors
Messages
947
I cant wait to see the new boys playing for our club next year.I watched Shack play a little this season and he is a very good defender and quite often bent the line back on his hitups, I am really excited to see how he plays in a good team.:D
 

Craig Johnston

First Grade
Messages
5,396
i'd be backing the long term investment and potential in shack over joe g anyday, shack could be an aus test rep within a couple of seasons, he has all the attributes to become a marquee player, so why not bag him now for reasonable cost
 

PJ Marshal

Coach
Messages
13,525
It sure is.

I was going to start one comparing letting Michael Vella go and whether Corey Pearson was a better signing.

Suity

cosidering vella and pearson played in the same side together in 04

makes your statement wrong and confirms the fact that you are a moron
 

COACH STERLING

Juniors
Messages
1,906
I'm tipping Shackleton to have a bigger season than Justin Poore.
From the games I watched of the roosters, he was heads and shoulders above the rest of the pack.
 

caylo

Bench
Messages
4,870
to put it into perspective
Gulavau - 150K (atleast 120K i would imagine)
Kingston - 105K (55K + the 50K match payments)
Shakelton - 170K (from all reports)

So 255K vs 170K (+55K for Mitchell) we probably got the better end of the deal. I think we will miss Joe more then Kinga, he has improved so much and I hope Shak can fill that void and then some.
 

Voodoo Rock

Juniors
Messages
79
moot point, might aswell discuss this equation aswell

would u rather resign morts and mateo next year or have signed poore and tahu this year

i welcome all our new players and wish all those departing good luck with the rest of their careers too
 

hasman

Juniors
Messages
205
I rather Shackleton then Todd Lowrie.

No offence for the Same amount of money.

Who would you rather have ?
 

Eelementary

Post Whore
Messages
57,249
My two cents:

Shane Shackleton is a big, aggressive guy. He's 27, so still fairly young. He played a great season in a horrid, horrid pack.

Todd Lowrie played a great 3 months for us. He always tried his arse off, but he wasn't a big unit and, to be blunt, his first year or so at the club was fairly ordinary.

Joe Galuvao always impressed me when he put on our jersey. He ran hard, tackled hard and always gave 100%. He was bigger than Todd, but hardly a unit either.

It is my belief that if we were to take one thing out of the Grand Final loss this year it is that our pack simply wasn't capable of matching the Storm's pack physically. They tried, and very valiantly. But they were simply out-muscled by a bigger, stronger pack.

Shane Shackleton will add size, bring a strong work ethic in defence to the table and he bends the line with his runs. Both Todd and Joe were bending the line and working hard in defence, so we're not losing anything there.

Bottom line, I am thinking it will be a master stroke - we can have work-horses like Cayless, Hindmarsh and Benny, and then use Mateo, Fui, Poore and Shack to make metres and cause all sorts of headaches.

As for Kingston, I love the bloke's passion, but he won't be missed. I am sorry to be so blunt, but we have Kris Keating, Anthony Mitchell and Matt Keating all capable of playing hooker. Mitchell, in particular, will be a great addition to this squad and will play a similar role to Kingston - only adding his unique style to the mix.
 

Craig Johnston

First Grade
Messages
5,396
caylo does have games where he hits the ball up 17-20 times, regardless how many minutes he plays, that is a workhorse effort
 

Eelementary

Post Whore
Messages
57,249
Cayless usually makes about 20 tackles and 10 to 15 hit-ups. OK, it's no Nathan Hindmarsh-like, but not many blokes can do that except for Hindy.
 

caylo

Bench
Messages
4,870
Cayless usually makes about 20 tackles and 10 to 15 hit-ups. OK, it's no Nathan Hindmarsh-like, but not many blokes can do that except for Hindy.

I disagree, while he makes 15 hit ups but makes around 30-35 tackles a game and just as many tackles hindy on tackles/min
 

Latest posts

Top