What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Is Cameron Smith the best No 9 ever?

Big Time

Juniors
Messages
602
Hooking role is different to what it used to be so cannot compare the likes of Noel Kelly with him. OUt of your modern day hookers, I would have Ben Elias, Steve Walters and Danny Buderus before him.

Anyone for Snoopy Collins??
 

Big Time

Juniors
Messages
602
I think the mobility factor is a bigger issue than height - may not have emphasised that enough.

Hilditch is definitely old school, which shows as his last 4 years were solely as a prop. A better example would be Ken Stewart from Souths who was also tallish but old school - and replaced by a young Mario Fenech very quickly. Irony is that Parra then bought Stewart to replace Edge - but in his final year he too was converted to a prop as the youthful and more mobile Moseley took over.

Parra were well behind some other Clubs at the time with this hooker 'revolution' - about the only thing they were behind in.

Would have liked to have seen Cunningham ply his trade in the NRL for a year or so. There's a good history of Pommie hookers doing well in Australia - Mike Stephenson, John Gray, Lee Jackson and a small cameo for Brian Noble.


Would be good to see the likes of James Roby head over here. I believe he would give the mantle of top hooker in NRL a shake.
 
Top