What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Is Des fairdinkum?

Raider_69

Post Whore
Messages
61,174
Is des fair dinkum?

The includsion of Mark Bryant is proof he is not, you dont win comps with a bench players like Bryant, Afamasunga and Cuthbertson whom all did a sweet F/a
 

wittyfan

Referee
Messages
29,978
Des hasn't been fair dinkum since about Round 19 in 2005.

His lack of ability was cruelly exposed last night.
 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
152,879
The Mack said:
Manly should have gone with

Stewart
Robertson
Bell
Lyon
Hicks
Burns
Orford
King
Monas
Kite
Watmough
Stewart
Menzies

Ballin
Matai
Cuthbertson
Hall/Afamasaga
Bingo!!! that side would have been far more competitive.
 

Dutchy

Immortal
Messages
33,887
Originally Posted by The Mack
Manly should have gone with

Stewart
Robertson
Bell
Lyon
Hicks
Burns
Orford
King
Monas
Kite
Watmough
Stewart
Menzies

Ballin
Matai
Cuthbertson
Hall/Afamasaga


My Team

Stewart
Robertson
Bell
Lyon - KICKER
Hicks
Burns
Orford
King
Monas - CAPTAIN
Kite
Watmough
Stewart
Williamson

Ballin
Matai
Cuthbertson
Menzies
 

winnyason

Juniors
Messages
1,576
the old saying is you have to lose won to win one but i have grave concerns if we will be back a few points fellow eagles fans
1. the roosters & broncos are our main worries to get back to next years decider locky hunt back, roosters looked very dangerous next year.
2.the storm may be buliding a canberra type era, with inglis, smith, slater, folau, hoffman, white, cronk & a nursery of hard nosed kiwi pigs lima, blair, smith let's hope a car takes out smith or inglis other wise a long couple of years ahead.
3.our problems talk about nervous playing away from game plan.
4. Pigs have no mongrel that flea crocker hits stewart we cheap shot we go hide.
5. Josh Perry must bring some mongrel jason king let's go missing.
6. The matt oford bagging unjustified no go forward so we had to go wide in own 20, he was kicking under pressure because he had no go forward.
7. the five eight issue we don't have one jamie lyon is a centre look at parra match won us match, either matai goes to lock(only player with mongrel) or bell to wing.
the main reason we had ox under pressure other option at list inglis can bomb.
8. the question who for 6: clint halden, steve menzies or james mortimer
9. Ballin has a lot of pressure on him will he handle it.
10.must use ballin & lestrange off bench worked for parra give it a go.
11. williamson time is numbered in first grade either matai at 13 or that young rugby boy every one was after hargeraves.
12. watmough putting in hollower that are rubbish missed 11 tackles & dropped 2 balls went missing.

my thoughts fellows very worried about 13 & 9 next year.
 

Hari Kari

Juniors
Messages
939
Biggest dud was Cuthbertson.

He's not a bad player when they're 20 in front and he's fresh and everyone else is buggered though.
 

Hari Kari

Juniors
Messages
939
winnyason said:
6. The matt oford bagging unjustified no go forward so we had to go wide in own 20, he was kicking under pressure because he had no go forward.

I won't say he had a bad game but he had two chances near their line to put in good attacking kicks without much pressure on him while they were still in the game and both were very ordinary.
 

winnyason

Juniors
Messages
1,576
this bloke solves the 13 problems
MANLY have won the race to sign one of the best young rugby union talents in the country after yesterday securing 18-year-old Waratah Jared Waerea-Hargreaves.
In a blow to rugby union in the battle between the codes, Waerea-Hargreaves has rejected interest from four other NRL clubs as well as the NSW Waratahs, the Western Force and the New Zealand Rugby Union to link with the Sea Eagles on a two-year deal.
The New Zealand-born back-rower, who has been compared to Bulldogs second-rower Sonny Bill Williams and retired Manly lock Ben Kennedy, was apparently offered by the Sea Eagles up to four times more than the Waratahs were prepared to outlay.
The Watarahs offered him a four-year deal but two of those seasons would have been spent as part of their academy program.
Waerea-Hargreaves was dropped from the Central Coast Rays team to play the East Coast Aces this Sunday in the Australian Rugby Championship.
His manager, Mike Newton, denied the move was a "money grab".
"I wanted him to be in a professional environment next year," Newton said. "I believe his progress and form certainly warranted being a full-time professional, and the Waratahs couldn't offer it.
"He's certainly excited about it. He's always had a genuine interest in rugby league and he has an opportunity to be training with one of the top NRL teams in the competition."
"Being able to play under a bloke like [Manly coach] Des Hasler is a huge privilege for him. He hasn't played league since he was 10 or 11, but I'm sure he'll be well suited to the game."
Newton also said the lure of a State of Origin jumper was a consideration for the player whose teammates at Norths call him Sonny because of his likeness in look and talent to the New Zealand international.
"When I told him that he'd still be eligible for NSW under-19s next year, he said to me, 'does that mean I'll play at Suncorp, does that mean I'd play before the Origin'," he said. "He's always loved Origin, he loves the confrontation, he loves the physical stuff."
Waerea-Hargreaves moved to Australia on a golf scholarship (he has a handicap of two) in Queensland but then took up rugby union and was last year signed by the Waratahs for this season.
Wests Tigers, South Sydney, Cronulla and Gold Coast had been monitoring him, while a senior New Zealand rugby official had flown to Sydney to watch him play. But after yesterday discussing his future via satellite phone with his father, who is in Iraq serving as a contracted engineer with the US military, Waerea-Hargreaves opted for Manly.

but where that f**k is a 6 james mortimer or who sam key let groom & burns go f**k me
 

manlyone

Juniors
Messages
25
I think the problem with Burns is that he is a specialist half with the potential to play at dummy half.

The semi final last year when Saints smashed us is the classic example - early in the first half manly had chances with a backline set deep. Unfortunatley Burns can only catch & pass or step back on the inside. He does not posses the ability to set up outside backs. His defence (for a little bloke), attitude and enthusiasm are outstanding but he is not a 5/8th .... in saying that I think he will be a sensation at 1/2 with JT at 5/8 at the cowboys.

5/8 is obviously a problem for Manly, Lyons has shown glimses of good 5/8 play but all his best footy has been played at centre. Menzies is a legend but he is also not a real 5/8 ...... what Manly do for 5/8 next year will be interesting - Wells, Halden and Mortimer are possibilities. If one of these guys steps up, Matai moves into the forwards for some necessary mungrel & assuming Ballin does a great job at hooker means we can improve on 2007.
 

manlyone

Juniors
Messages
25
I see witt as exactly the same as Burns ..... a half playing 5/8. The only difference between them is that Witt can kick goals but can't tackle.
 

Latest posts

Top