Is Issac John a better halfback ?

[ozbash]

Than Seymour or Maloney ?

He seems to spark the whole team up, and actually calls the shots..

Thoughts

 

[playdaball]

He needs to be in the mix somewhere

 

[RHYTHM AND STEALTH]

The only reason that Seymore and Baloney dont play much is becos of injury so when they inuury free they deserve to be back together. We go awesum when they play`

 

[Iafeta]

I've been very impressed by Isaac. Didn't think the bloke had anything to offer at all... up till the end of last year I was convinced he had a weak kicking game, little spark with ball in hand and an inability to organise. He wasn't really that flash in U20s, he seemed to be made to look decent by a crack hot U20s side.

However, wow, the improvement in him blows me away. Well Isaac! As to whether he should usurp the Buster/Maloney combination, I don't think so. Seymour is such a good organiser and Maloney is the scrapper who seems to take advantage of opportunities. Perhaps interchange hooker?

 

[Martli]

It's a good position to be in, but I think we've been our best with Seymour and Maloney in there. I agree with feka, maybe he can take Hendo's role and Aaron Heremaia can play a few more minutes.

 

[Scott]

Been very impressed the past 2 weeks, but Buster is the #1 #7.

 

[Meth]

Been very impressed the past 2 weeks, but Buster is the #1 #7.

this

 

[Drzoidberg]

Yea give John Hendo's spot and Hoho can stay at the back

 

[Micistm]

Seymour still edges IMO, but that takes nothing away from Issac, who's taken his chance well. Defo on the bench on Seymours return at the expense of Hendo.

 

[Rich102]

Not according to Cleary.
Hendo will be there till hell freezes over. (Remember Rovelli, Witt et al.?)

 

[Bobby DIGital]

It would be good to see a Kiwi start at 7 for an NRL side each week.

 

[tezzah]

Isaac John is not a hooker!

 

[Meth]

Slightly off topic, but did anybody watch 40/20's highlight package of the game- when the Taia hit on John was shown, the token girl basically accused John of taking a dive- the guy was nudged off balance, fell over and got back up.

 

[Iafeta]

There were only two dives in that game - Scott Dureau at the back end of the first half committed a Hollywood stunt act, and then he himself followed it up with a dive in terms of performance of epic proportions. Karma. That performance by Dureau made Grant Rovelli look like Wally Lewis/Andrew Johns combined.

 

[Mixmasterreece]

There were only two dives in that game - Scott Dureau at the back end of the first half committed a Hollywood stunt act, and then he himself followed it up with a dive in terms of performance of epic proportions. Karma. That performance by Dureau made Grant Rovelli look like Wally Lewis/Andrew Johns combined.

And to think we tried to lure him here for the 2009 season..... we dodged a huge bullet.

 

[ozreece77]

There were only two dives in that game - Scott Dureau at the back end of the first half committed a Hollywood stunt act, and then he himself followed it up with a dive in terms of performance of epic proportions. Karma. That performance by Dureau made Grant Rovelli look like Wally Lewis/Andrew Johns combined.

QFT

not the first time this season he's taken a dive to milk a penalty either.

The Knights forum on this website dont think too highly of the guy and thats putting it mildly.

 

[Shaun Hewitt]

I'd have either John or Seymour on the bench over Henderson when Brett comes back.
However knowing Cleary this won't be the case as previously mentioned

 

[PASSION]

saw 40/20 interview with Isaac John tonight he seems to be a very focussed young half back in the making! Knows that he has still got a lot to learn and looks very keen and bright prospect for any team. Make sure you keep him i say

 

[Kiwis 473]

I like Issac at halfback or five eight (either). Seymour and Maloney are very similar players. Issac John (while still very young) brings something different.

 

[Mixmasterreece]

Isaac has torn his ACL and needs season ending surgery