Is Madden 05 the Greatest sports game ever

[CJG 182]

*Double*

 

[strong_latte]

Well I'm done arguing with you. I went a bit over board in my first post above and yeh sorry for that but your mind is made up and no one is gunna change that. And I do agree with one thing though. League is a lot better.

Goes both ways, I admit that I probably went a bit over board on this topic and yeah everyone is entitled to their own opinion... We'll all just leave it at that and get back on topic aye?
So do you think Madden 2005 is the greatest sports game of all time? Well as someone who doesn't like american football I can't seriously comment, but I do acknoledge that the games are of high technical quality... that said all the people I know who do like NFL say that ESPN 2k5 is better than Madden anyway...

 

[booeycollector]

yep

 

[ak47]

I own ESPN 2004 and that was better than Madden 2004
I now own Madden 2005 coz ESPN is not out in australia yet (well i cant find it)
when ESPN 2005 does come out, i will be swapping with Madden 2005, coz ESPN have had a better NFL product than EA for the past 3 years.

However - i'd have to disagree that neither is the best sports game of all time.

Either Jonah Lomu Rugby, or PES4 (Pro Evolution soccer4) are the greatest sports games of all time, closely followed by Tiger Woods 2005.

I watch more NFL and RL, than i watch Soccer and union combined so, dont think i am biased.
But i play ps2 more than anything, and for video game that best represent their reflective sports - JLR or PES4, are the icing on the cake.

However when ESPN and EA team up next year with Madden2006 - that will be one hell of a game!!!!!

 

[-JJ-]

ESPN 2K5 just came out in NZ, I think it came out the week before in Aus.

 

[Manu Vatuvei]

PES4. And if I was compiling a top 10, it would consist entirely of PES and ISS games.

 

[canberra_raiders2k2]

Trust me play espn nfl 2k5...the game hands down destroys every other football sim.

 

[strong_latte]

Trust me play espn nfl 2k5...the game hands down destroys every other football sim.

What about PES4? Most people say that is better than anything else sports related...