Opinion Is Ricky Stuart the most overrated coach ever?

[millersnose]

Who should have won the Dally Ms:
FB: ben barba
W: femi
C: Jack Bird
5/8: Michael Speechley
HB: Chad
L: Gal
2R: Wayde Graham
P: Micheal Prior
H: Michael Ennis
Capt: Gal
Coach: Peter Sharp
Rep player: Gal
Provan/Summons: gal
Ken Stephens: Fifita
Rookie: Luke Lewis

Right shark groupies?

Well no
I think papali was dudded and thought Maloney didn't really deserve 5/8
Bj was clearly the best centre
This is a thread about Ricky Stuart

 

[AWESOME PERSON]

Who's Michael Prior?

 

[AlwaysGreen]

Well no
I think papali was dudded and thought Maloney didn't really deserve 5/8
Bj was clearly the best centre
This is a thread about Ricky Stuart

Dominated in the last few weeks, including in a week that their in their first legit grand final in nearly 40 years by sharks fans.

 

[Cloudsurfer]

To win coach of the year is just that, doesn't mean he's a super coach, only time will determine that so I'm sticking with overrated at this stage. Has he pulled the team together & they've performed for him to deserve the accolade this year, probably yes. Ahead of others? Personally don't think so.
My problem with Ricky is what looks like a show of humility in pressers etc. Mr. Nice , Mr Humble. Must have had some media coaching to keep the petulance under control.

The comparable is that Croker appears to be a genuinely humble guy, just wish every time we see him he doesn't look like he's about to cry...

 

[Pete Cash]

Croker has resting cry face.

 

[AWESOME PERSON]

Dominated in the last few weeks, including in a week that their in their first legit grand final in nearly 40 years by sharks fans.

The super league grand final was indeed legit. Both those teams would've hammered any of the ARL sides that year.

 

[Generalzod]

Surely Flanno should be coach of the year...

 

[Pete Cash]

I think the award only takes the regular season into account

 

[carcharias]

I think the award only takes the regular season into account

Lucky for Ricky then because his finals campaign was absolute rubbish .

All hail Flano of the Shire!

 

[millersnose]

On the bright side the Viking clap parody has become so much fun since Ricky whinged about it being " disrespectful"

 

[AlwaysGreen]

Sharks win first premiership after 50 years of trying.

3 days later sharks groupies still obsessing over a former coach.

Not parody but still laughable.

 

[Generalzod]

Sharks win first premiership after 50 years of trying.

3 days later sharks groupies still obsessing over a former coach.

Not parody but still laughable.

Didn't Ricky say before the Melbourne game that Canberra will win the premiership this year? Ricky must have been hurtin him to see Flanno lift that trophy.

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sp...l/news-story/56e29663ded422c29cf63c0eaf800e08

 

[myrrh ken]

On the bright side the Viking clap parody has become so much fun since Ricky whinged about it being " disrespectful"

We had the fin slap first anyway

 

[myrrh ken]

Didn't Ricky say before the Melbourne game that Canberra will win the premiership this year? Ricky must have been hurtin him to see Flanno lift that trophy.

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sp...l/news-story/56e29663ded422c29cf63c0eaf800e08

Knew they were destined to lose that game after that. Coaching cliche 101 Ricky: one game at a time. Don't play with your players heads

 

[AlwaysGreen]

Didn't Ricky say before the Melbourne game that Canberra will win the premiership this year? Ricky must have been hurtin him to see Flanno lift that trophy.

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sp...l/news-story/56e29663ded422c29cf63c0eaf800e08

please don't recruit me to daily telegraph prescriptions.

The point is this. You won. Most fans with a brain in their heads are happy for you. Yet their seems to be this preoccupation with Sharks fans to snipe at everyone.

Flano is a big boy. He's got a jack gibson medal. He doesn't need sharks fans to defend his honour

 

[betcats]

please don't recruit me to daily telegraph prescriptions.

The point is this. You won. Most fans with a brain in their heads are happy for you. Yet their seems to be this preoccupation with Sharks fans to snipe at everyone.

Flano is a big boy. He's got a jack gibson medal. He doesn't need sharks fans to defend his honour

They been waiting 50 years mate you cant expect them to know how to act after finally winning one.

 

[Generalzod]

please don't recruit me to daily telegraph prescriptions.

The point is this. You won. Most fans with a brain in their heads are happy for you. Yet their seems to be this preoccupation with Sharks fans to snipe at everyone.

Flano is a big boy. He's got a jack gibson medal. He doesn't need sharks fans to defend his honour

He left the Sharks the Roosters and the EELS in a mess...

 

[AlwaysGreen]

He left the Sharks the Roosters and the EELS in a mess...

So what?
You've just won the premiership. I'm sure in the 50 years you didn't win won one you've had dud coaches. Yet it's all about Ricky.

He's ours to deal with now.

 

[Walt Flanigan]

Eels were already a mess and still are.

As for the Roosters, if he gets us 3 grand finals and a premiership he can leave the club however he likes.

 

[myrrh ken]

They been waiting 50 years mate you cant expect them to know how to act after finally winning one.

There's some truth to that!

Yet their seems to be this preoccupation with Sharks fans to snipe at everyone.

Not everyone, just Ricky and Canberra fans. It just feels right.