What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Joel Monaghan quits Raiders over Twitter pic

Should he be banned from the game for life?

  • Yes

    Votes: 137 47.1%
  • No

    Votes: 154 52.9%

  • Total voters
    291
  • Poll closed .

Razor

Coach
Messages
10,077
Some of you really just don't get it do ya. It's like you don't want the league to at least have a reasonable image, it's not about you, it's about the mums, dads, kids, general public..it's what they think, and they don't need a beatup in the media to think like that.

Look at the NFL - one of the most successful sporting competitions in the world. They have plenty of players playing for them that have been convicted for assault, sexual offenses, etc. Look at Mike Tyson. Look at other sports. No other sport carries on like the NRL does.

Look at the AFL - whenever their players are charged with anything - glassing their partner, assault, etc. the AFL comes out and says "Nothing to do with us". The NRL come out with their moral outrage having press conferences and press releases, guaranteeing massive media attention.
 

Kiki

First Grade
Messages
6,349
thanks dude!

god people why are u spending ur time googling to see if it comes up in other countries? WHO CARES?

i'm all for a discussion on how it will affect the image of the game in Australia, NZ and England but....Switzerland?! they probably think it's rugby union.

most people in the world don't even know there IS a different rugby code.

i wanna amend this to include the Pacific Islands because they are a crucial part of the current game, as well as future development.

this whole scandal is epically unfortunate for everyone involved. i hate seeing the game i love being put through the ringer AGAIN.
 

Raider_69

Post Whore
Messages
61,174
i wanna amend this to include the Pacific Islands because they are a crucial part of the current game, as well as future development.

this whole scandal is epically unfortunate for everyone involved. i hate seeing the game i love being put through the ringer AGAIN.

the games rep has gone to the dogs
 
Messages
16,034
i have sad he should be deregistered and banned for life

if it rates well the networks will want and pay for it

dickhead

And El Diablo you dont think any parents will be stopping their kids and not watching it themselves after this?

Also you dont think it will affect a parents choice when it comes to little johnny playing soccer or league?

If not ur a twonk!
 

Apey

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
28,293
I'm with R69 and others. I can't believe some people are treating him harsher than how they would treat the wife-beaters, the druggos and the alleged rapists. I can understand more attention and 'interest' - because what he did was f**king weird and highly, highly disturbing but as far as damage done to the victims for scandals it doesn't rank as high as beating up women and numerous other scandals we've been through for me.
 
Last edited:

Razor

Coach
Messages
10,077
And El Diablo you dont think any parents will be stopping their kids and not watching it themselves after this?

Also you dont think it will affect a parents choice when it comes to little johnny playing soccer or league?

If not ur a twonk!

No normal parent would stop watching the sport or stop their kids from watching the sport because of this. Notice I said normal parent. Soccer is already the most played sport by kids, and it won't change a normal parents decision on allowing their kids to play League or not.
 

Apey

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
28,293
I should clarify - I was talking about the actual 'event' in my last post. While I personally don't think it was our worst scandal, I believe it will be our worst as far as damage to the game's image goes.
 

Lambretta

First Grade
Messages
8,689
And El Diablo you dont think any parents will be stopping their kids and not watching it themselves after this?

Also you dont think it will affect a parents choice when it comes to little johnny playing soccer or league?

If not ur a twonk!

If there were dogs licking players c**ks on Friday night football, I'd say there was a fair chance that parents wouldnt want their kids watching.

Actually with FNF the late kick offs are enough to stop kids watching anyway.

BUT - I doubt if this incident will actually stop anyone tuning in to watch a game in March 2011. By then, Monaghan will not be playing for anyone and no one else will mention it.

Unless you think that Vossy, Gus and Andrew Johns are going to be giving us all a blow by blow account in 5 months time. Errr so to speak.
 

chefman21

Juniors
Messages
1,220
thanks dude!

god people why are u spending ur time googling to see if it comes up in other countries? WHO CARES?

i'm all for a discussion on how it will affect the image of the game in Australia, NZ and England but....Switzerland?! they probably think it's rugby union.

most people in the world don't even know there IS a different rugby code.

Wow.... What a backward thinking philosophy on promoting this game. People want to make it an international game. Judging by the countless threads on international expansion and improvement you do. Of course it f**king matters what other countries think of the code. People want more money coming into the code. Yet the first image sponsors and new fans get of this code is one of the games best players with his genitalia in a dogs mouth. It's entirely negative publicity in multiple countries. There are no positives from this. None. And the more incidents that occur the more likely this code won't expand into big markets such as Asia and Europe.
 

Lambretta

First Grade
Messages
8,689
No normal parent would stop watching the sport or stop their kids from watching the sport because of this. Notice I said normal parent. Soccer is already the most played sport by kids, and it won't change a normal parents decision on allowing their kids to play League or not.

I don't agree. Parents wont let their kids play football. Wayne Rooney shags grandmas and most of the other are coke snorting, wife beaters.

Sif anyone would let their kids watch or play a sport where some professionals are less than angelic. It would never happen. Never. The game of football doesn't exist.

(the above post may not be strictly 100% serious)
 

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
And El Diablo you dont think any parents will be stopping their kids and not watching it themselves after this?

Also you dont think it will affect a parents choice when it comes to little johnny playing soccer or league?

If not ur a twonk!

so parents decide what sport they'll play based on Joel Monaghan :lol:
 

Borat.

Juniors
Messages
1,352
Phil kearns has been implicated in a similar indecent.... link coming

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/sport/co...00013/Mr-Big-is-really-Munsters-nice-guy.html

The recollection had reminded him of the time he was part of an Australian squad preparing for the 1999 World Cup final against France. "We had one of those video conferencing systems where players could talk to and see their wives and kids back in Australia. Any way, in the week before the final, Phil Kearns, who had been injured and had returned home, was using one to send us a good-luck message.
"He was talking to the guys and when he walked into shot it was obvious that he had no shirt on. I thought he just had no top on but his wife, who was holding the video camera, panned down to reveal that Phil was stark naked. Better than that, his dog - he had a big Alsatian - then walked over, nudged him in the nuts and started licking. I've never seen anything like it.
"We found out afterwards that Phil had rubbed jam or honey into his groin to get his dog to do that on cue. It was his way of settling down the squad who were really tense and worried at the final coming up."
There's nowhere to go after that..


If true that takes the cake - not drunk and wife involved!
 
Last edited:

Ridders

Coach
Messages
10,831
It's over 1000!!!

over9000ry4.jpg
 

Batman Returns

Juniors
Messages
294
Pretty pathetic of Alexander if he did say something like that. I'll contact some media friends on this side of the Tasman, draw their attention to what he's said, and see if they can find and use the footage....I think this crap needs closer examination. We don't need these slurs from a so-called legend coming up with a pitiful attempt to divert attention from the scrutiny his country is coming under world-wide. Where's his proof???? Enough is enough. You've got guys like Kearns and Monaghan who like to get up to this kind of stuff; no need to drag NZ into this.

Bloody dog-shaggers.
 

God-King Dean

Immortal
Messages
46,614
I bring this up everytime with The Outraged (I'll call em that from now on) when there's a scandal, but it never gets answered.

I'll ask it again:

If this damages the game, & parents won't want there kiddies watching/playing League - then why is it every single year crowds & rating increase?
 

Kiki

First Grade
Messages
6,349
Wow.... What a backward thinking philosophy on promoting this game. People want to make it an international game. Judging by the countless threads on international expansion and improvement you do. Of course it f**king matters what other countries think of the code. People want more money coming into the code. Yet the first image sponsors and new fans get of this code is one of the games best players with his genitalia in a dogs mouth. It's entirely negative publicity in multiple countries. There are no positives from this. None. And the more incidents that occur the more likely this code won't expand into big markets such as Asia and Europe.

mate, please. people making threads on an internet forum doesn't mean much. no one IN rugby league has illusions of making it a popular sport in places like Switzerland.

first things first, we should be able to have a Four Nations where more than 2 teams are actual contenders. that's what international development is focused on right now (or should be).
 

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
going by some posters logic no children would attend school based on all the various stories of pedo teachers that come out each year
 

Latest posts

Top