What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

The Game Judiciary & Match Review charges - 2022 season

Chimp

Bench
Messages
2,855
It’s one of the areas where the NRL have completely messed up - how can accidental ‘dangerous contact’ (head clashes, contact with head when attacker slips into what would otherwise have been a legal tackle, Nikora style ‘hip drop’ where it was just the momentum of the tackle that led to his body swinging into legs of attacker) be punished more severely than deliberate acts that are only ever intended to injure (these elbow/forearm drops). Yes proving ‘intent’ is difficult, these cases are cut and dried - whether they actually caused substantial damage or not, they’re purposely, actively making dangerous contact - that type of act should be the most harshly punished of all.
 

Frailty

First Grade
Messages
9,454
NRL wanted to simplify the system because prior offence loading was "too difficult".
So they created a system where a player can get fined 25 times in a season as long as they keep getting graded as a grade 1.

That being said - how NAS' forearm is only considered a Grade 1, I will never understand.
 

League Unlimited News

Administrator
Staff member
Messages
8,682

Match Review Charges​

PlayerChargePleaSuspension/Fine
Asu Kepaoa (Wests Tigers)Grade 2 Careless High Tackle TBC1-2 matches
Isaac Liu (Titans)Grade 1 Crusher TackleTBC$1500-$2000 fine
Brian Kelly (Titans)Grade 3 Dangerous ThrowTBC4-5 matches
Coen Hess (Cowboys)Grade 2 Careless High TackleTBC1-2 matches
Lindsay Collins (Roosters)Grade 3 Dangerous ContactTBC4-5 matches
Victory Radley (Roosters)Grade 1 Dangerous Contact TBC$1800-$2500 fine
Jared Waerea-Hargreaves (Roosters)Grade 1 Contrary ConductTBC$3000 fine - 2 matches
Nelson Asofa-Solomona (Storm)Grade 1 Dangerous Contact TBC$3000 fine - 2 matches
Jordan Riki (Broncos)Grade 1 Shoulder ChargeTBC$3000 fine - 2 matches
Reagan Campbell-Gillard (Eels)Grade 1 Dangerous ContactTBC$1000-$1500 fine

 

lockyno1

Post Whore
Messages
53,345
As usual JWH lining up for another week to get fined. They need to bring in the 3 fines equal a week ban. It's ridiculous you can have 5 fines in a season. NAS was worse too.

Collins about right was an ugly tackle.

Kelly, think he's a bit unlucky but can't say it wasn't ugly.
 
Messages
12,484
As usual JWH lining up for another week to get fined. They need to bring in the 3 fines equal a week ban. It's ridiculous you can have 5 fines in a season. NAS was worse too.

Collins about right was an ugly tackle.

Kelly, think he's a bit unlucky but can't say it wasn't ugly.
At least Jared gets fined. Munster does what he wants
 

Timmah

LeagueUnlimited News Editor
Staff member
Messages
100,986
As usual JWH lining up for another week to get fined. They need to bring in the 3 fines equal a week ban. It's ridiculous you can have 5 fines in a season. NAS was worse too.

Collins about right was an ugly tackle.

Kelly, think he's a bit unlucky but can't say it wasn't ugly.
In other words, we need to bring back the previous system, which was replaced because repeat offenders kept getting suspended around finals time 🤔
 

Munky

Coach
Messages
12,200
In other words, we need to bring back the previous system, which was replaced because repeat offenders kept getting suspended around finals time 🤔

They don't want the star players missing with suspension for the finals.

Except what happens when a star player is missing from injury because of a grub act committed purely due to the perpetrator knowing the risk/reward is in their favour?
 

lockyno1

Post Whore
Messages
53,345
In other words, we need to bring back the previous system, which was replaced because repeat offenders kept getting suspended around finals time 🤔

Then don’t do repeated infringements pretty simple really. 3 fines is PLENTY get the message and don’t thug it up.
 
Messages
4,310
In other words, we need to bring back the previous system, which was replaced because repeat offenders kept getting suspended around finals time 🤔
f**k this sport continually makes it much harder than it has to be.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Warriors Fever

Juniors
Messages
1,752
Guarantee if nas was at a lowly club he would have a lot more suspensions to his name. Is it any wonder nrl fans call conspiracy when the same clubs are let off the hook. What do the bosses of Melbourne have over the nrl? Something incriminating obviously
 

BWNB

First Grade
Messages
7,971
Oh ffs how come Hess only got a week, should have been 3. Dale got 3 for an accident
 

BWNB

First Grade
Messages
7,971
Didn’t he get offered 1 week and you blokes challenged it (we all told you how dumb that decision was).
Nope he was charged with a head 3 offence meaning he would miss 3 weeks with an early guilty plea.
 

shaggs

Coach
Messages
11,143
Nope he was charged with a head 3 offence meaning he would miss 3 weeks with an early guilty plea.
I thought it was 3 weeks and got downgraded to 2. Plead guilty but challenged the grading.

Who knows. Basically if you have plenty to use for fines then elbow away. Precedent has been set.
 

Latest posts

Top