Judiciary

[redv13]

Has there been any mention of the tackle on Sua?

Was a great tackle that JWH does every week. Nil issues, play on

 

[jak]

1 week !!!??? he gets 1 week for the worst stiff arm tackle since Les Boyd broke Daryl Brohman's jaw

is it to late for uncle nick to have it downgraded?

 

[Trifili13]

The Bunker said it was not as bad as what it looked like - pointless saying anything else the decision was made.

Fox have too many there with their own agenda's so your not going to get unbiased opinions on incidents in games or on the game itself.

I find Fox to be detrimental to the game myself which coincides with the way Murdoch operates his newspapers and other media outlets.

Has way to much say and influence just like his Criminal Americansky country does.

Bunker also said it was a shepherd, pointless you arguing the Dragon's player would not have tackled him. Can't have it both ways.

I agree that Fox commentators have their own agenda but to exclude the 9 commentators from being bias is laughable. You must watch the games on mute.

 

[The_Frog]

is it to late for uncle nick to have it downgraded?

When the CEO of the NRL says it should have been a sin bin, Nick would realise that discretion is the better part of valour. Save your bullets for a winnable battle. At the same time I can just see PVL having a quiet word with Abdo about the wisdom of buying into judiciary matters publicly right about now.

 

[blaza88z]

I thought Hook said it perfectly

He had 30 metres to decide where to hit him and that's where he hit him

 

[St Tangles]

Has there been any mention of the tackle on Sua?

Touched on at the end of Annesly's weekly defence of the ridiculous

Deemed an accident

 

[blaza88z]

I think it's also laughable that Nanai from the Cowboys got sin binned for what has been deemed as a fine and Tupou will almost certainly miss at least 1 week but was allowed to stay on the field

 

[marshall stalin]

Well said True!

Nothing more needs to be said. You've missed my point and shown your ignorance.

Nothing more needs to be said. You've missed my point and shown your ignorance.

Your families ignorance you should say likening a football game to battles and war - you have to be kidding

My brother is a Chooks supporter and messaged me saying "The best team won on the day. They showed a resolve that would make the diggers proud." That's what the day should mean to supporters of both teams.

 

[marshall stalin]

Well said True!

Incorrectly said in likening a football game to battles and war one has to say

 

[2010Dragons]

Touched on at the end of Annesly's weekly defence of the ridiculous

Deemed an accident

regarding the tupou careless high tackles. Annessley said he should have gone to the sin bin and basically said that if a player stays down then the referees look more at sin binning the culprit.
Referee Adam Gee will be refereeing park footy this week and Ashley Klein should just retire.

Well that will do me!!!!
Hook needs to bring in some trained actors to teach the boys how to lie down like a dog or get some tips from Tedesco.

WTF has happened to the game I once played and loved?

 

[marshall stalin]

Haaa why do use a German nazi name then?? Anyway go back to your chookpen then, and by the way there’s no chance that your steggles will be in the GF either.
Can’t wait for Teddy to miss a few games as without him lucky to scrape into the 8

You are rather Ignorant in the west one has to say- Comrade General Secretary Marshal Stalin Supreme Leader of the Great Soviet Union who led the Great Soviet Union to victory over the Criminal Nazi Germanic hordes in the Great Patriotic War

Uncle Joe left and right the Great Soviet Union forces raising the Hammer and Sickle over the Criminal Nazi Germanic Hordes Reichstag in their Criminal Berlin Capital - 1000 Year Criminal Reich lasted only 12 years

 

[Gourley's Socks]

...I can just see PVL having a quiet word with Abdo about the wisdom of buying into judiciary matters publicly...

But only when they involve Easts or Melbourne.

 

[marshall stalin]

1 week !!!??? he gets 1 week for the worst stiff arm tackle since Les Boyd broke Daryl Brohman's jaw

shouldn't get anything a mere tap all it was - no previous suspensions or reportings in his previous 10 years of NRL should count for something

 

[KogarahWarrior]

shouldn't get anything a mere tap all it was - no previous suspensions or reportings in his previous 10 years of NRL should count for something

Hahaha idk why you're still trying to prove this, nobody's going to agree with you on a Dragons forum. Actually, nobody's going to agree with you on any forum other than the Roosters one. And even most of the Roosters supporters won't agree with you, because you're wrong. It was not a 'mere tap'. It was a head-high clothesline and completely dangerous, but you seem to be acting like you would have handled it with ease.

 

[justadragon]

Can some please explain to me how a hip drop tackle is deemed an accident, the person making that tackle is in complete control throughout the tackle and can let go at anytime, plus lets not forget that Tupou finished Su'a off when he was already in a compromised position, both players are at fault there and both should have received some punishment, why couldnt McGuire or Fui say it was and accident, that is because they followed through with the tackle.

 

[Como Connection]

Bunker also said it was a shepherd, pointless you arguing the Dragon's player would not have tackled him. Can't have it both ways.

I agree that Fox commentators have their own agenda but to exclude the 9 commentators from being bias is laughable. You must watch the games on mute.

I suggest you ignore him as I have.
CC

 

[Dragon David]

Incorrectly said in likening a football game to battles and war one has to say

My liking True Believer's post is my opinion particularly with him saying "My brother is a Chooks supporter and messaged me saying "The best team won on the day. They showed a resolve that would make the diggers proud." That's what the day should mean to supporters of both teams.".

You know that the Dragons supporters have the right to express their views after yesterday's Dragons' victory over your team. You had that right for the past 3 years so you had plenty to gloat about then.

The match review committee has charged Tupou and he is suspended for one week. Just be grateful that that was all he was given and that there were no other players from your team charged.

 

[rasaint]

JWH hip drop has taken out our player Sua ( best back rower) probably 6 to 12 weeks. Are hip drops now ‘accidents’ if you are part of one of the elitist teams?

Was Radley’s apparent shoulder charge on Lawrie simply dismissed by a Judiciary? Are shoulder charges now accidents if you are part of one of the elitist teams? No one seems to want to comment on this interesting incident in the game. Radley turned side on and no discernible arm wrap I could see. He did come off second best in the end.

 

[BLM01]

Can some please explain to me how a hip drop tackle is deemed an accident, the person making that tackle is in complete control throughout the tackle and can let go at anytime, plus lets not forget that Tupou finished Su'a off when he was already in a compromised position, both players are at fault there and both should have received some punishment, why couldnt McGuire or Fui say it was and accident, that is because they followed through with the tackle.

Fui's was definitely an accident as grabbed him from behind and had weak hand grips on shorts only.
The only way to get him to ground was to pull him back down towards himself.
Been happening for 100 years.
Who started all this hip drop tackle stuff and definition anyway and what game allows players to struggle for hours in the tackle waiting for a held call inviting all this wrestle and 3rd man in stuff.

 

[marshall stalin]

JWH hip drop has taken out our player Sua ( best back rower) probably 6 to 12 weeks. Are hip drops now ‘accidents’ if you are part of one of the elitist teams?

Was Radley’s apparent shoulder charge on Lawrie simply dismissed by a Judiciary? Are shoulder charges now accidents if you are part of one of the elitist teams? No one seems to want to comment on this interesting incident in the game. Radley turned side on and no discernible arm wrap I could see. He did come off second best in the end.

Not a hip drop at all by JWH and nothing in Radley's tackle either.