What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Kapow - sandow

oldmancraigy

Coach
Messages
11,980
does not surprise me , clearly he turned some games . I have always been a supporter of Sandow from start and have defended him against a lot of the cum lately parra fans in the past who now think he is kapow. My criticism since his signing with Eels has been one of VALUE. I have no issue with Souths not matching the eels offer for sandow , you have paid overs and this is where critic of his weakness comes to play. Good luck with him next year. I would assume his pay and now the $750k PA plus for the manly winger will provide plenty of disruption to team harmony .

We paid Sandow $1.7k over 4 years. (or so the reports suggest)
That's an average of $425k per year.
That's for your best player - the bloke who almost dragged your overpaid overhyped mugs into the top 8.
Wait until he gets to play with some real talent (Hayne) or with a 5/8 who doesn't always overcall him (Roberts) or behind a couple of props who don't just make meters, but get quick play-the-balls (Fui/Mannah).
Sandow will look better for us than he did for you - and it just so happens that he plays a position that we were SO WEAK that you yourself Galeforce would've been an improvement on the duffers we had run out there. Just so happens to be the most important position on the footy field in terms of attacking structure and so getting results in the win column.

If you don't think Sandow is worth $425k then you need to ask yourself which halfbacks in the comp are? It's the most important position on the paddock, so if anyone is worth $425k it's a halfback - especially a very young one who just got named best player for his club and already has 4 years first grade experience.
 
Messages
12,179
We paid Sandow $1.7k over 4 years. (or so the reports suggest)
That's an average of $425k per year.
That's for your best player - the bloke who almost dragged your overpaid overhyped mugs into the top 8.
Wait until he gets to play with some real talent (Hayne) or with a 5/8 who doesn't always overcall him (Roberts) or behind a couple of props who don't just make meters, but get quick play-the-balls (Fui/Mannah).
Sandow will look better for us than he did for you - and it just so happens that he plays a position that we were SO WEAK that you yourself Galeforce would've been an improvement on the duffers we had run out there. Just so happens to be the most important position on the footy field in terms of attacking structure and so getting results in the win column.

If you don't think Sandow is worth $425k then you need to ask yourself which halfbacks in the comp are? It's the most important position on the paddock, so if anyone is worth $425k it's a halfback - especially a very young one who just got named best player for his club and already has 4 years first grade experience.
mate ive given up on trying to use logic with souths supporters let them all think he's no great loss until they try playing without him next year
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,408
If you don't think Sandow is worth $425k then you need to ask yourself which halfbacks in the comp are? It's the most important position on the paddock, so if anyone is worth $425k it's a halfback - especially a very young one who just got named best player for his club and already has 4 years first grade experience.

Exactly.

Given the importance of halfbacks, and their current undersupply, someone like Luke Walsh would be worth $300k on the open market, and he's only average.

Maybe this time last year Sandow wouldn't have been worth $400k+ but right now it's a very fair price for a match winner who can break the line and kicks so well.
 

Whos Ya Daddy

First Grade
Messages
5,699
Sandow is a turnstyle.

Sure he cuts a good highlight package but he just can't defend to save his life, he let in the match losing try so many times last season.

He's not a first grader whilst that happens, I don't care how good he is in attack.

And you want to have Ben Roberts on the field at the same time? lol
 

TheParraboy

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
69,273
I think Sandow will be worth 1 million a year off contract at the eels after we win 2 or 3 premierships in the next few years
 

Eels Dude

Coach
Messages
19,065
Sandow is a turnstyle.

Sure he cuts a good highlight package but he just can't defend to save his life, he let in the match losing try so many times last season.

He's not a first grader whilst that happens, I don't care how good he is in attack.

And you want to have Ben Roberts on the field at the same time? lol

Most halfbacks are poor defenders... it's how you hide them on the field that matters and Souths were coached poorly there.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,408
And you want to have Ben Roberts on the field at the same time? lol

Are you kidding? Roberts is a good defensive half.

As for Sandow, we've got enough good defenders who work hard that we can hide him. Souths' problem was that they have far too many players that either don't work hard in defence (e.g. Sutton, Luke) or just plain aren't good enough defenders (e.g. Taylor, Sandow).

Souths would be better off with someone like Ben Hornby at halfback. Even Ben Smith would be better for them than most of their back-rowers. At times this year Michael Crocker was the only Souths defender worth feeding. Him and McQueen who was stuck on the wing all year.

Sandow will be perfect for us because he's the complete opposite to most of our players.
 

jk13

First Grade
Messages
6,229
It still baffles me on this site that souffs supporters think they are an authority on anything. God bless them.
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,408
If Reynolds can kick I don't think Souths will miss Sandow as much as we'll gain from signing him.

They have attacking talent all across the park, as well as the aforementioned defensive issues.
 

jk13

First Grade
Messages
6,229
God help Reynolds if he misses a tackle or let's a try in. It's not like the good teams r gonna target him...
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,408
Sandow could well end up being our best ever signing, after Jack Gibson at least.

Depends how good he ends up becoming (Sandow, not Gibson).
 

Poupou Escobar

Post Whore
Messages
92,408
Jack's Joker also had his cheeks torn. I believe Batman fired one of his gadgets that shot through both sides of his face right before he fell into the chemical vat.

True story.
 

Latest posts

Top