What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

LU Panthers Forum Player of the Year

OldPanther

Coach
Messages
13,404
Im a drunk sad panther fan. No need to ever listen to me mate

Sad drunk you still had a good idea haha. Seems like a fair way to do it.

I'm angry and want to make a video about our lack of attack but resisting because want to be only positive on the channel haha.

Also hope you're ok and it's just the game got you down?
 

Dave's mate

Juniors
Messages
1,783
Sad drunk you still had a good idea haha. Seems like a fair way to do it.

I'm angry and want to make a video about our lack of attack but resisting because want to be only positive on the channel haha.

Also hope you're ok and it's just the game got you down?
Yeah life is mostly great otherwise haha
 

TheFrog

Coach
Messages
14,300
Ok I'll go back and edit with that in mind as a rule.
It's up to the individual how what system they use to mark players. I use the RLW system, which favours middle scores (4-7), but this is by no means compulsory. Players who play fewer minutes are often going to get lower scores, but that's up to you too. Don't listen to anyone trying to tell you how you should do it, just do what you think. It becomes a consensus only by combining the scores.
 

Fangs

Coach
Messages
14,364
It's up to the individual how what system they use to mark players. I use the RLW system, which favours middle scores (4-7), but this is by no means compulsory. Players who play fewer minutes are often going to get lower scores, but that's up to you too. Don't listen to anyone trying to tell you how you should do it, just do what you think. It becomes a consensus only by combining the scores.

Agreed Frog.

Here's looking at your Fangs':

Round 20

Edwards 7 (tried bloody hard)
Mansour 3
Whare 2
Naden 4
To'o 6
Maloney 5
Cleary 4 (Special mention, very poor. Run and pass doesn't cut it mate)
Tamou 5
Kenny 3
Fisher-Harris 7
Martin 7
Winterstein 5
Yeo 5

Egan 4
Luai 2
Leota 6
Campbell-Gillard 4
 

Panfa

Juniors
Messages
1,266
Edwards 5= safe but 1st tackle obstruction killed us and changed the game Mansour 4= no speed for a winger and has lost his aggression needs to go whare 3= spent more time taking hitups then staying wide bad defensive read for dogs 2nd try Naden 4=butchered a certain try by trying to pick up the ball in goal scored 1 try but has gone backwards last 2 weeks T'oo 5= strong runner of the ball needs to stay wider in attack and go in when his centre goes in to close down opp attack Maloney 4= clueless attacking performance bad hands superleague will be a perfect fit for you enjoy the $$$ Cleary 3= Worst halfback in the comp no try assists has 1 move run across field and then pass back inside to a centre or backrower Yeo 4 =Whats happened to this bloke thought he got in the way of our centres yesterday and killed our attack Martin = 8 player of the match without a doubt strongest defender and was dangerous everytime he ran the ball with purpose Winterstein 3 =why is he only used in the first 15 mins then gets subbed and not put back on waste of a player in our 17 Tamou 5= As a captain needs to lead more from the front big fella is starting to slow down a bit now Kenny 4= not giving quick enough ball outwide like he did a few weeks ago and shocking miss 1 on 1 for bulldogs 3rd try why defend a hooker from a scrum is beyond me Fisher harris 7= outstanding game again playing frontrower runs hard tireless in defence always a threat egan 4= he needs to be more creative the better attacking hooker of the 2 needs to realise his potential Luai 2= didnt get much game time got injured after 10 mins hard to give a true score Leota 6= hes starting to improve getting his aggressive runs and defence back now Campbell gillard 4= not running with any real purpose comes off the bench when opposition teams are buggered and still cant make an impact.
 

OldPanther

Coach
Messages
13,404
It's up to the individual how what system they use to mark players. I use the RLW system, which favours middle scores (4-7), but this is by no means compulsory. Players who play fewer minutes are often going to get lower scores, but that's up to you too. Don't listen to anyone trying to tell you how you should do it, just do what you think. It becomes a consensus only by combining the scores.

I agree with you. I just liked his way of thinking there so feel like adoption that style.
 

OldPanther

Coach
Messages
13,404
Edwards 5= safe but 1st tackle obstruction killed us and changed the game Mansour 4= no speed for a winger and has lost his aggression needs to go whare 3= spent more time taking hitups then staying wide bad defensive read for dogs 2nd try Naden 4=butchered a certain try by trying to pick up the ball in goal scored 1 try but has gone backwards last 2 weeks T'oo 5= strong runner of the ball needs to stay wider in attack and go in when his centre goes in to close down opp attack Maloney 4= clueless attacking performance bad hands superleague will be a perfect fit for you enjoy the $$$ Cleary 3= Worst halfback in the comp no try assists has 1 move run across field and then pass back inside to a centre or backrower Yeo 4 =Whats happened to this bloke thought he got in the way of our centres yesterday and killed our attack Martin = 8 player of the match without a doubt strongest defender and was dangerous everytime he ran the ball with purpose Winterstein 3 =why is he only used in the first 15 mins then gets subbed and not put back on waste of a player in our 17 Tamou 5= As a captain needs to lead more from the front big fella is starting to slow down a bit now Kenny 4= not giving quick enough ball outwide like he did a few weeks ago and shocking miss 1 on 1 for bulldogs 3rd try why defend a hooker from a scrum is beyond me Fisher harris 7= outstanding game again playing frontrower runs hard tireless in defence always a threat egan 4= he needs to be more creative the better attacking hooker of the 2 needs to realise his potential Luai 2= didnt get much game time got injured after 10 mins hard to give a true score Leota 6= hes starting to improve getting his aggressive runs and defence back now Campbell gillard 4= not running with any real purpose comes off the bench when opposition teams are buggered and still cant make an impact.

I love when people write out explanations.

Poor Yep is playing busted. They are trying to manage him through the season although he needs surgery. He should've been sorted once June 30 happened but they won't.
 

Panfa

Juniors
Messages
1,266
I understand yeo is not 100% but its not like we dont have any guys who cant fill in theres Cartwright sele fuimaono or burns who could play 2nd row.
 

soc123_au

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
19,884
Edwards 7
Mansour 3
Whare 2
Naden 4
To'o 6
Maloney 5
Cleary 4
Tamou 6
Kenny 3
Fisher-Harris 7
Martin 7
Winterstein 5
Yeo 5

Egan 4
Luai 2
Leota 6
Campbell-Gillard 6
 

OldPanther

Coach
Messages
13,404
I understand yeo is not 100% but its not like we dont have any guys who cant fill in theres Cartwright sele fuimaono or burns who could play 2nd row.

Yep that's my gripe as well. He could have had surgery and been right to go for the off season.
 

Abacus

Juniors
Messages
2,128
I see 1's for Luai. Runs on gets poked in the eye......still had a better gane than either half
Simple, contributed nothing so he gets a low score. 6 minutes of game time is not a pass mark. I gave him a 1 because he contributed less than anyone else (except maybe Cleary).

We're talking player of the year ratings - you shouldn't get 5 points just for showing up. That cheapens the whole concept and rewards mediocrity.
 

Pomoz

Bench
Messages
2,997
I see 1's for Luai. Runs on gets poked in the eye......still had a better gane than either half
I think you might have been poked in the eye and can't see properly. Luai run around like a headless chicken for his six minutes on the field with an effective tackle percentage of 60%. Maloney had 64.7% effective tackle percentage a try assist and a line break assist and 2 forced drop outs. He made errors too, but he still delivered more than Luai, or Cleary. In Luai's defence he hardly had time to get into the game, but he didn't exactly set the world on fire.
 

TheFrog

Coach
Messages
14,300
Round 18 (Dragons) Average Ratings

Edwards 6.6
Mansour 7.0
Naden 7.9
Whare 6.4
To'o 7.9
Maloney 7.9
Cleary 8.0
Tamou 7.4
Kenny 7.1
Fisher-Harris 8.0
Kikau 6.9
Winterstein 6.1
Yeo 7.0

Egan 5.4
Luai 5.7
Leota 6.3
Campbell-Gillard 6.9

Standings will be updated with the Raiders ratings.
 

TheFrog

Coach
Messages
14,300
Round 19 (Raiders) Average Ratings

Edwards 8.3
Mansour 5.0
Naden 3.8
Whare 4.8
To'o 5.6
Maloney 6.8
Cleary 6.0
Tamou 6.8
Kenny 5.0
Fisher-Harris 7.6
Yeo 5.4
Winterstein 4.5
Martin 5.8

Egan 5.5
Luai 4.8
Leota 6.4
Campbell-Gillard 5.8

Standings (games)

1. Fisher-Harris 1207 (18)
2. Tamou 1177 (18)
3. Maloney 1052 (17)
4. Campbell-Gillard 955 (17)
5. Leota 930 (18)
6. Cleary 905 (15)
7. Mansour 878 (15)
8. Yeo 839 (14)
9. Kikau 803 (13)
10. Edwards 795 (14)
11. Egan 775 (14)
12. Whare 659 (13)
13. Martin 595 (10)
14. To'o 591 (9)
15. Winterstein 560 (11)
16. Luai 534 (11)
17. Blake 501 (10)
18. Kenny 481 (8)
19. Naden 480 (7)
20. DWZ 467 (10)
21. Katoa 467 (11)
22. Grant 335 (7)
23. Sele 279 (5)
24. Fuimaono 255 (6)
25. MWZ 206 (4)
26. Aekins 152 (3)
27. Hetherington 95 (2)
28. Ellis 54 (2)
29. Cartwright 46 (1)
 

OldPanther

Coach
Messages
13,404
Round 19 (Raiders) Average Ratings

Edwards 8.3
Mansour 5.0
Naden 3.8
Whare 4.8
To'o 5.6
Maloney 6.8
Cleary 6.0
Tamou 6.8
Kenny 5.0
Fisher-Harris 7.6
Yeo 5.4
Winterstein 4.5
Martin 5.8

Egan 5.5
Luai 4.8
Leota 6.4
Campbell-Gillard 5.8

Standings (games)

1. Fisher-Harris 1207 (18)
2. Tamou 1177 (18)
3. Maloney 1052 (17)
4. Campbell-Gillard 955 (17)
5. Leota 930 (18)
6. Cleary 905 (15)
7. Mansour 878 (15)
8. Yeo 839 (14)
9. Kikau 803 (13)
10. Edwards 795 (14)
11. Egan 775 (14)
12. Whare 659 (13)
13. Martin 595 (10)
14. To'o 591 (9)
15. Winterstein 560 (11)
16. Luai 534 (11)
17. Blake 501 (10)
18. Kenny 481 (8)
19. Naden 480 (7)
20. DWZ 467 (10)
21. Katoa 467 (11)
22. Grant 335 (7)
23. Sele 279 (5)
24. Fuimaono 255 (6)
25. MWZ 206 (4)
26. Aekins 152 (3)
27. Hetherington 95 (2)
28. Ellis 54 (2)
29. Cartwright 46 (1)

1. Fish
2. Daylight

Haha.

My video is up now a well so people can watch I posted it as it's own topic.
 

Kilkenny

Coach
Messages
13,878
I wish I was in a position to submit my ratings for each individual but I was at the game, had a few drinks, haven’t watched a replay so just am not in a position to accurately access individual performances.

Being at the game I thought as a team we all actually tried really hard we are just hopeless basically.

It is not through lack of effort, the effort was there just the execution is sadly lacking.

If I was going to give a 3-2-1 I would probably say our three best were Edwards, JFH & someone else perhaps To’o.

Much easier to give the minus 3-2-1 to the coaching staff because frankly what they do in between games is a great mystery given what the 17 dish up during game day.

I use to enjoy Matt Elliot’s post game press conference’s when he was famous for his didn’t see that coming or we didn’t perform like we trained all week but seriously our attack is worse than anything Elliot’s far inferior squad used to dish up so not quite sure where we are at currently.
 

Dave's mate

Juniors
Messages
1,783
I wish I was in a position to submit my ratings for each individual but I was at the game, had a few drinks, haven’t watched a replay so just am not in a position to accurately access individual performances.

Being at the game I thought as a team we all actually tried really hard we are just hopeless basically.

It is not through lack of effort, the effort was there just the execution is sadly lacking.

If I was going to give a 3-2-1 I would probably say our three best were Edwards, JFH & someone else perhaps To’o.

Much easier to give the minus 3-2-1 to the coaching staff because frankly what they do in between games is a great mystery given what the 17 dish up during game day.

I use to enjoy Matt Elliot’s post game press conference’s when he was famous for his didn’t see that coming or we didn’t perform like we trained all week but seriously our attack is worse than anything Elliot’s far inferior squad used to dish up so not quite sure where we are at currently.
Elliott had some very VERY good players. Just a complete dud of a coach
 

Latest posts

Top