LU Panthers Forum Player of the Year

[TheFrog]

I haven’t been adding ratings but I gotta say if I had to pick our most consistent performer all year it’s probably Tamou. JFH is right up there but he has to get the dumb penalty out of his game.

What balances that is JFH playing an extra 25 or so minutes per game. If he could lose the penalties he'd be truly elite.

 

[betcats]

What balances that is JFH playing an extra 25 or so minutes per game. If he could lose the penalties he'd be truly elite.

Agree

 

[TheFrog]

Round 20 (Bulldogs) Average Ratings

Edwards 6.3
Mansour 4.0
Whare 3.5
Naden 4.1
To'o 5.1
Maloney 4.6
Cleary 3.4
Tamou 5.9
Kenny 3.9
Fisher-Harris 7.5
Yeo 5.3
Winterstein 3.6
Martin 7.4

Egan 3.5
Luai 2.2
Leota 5.9
Campbell-Gillard 5.3

Standings with Sharks match.

 

[TheFrog]

Round 21 (Sharks) Average Ratings

Edwards 9.0
Mansour 6.9
Naden 6.0
Crichton 5.8
To'o 6.9
Burton 7.1
Cleary 8.8
Tamou 6.8
Kenny 6.8
Fisher-Harris 7.8
Kikau 7.1
Martin 7.6
Leota 6.3

Yeo 5.7
Leniu 4.9
Campbell-Gillard 4.8

Standings (games)

1. Fisher-Harris 1360 (20)
2. Tamou 1304 (20)
3. Maloney 1098 (18)
4. Campbell-Gillard 1056 (19)
5. Leota 1052 (20)
6. Cleary 1027 (17)
7. Mansour 987 (17)
8. Yeo 949 (16)
9. Edwards 948 (16)
10. Kikau 874 (14)
11. Egan 810 (15)
12. Martin 745 (12)
13. To'o 711 (11)
14. Whare 694 (14)
15. Winterstein 596 (12)
16. Kenny 588 (10)
17. Naden 581 (9)
18. Luai 556 (12)
19. Blake 501 (10)
20. DWZ 467 (10)
21. Katoa 467 (11)
22. Grant 335 (7)
23. Sele 279 (5)
24. Fuimaono 255 (6)
25. MWZ 206 (4)
26. Aekins 152 (3)
27. Hetherington 98 (2)
28. Burton 71 (1)
29. Crichton 58 (1)
30. Ellis 54 (2)
31. Leniu 49 (1)
32. Cartwright 46 (1)

Starting with round 22, players who have played over 20 games will start to lose their lowest ratings as per the rules.

 

[TheFrog]

Round 22 Broncos

Edwards 7
Mansour 6
Whare 6
Naden 4
To'o 7
Maloney 6
Cleary 6
Tamou 6
Kenny 6
Fisher-Harris 8
Kikau 6
Martin 5
Leota 7

Yeo 6
Katoa 5
Leniu 4
Campbell-Gillard 5

 

[age.s]

Edwards 7 - Good game again. Safe for the most part and some dangerous runs. Would have liked him to make try savers on Haas and Staggs but you can't have it all.
Mansour 5 - Some good runs but just no idea on the edge with Naden. Hard to know how much is on him but having your edge shredded like that isn't a good look.
Naden 4 - Another really poor game. I love his enthusiasm when attacking kicks but his defense isn't NRL standard. Very concerned that he's being regularly found out.
Whare 6 - Some good moments and some poor ones. Did well defensively as usual.
To'o 8 - The only bit of spark in our backline. Great work for his try and the usual hard meters out of our end.
Maloney 5 - Nothing in attack and run over in defense.
Cleary 5 - Not great. Nice work for his try but looked like a handbrake for most of the game. Has no idea what to do when Maloney is out there.
Tamou 6 - Haas try is on him. Did his usual thing otherwise.
Kenny 5 - A couple of really poor moments. Service was ok I guess. Very good in defense though.
JFH 8 - The only thing holding this shitshow together.
Kikau 6 - Not having the impact we need him to. Teams have worked out that he's got nothing if you hit him low. Crap miss for the Haas try.
Martin 5 - Hands are an ongoing issue. Didn't crunch people like last week.
Leota 7 - I like him starting. Good energy in defense.

Yeo 6 - Tons of hard work in defense, particularly when scrambling. Just seems to have no impact otherwise.
Katoa 6 - Changed the game when he came on. He's unfit but I hope he finds a way to turn it around.
Leniu 6 - Really needs to get more minutes. One excellent charge, gained us some meters in defense. No coincidence our best period came when he was on.
RCG 5 - Did he play? Ineffective again. Eating up a spot atm.

 

[Flashstep]

Edwards 7 - Good game, might be a little harsh but I think he has some defensive issues, needs to run to the line more when sweeping in attaching plays.
Mansour 5 - Runs hard but has to many errors in his game and in general just doesn’t have it in him to be a winger in first grade, massive defensive issues.
Naden 4 - Bit of a liability in defence and never passes to mansour, a good example of why you shouldn’t hype up a new player after a few good games, I don’t want to give up on him yet though.
Whare 6 - decent hame considering he’s been told he can look elsewhere.
To’o 8 - Probably our best backline player already which says a lot about our club, a rookie that runs hard and fast and has a knack of finding the try line.
Maloney 4 - A complete idiot tonight and not for the first time for us, really should stand up a lot more for a young team but doesnt have it in him.
Cleary 5 - scored a decent try but other than that another poor game, just looks lost out there, whether Maloney is a causing that we will find out next year.
Tamou 6 - Standard game for him
Kenny 5 - Meh, we need a hooker desperately, Korisau at 500k is much better value for money than any of the hookers we have.
JFH 7 - Best player by a long way for us this year, and another good performance to bad it’s just like a lot of games where nobody can match him.
Kikau 6 - Teams have figured him out, we haven’t helped by using him as our main attacking weapon for years, probably should be a middle forward and play less minutes
Martin 5 - didn’t see much of him at all tonight
Leota 6 - Looks a better player when starting

Katoa 5 - Same as Kenny really
Yeo 5 - Pretty poor season by his standards but I think he’s playing injured well at least I hope he is
Leinu 5 - Looks alright but not a lot of minutes, understandably being eased into first grade
RCG 5 - The Sooner parramatta take him the better.

 

[TheFrog]

To’o -

Need a rating.

 

[Flashstep]

Need a rating.

My bad, I’ll give him an 8

 

[Thirsty Panther]

Round 22 Broncos another bad game by us.

Edwards 7
Mansour 5
Whare 5
Naden 4
To'o 7
Maloney 6
Cleary 7
Tamou 6
Kenny 6
Fisher-Harris 8
Kikau 6
Martin 5
Leota 5

Yeo 6
Katoa 5 is it OK I give him a score this week, Frog
Leniu 4
Campbell-Gillard 5

 

[Pomoz]

Round 22 Broncos

Edwards 6 - Can't blame him for not stopping Haas, who could? 202m!
Mansour 5 - offers nothing in attack but sweat and effort
Whare 5 - good flick pass for Too.
Naden 3 - a shocker, but nearly scored. He can sniff out opportunities, it's defence he needs to fix.
To'o 7 - Already our best back. The Eels must be excited.
Maloney 5 - Great pass to Whare to create the overlap, got trampled and smashed but kept going.
Cleary 4 - Except for the try where he actually run, he seemed to be lost out there. Narcolepsy?
Tamou 6 - 172m. Good effort. Need two more like him.
Kenny 5 - 44 tackles, but not enough creative work.
Fisher-Harris 7 - Tackled his guts out and 121m. Player of the year. Daylight second.
Kikau 6 - Missed tackles don't show several times where he didn't lay a finger on them. Blunt instrument
Martin 4 - Quiet. Ineffective. Benched and played 40 mins. Hmmm.
Leota 4 - I don't get the love for Leota. 85m, 21 tackles. Big deal. RCG delivered more with 2 mins less.

Yeo 5 - Looking very limited as a player this season. Always tries hard though.
Katoa 5 - "Is that Uber? A taxi to the ruck please and can we swing by Pie Face, I'm starving?"
Leniu 4 - Need to see more of his running game. 1 run not good enough.
Campbell-Gillard 5 - Meh.

Dave's mate - 2 - Can't count, only used 7 of 8 interchanges. I guess he thought our superior fitness would get us through. He should send the attack coach on annual leave for six months and replace them with a pot plant. It's just as ineffective at coaching attack but it'll brighten the place up.

 

[OldPanther]

Can we just use the mercy rule and declare Fish the winner? He's embarrassing everyone

 

[Kilkenny]

Edwards - 7. One dropped ball otherwise very solid.
Mansour - 4. Always give 100% but his deficiencies were evidence for all to see tonight.
Naden - 3. Game to forget.
Whare - 5. Solid but limited.
Too - 7. Only attacking weapon in the backs who get’s few attacking opportunities.
Maloney - 6. Tried his gut’s out and not helped by our impotent attacking structures.
Cleary - 5. Great try but little else.
Tamou - 6. Did what he does.
Kenny - 5. Get’s 5 for his defensive efforts.
JFH - 6. Wouldn’t it be great if he was our second best front rower.
Kikau - 6. It’s all been said. Being ruined by our coach and game plan.
Martin - 4. Need’s to use more of the hand spray his dropped balls are too common.
Leota - 5. Another whose game has not come on due to misuse Ivan and Griffin.

Yeo - 5. Credible performance given he is playing busted.
Katoa - 4. Lost a point for his contribution to the Hass try.
Lenui - 4. See Leota I hope lack of coaching doesn’t ruin this huge talent.
RCG - 5. One trick pony who has forgotten what his trick was.

 

[Abacus]

To'o 7 - Already our best back. The Eels must be excited

GOLD!!!

 

[TheFrog]

Round 22 closing soon.

Players to shed points in R22 due to playing over 20 games-
Fisher-Harris 33 (R10)
Leota 27 (R10)
Tamou 40 (R10)

 

[OldPanther]

Round 22 closing soon.

Players to shed points in R22 due to playing over 20 games-
Fisher-Harris 33 (R10)
Leota 27 (R10)
Tamou 40 (R10)

Huh? You're removing points?

 

[TheFrog]

Huh? You're removing points?

The rules as outlined in the first post of this thread are that each player's 20 best performances are counted (plus one for each final). This is to make missing one or two games due to injury/origin less of a penalty. The ones shown are the lowest scores for each player who has 21 games. It's not going to make much difference anyway.

 

[OldPanther]

The rules as outlined in the first post of this thread are that each player's 20 best performances are counted (plus one for each final). This is to make missing one or two games due to injury/origin less of a penalty. The ones shown are the lowest scores for each player who has 21 games. It's not going to make much difference anyway.

Not going to lie I don't remember the first post. So much football news happens it's one thing in one thing out of the mind.

That is a good idea to average it out and will make sense now I know the system

 

[TheFrog]

Average Ratings Round 22 vs Broncos

Edwards 6.8
Mansour 5.0
Whare 5.5
Naden 3.7
To'o 7.3
Maloney 5.3
Cleary 5.3
Tamou 6.0
Kenny 5.3
Fisher-Harris 7.3
Kikau 6.0
Martin 4.7
Leota 5.7

Yeo 5.4
Katoa 5.0
Leniu 4.5
Campbell-Gillard 5.0

Standings (games)
Only 20 best scores are counted.
1. Fisher-Harris 1400 (21)
2. Tamou 1324 (21)
3. Maloney 1098 (19)
4. Campbell-Gillard 1106 (20)
5. Leota 1082 (21)
6. Cleary 1080 (18)
7. Mansour 1037 (18)
8. Edwards 1016 (17)
9. Yeo 1003 (17)
10. Kikau 934 (15)
11. Egan 810 (15)
12. Martin 792 (13)
13. To'o 784 (12)
14. Whare 749 (15)
15. Winterstein 596 (12)
16. Kenny 641 (11)
17. Naden 618 (10)
18. Luai 556 (12)
19. Katoa 517 (12)
20. Blake 501 (10)
21. DWZ 467 (10)
22. Grant 335 (7)
23. Sele 279 (5)
24. Fuimaono 255 (6)
25. MWZ 206 (4)
26. Aekins 152 (3)
27. Hetherington 98 (2)
28. Leniu (2)
29. Burton 71 (1)
30. Crichton 46 (1)
31. Cartwright 46 (1)

 

[OldPanther]

Edwards: 9
Cleary: 6
Egan: 6
Lenui: 6

Everyone else: 2