manu vatuvei should be an immortal

[wittyfan]

Jones had bad games for the whole of 2009.

 

[Meth]

Jones is not an immortal. Lol at Manu anyone remember that game against Parra a few years back? that was gold the amount of times he knocked on lol.

wow- equally as stupid as the OP, at the opposite end of the argument

 

[Wato]

wow- equally as stupid as the OP, at the opposite end of the argument

I was just pointing out a bad game he played, the only reason I remember it is because of the continuous call team and Lol at the people saying Jones should be an immortal. His behind Johns, Lockyer, Buderus and even probably Thurston. Also I think Manu's a great player but not an immortal and he never will be.

 

[snoozer]

please. manu is better than all of them, not only on the field, but off. he has helped promote NZ league MUCH more than them, like i said, he is an icon.

you must be the warriors version of bunniesman.

 

[nqcowboy87]

lopini kaufusi > manu vatuvei

 

[redvscotty]

Metcalfe > Manu

 

[wittyfan]

Locke >Manu

 

[Glen]

An immortal never had a game like this:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CHrbmKIuv4Y&feature=related

 

[Charles Bronson]

make chris walker an immortal too!

 

[TheDalek079]

Is Manu in the same league as Bozo, Changa, Reg, Sterlo, Churchill, Lewis and Artie? Hell no!!!

 

[shiznit]

Manu is by far the best winger in the game...

if the bloke was Australian he would be one of the first picked for Australia and whatever Origin side he qualified for(seeing as he's kiwi id say hes probably already on Queensland's radar)...

no one even comes close... and thats saying something because theres some brilliant wingers out there.

His combo of speed, size, power and ability in the air is just unstoppable.

and for mine he's the type of bloke you would show to a young kid who has an absolute shocker on the football field to turn it around... they way he came back from that was a credit to himself and the coach for sticking with him.

having said all of that... he's no f**king immortal... well not the RLW magazine immortal... nowhere near.

he could one day be inducted into the Kiwi immortals which are done by the NZRL i think... which i think Stacey Jones has been inducted into.

 

[Usain Bolt]

f**k off he aint no Scott Minto. Minto would piss on this clowns grave afer he kills him

 

[Meth]

People trying to bag Manu out by bringing up that Parramatta game are seriously geniused

 

[Loudstrat]

Is Manu in the same league as Bozo, Changa, Reg, Sterlo, Churchill, Lewis and Artie? Hell no!!!

Wow - big nams there. Swap Sterlo for Puff and you'd have 7 immortals!

Manu has the best smile of any winger - but we'll keep Luke Burt thanks. Manu is good, don't get me wrong, but he's nowhere near the start of what it took to be Eric Grothe Snr.

 

[sheepbender]

Best Kiwis player? he's hardly the best Warrior of all time.. There are countless superior players to Vatuvai that have played for the Warriors since 95.. I don't understand the wraps on him, I love the Warriors but he's just a winger..

 

[Loudstrat]

Has he had the impact of Frances Meli yet? Or Shaun Hoppe?

 

[Manu Vatuvei]

jsmith, iluke, nighto, are better more consistent players than manu.

lol

This somehow manages to be stupider than the original post

I have no objection to being made an immortal btw

 

[Manu Vatuvei]

Best Kiwis player? he's hardly the best Warrior of all time.. There are countless superior players to Vatuvai that have played for the Warriors since 95.. I don't understand the wraps on him, I love the Warriors but he's just a winger..

Countless? If you struggle to count to 1 or 2 then you're probably right

 

[My Morning Coat]

Manu wouldnt even figure in the warriors top five wingers of all time...check out this list
Paul Staladi
Justin Murphy
John Kirwan
Odell Manuel
John Carlaw

 

[Loudstrat]

Manu is probably one of the most marketable players in the game. Cleanskin - plays with obvious joy of the game - respectful. They perfect "face of the game" like Hindy, Preston Campbell, Hayne etc and a few others -and not the personality deprived morons they usually promote.

Manu has to prove himself on the big stage though. I still remember Meli's 4 tries in a semi. Hoppe proved himself in finals and tests. From another position, Hohia has as well. Manu - not yet.