Match Discussion: Round 6 vs Eels @ Bankwest Stadium

[BuffaloRules]

Garner is decent but has poor D. May be better off bench as impact.

He was poor today... surprisingly poor as I thought he had been going ok...

I think you have to persevere with him though and hope it’s a one off... I don’t like the other options at least until Lawrence is back..

 

[Front-Rower]

Maybe but at least I'm not speaking absolute dribble like you are. Factually you just stated that marketing picked the team implying that Robbie and Benji were the problem. They didn't play today apart from Robbie for a couple of minutes.

Do you get that ? Maybe go and take a bex and have a lie down.

Are you stating that Robbie and Benji were to blame and our forwards and halves were great ?

You think Fonua is a first grade standard player. Should I go on?

 

[Front-Rower]

8. Aloiai
9. Farah
10. Twal
11. Chee Kam
12. Matterson
13. Taylor

Packer offers the penetration of a child’s c**k and we need Taylor in to actually make some tackles.

Gee that’s going to put fear into the opposition

 

[benched tiger]

Garner let two tries in with missed tackles.

 

[The unknown]

Agree was garners worst 1st grade game but he's mainly been good for us so id persist. Maybe he was just taught a lesson today so hopefully will bounce back

It's the consistent underperformers that need to be looked at (Packer, Chee Kam, Matulino, Jennings) but then again we have nobody to replace them

 

[Tiger05]

Garner is decent but has poor D. May be better off bench as impact.

His defence isn't up too scratch is it.

 

[benched tiger]

Fonua is terrible, he is far to slow for a back in the NRL, if he cannot adapt to making himself a forward which I seriously doubt he could, then he should be dropped or moved on.

 

[Vic Mackey]

Garner let two tries in with missed tackles.

Same as last week. The guys still a work in progress, can’t beleive some people wanted us to punt Lawrence for this guy

 

[Old Time Tiger]

The club should do a Parramatta, tell all off contract players that no contracts will be renewed until...................who knows but if the likes of Fonua and Packer can get a run elsewhere they should jump at it.

As for flicking the likes or Farah and Marshall go, well they will be gone at the end of the season. Mybe actually had a go today simply because he had to when he moved to dummy half. Reynolds tried, Brooks tackled, Jennings is shit, wingers are too small.

Did anyone see the reserves? How did the backs go?

 

[Tiger05]

8. Aloiai
9. Farah
10. Twal
11. Chee Kam
12. Matterson
13. Taylor

Packer offers the penetration of a child’s c**k and we need Taylor in to actually make some tackles.

I'd play Eisenhuth at 13 and use Aloiai as an impact player. I'd keep Packer in the team for the moment.

Mind you it is just shifting beck chairs on the titanic.

We just went to pieces out there. I don't know if mass changes are required. I think the key decision is Benji in for Reynolds. Reynolds has been good but he was puss today. I'd probably give him another chance.

I think Mbye at hooker was okay and Thompson at the back is a decent option.

 

[benched tiger]

Packer and Matulino should be regifted back to Cleary.

 

[Tiger05]

Same as last week. The guys still a work in progress, can’t beleive some people wanted us to punt Lawrence for this guy

Yep. He missed tackles last week as well. He is decent and deserves some effort to be put into him but Lawrence when fit comes straight back in.

 

[Tiger05]

Packer and Matulino should be regifted back to Cleary.

I reckon they've been okay. Packer was crud today but overall he has been decent. The problem is they are overpaid and that stops us getting better players.

 

[Das Hassler]

Garner let two tries in with missed tackles.

Exhaustion is what it is. ...brilliant coaching by BA....they just never let us up for air. We were up for the 10 count 20 minutes go. Kicking was criminal ..the 7 tackle restarts are just inexcusable.

 

[macnaz]

Lol the coach said before the game these two are the most influential players in the team. He loved how Farah plays straight. Farah hasn’t played straight in 10 years lol

Seriously give it a rest.... Farah has done WAY more positives for this club then negatives ... IF every player had his attitude and winning drive we wouldnt get beat by 50 f**king points by a shit team directed by Mitchel f**king Moses

 

[magpie_man]

Welp...there goes our F+A.

 

[Front-Rower]

Seriously give it a rest.... Farah has done WAY more positives for this club then negatives ... IF every player had his attitude and winning drive we wouldnt get beat by 50 f**king points by a shit team directed by Mitchel f**king Moses

Another one in denial.

Attitude? What, sulking behind the goal posts when captain?

 

[Front-Rower]

Seriously give it a rest.... Farah has done WAY more positives for this club then negatives ... IF every player had his attitude and winning drive we wouldnt get beat by 50 f**king points by a shit team directed by Mitchel f**king Moses

15 years of jack, just how Balmain and Western Suburbs fans like it as long as their favourites are in the team. No wonder our clubs and club is a joke. What a disgrace.

 

[leaguelegend21]

15 years of jack, just how Balmain and Western Suburbs fans like it as long as their favourites are in the team. No wonder our clubs and club is a joke. What a disgrace.

Piss off you negative and deluded merkin. Add something constructive to the discussion than incessantly bashing players you hate based on illogical vendettas.

 

[west4ever]

8. Aloiai
9. Farah
10. Twal
11. Chee Kam
12. Matterson
13. Taylor

Packer offers the penetration of a child’s c**k and we need Taylor in to actually make some tackles.

1- Tompson
2- Nofoaluma
3- MOMO
4- Masters
5- Jennings
6- Reynolds
7- Benji
8- Mattalino
9- Farah capt
10-Twal
11-Matterson
12-Garner
13-Taylor
14-Aloai
15-Mikaele
16-McQueen
17-MCK
There a some big call but seriously we can’t do worse than today.