Mergers and Premiership Tallies

[Willow]

How could you missed it? It was only 3,584 pages back.

 

[SoftSydney]

lol sorry didnt see it

Means nothing mate its just the NRL's stance of referring to teams by their mascot/emblem name rather then the team name.

Read my signature and click on the link to get the true story, these muppets are just clutching at straws as per usual.

 

[innsaneink]

I brought that up before. The silence was deafening.

Link: http://www.nrl.com/telstrapremiership/historicalladder/tabid/10252/default.aspx

No doubt the sore losers will discard this one as a mistake. lol

It just shows that even the NRL are not sure.

Your own club itself is very very sure.
See sig.

Regards,
Caring Ink.

 

[Willow]

Means nothing mate its just the NRL's stance of referring to teams by their mascot/emblem name rather then the team name.

So you're saying the NRL considered the mascot to be 'St George' in 2005.

Good to see you've turned the corner.

You're quick to respond Softy. If only you were as quick to read what's in front of you.

 

[Willow]

Your own club itself is very very sure.

Yep.

See sig.

Regards,
Caring Ink.

Yes, you care now - no longer 'commenting' lol.

You denied it. But hey, I already had you picked on that one.

Good to see you've finally admitted how much it grates on you.

 

[SoftSydney]

Your own club itself is very very sure.
See sig.

Regards,
Caring Ink.

A good read, I didnt realise that in their 1st year in 1999 STGI had co captains Mark Coyne and Paul McGregor. It was good to see them win their very 1st premiership this year.

 

[SoftSydney]

Yep.

Yes, you care now - no longer 'commenting' lol.

You denied it. But hey, I already had you picked on that one.

Good to see you've finally admitted how much it grates on you.

Do you have anything from STGI :lol::lol::lol: or just the propaganda from the bowls club

 

[InThatNumber]

The A typical wank arrogant STG point of view... well I am sorry to break the news to you, STG did not add the steelers to their name LMAO they merged new team buddy read my signature info taken from your site!
AND thats why you are officially on 1, u can all cry as much as you like even stamp your feet but its 1 and always will be.

Sorry pal my arrogance hurts you, but so be it... and I agree with you, Saints didn't add Steelers to their name.. I said Illawarra.. if you are going to have a come back at least get it right...

no crying here kid, that is your bag of chips..

sixteen.. will forever be until the next one.. stamp your feet a little more, you might warm up to the truth...

 

[Gaba]

Sorry pal my arrogance hurts you, but so be it... and I agree with you, Saints didn't add Steelers to their name.. I said Illawarra.. if you are going to have a come back at least get it right...

no crying here kid, that is your bag of chips..

sixteen.. will forever be until the next one.. stamp your feet a little more, you might warm up to the truth...

soft sydney and the others dont understand that, its Illawarra as a whole area not the steelers club.

Unlikely to happen but if Illawarra returns to the nrl lets say as Illawarra foxes ,the premiership stgeorge/Illawarra won would still count as 1 for Illawarra.

 

[SoftSydney]

Sorry pal my arrogance hurts you, but so be it... and I agree with you, Saints didn't add Steelers to their name.. I said Illawarra.. if you are going to have a come back at least get it right...

no crying here kid, that is your bag of chips..

sixteen.. will forever be until the next one.. stamp your feet a little more, you might warm up to the truth...

Keep dreaming the official tally stands at 1
16 will only exist in your head which pretty much means and counts for nothing:lol:

 

[Willow]

Do you have anything from STGI :lol::lol::lol:

Yes, the Red V magazine already posted.

or just the propaganda from the bowls club

So you've stopped calling it a RSL club. This was straight after I asked you what you've got against RSL clubs. You're very easy to manipulate softy. Sometimes I have to save you from yourself.

So what have you against bowls clubs?

 

[Willow]

I didnt realise that in their 1st year in 1999 STGI

All open to interpretation softy.

I note you ignore part where it says the joint venture as a partnership a 'second phase of St George’s life and that of Illawarra'.

In other words, neither club dies just because of the JV, they continue on in the JV.

Read what you want into it, opinions are free. But I still see dragons.com.au as an NRL website and as such has an NRL-sanctioned version of history. Just to remind you, that's the same NRL that was established in 1998 as a Joint Venture but inherited all the NSWRL records.

Life is full of contradictions, don't you agree?

had co captains Mark Coyne and Paul McGregor.

LOL. Good ol' NRL-sanctioned history.

There's a lot of things you don't know softy. Including the fact that the co-captaincy was a little different that year. Mark Coyne essentially retired earlier in the season. The site also fails to mention the co-coaching in 1999, crediting David Waite as the club coach despite Andrew Farrar 'officially' sharing the duties. But hey, we can't expect the NRL to know everything.

Softy, this is the problem when blow-ins such yourself decide overnight to make it their business. You scratch the surface and then think you know everything.

From the outset you have been trying to 'debate' (I use the term loosely) on something you have no knowledge of. You know nothing of the background to this, you know nothing about the club or its history. You're new to everything, still checking out your chest hairs. All you have are some NRL memos handed out to club websites and you treat this like some revelation.

Three months ago you didn't give a stuff about how many premierships Saints had won. And three months from now you'll find some new paper cause to follow. It's pretty sad really.

 

[Baron Vo Mandor]

wow softy, it's getting pretty lonely for you in here...

just the one of you against at least sixteen dragons fans..


hell, even baron has realised leaving this thread was the decent and right thing to do...

Hey buddy hope you had a good xmas, and yes it was the decent and right thing to do not to continue shattering your delusions in the spirit of the season.

That doesnt mean it isn't morally reprehensible for you to do so though!

 

[InThatNumber]

Keep dreaming the official tally stands at 1
16 will only exist in your head which pretty much means and counts for nothing:lol:

wow the emoticon, the comeback of choice for every Dragon hater hack who is losing the battle at convincing Dragons fans that the team we support hasn't won 16 comps.

Thank you very much, I will keep dreaming about official Dragons premierships... after a glorious 16th this season, I will start dreaming about a 17th title for my Dragons... who knows, 2011 perhaps?

Well apart from my head, 16 exists in history... keep trying to rewrite it if you will... but you will still fail miserably, just as in this argument...

 

[Baron Vo Mandor]

InThatNumber, could you please explain to me the following points.

*Why you are considering mascots and logos to be official clubs.
*Why you are claiming a 12 year old club can win 16 premierships.
*Why you are claiming that 3 clubs won the 2010 premiership.
*Why you are claiming that the St George Dragons competed in the 2010 comp.
*Why you are claiming that the Illawarra Steelers competed in the 2010 comp.
*Why you are behaving in a morally reprehensible way.

 

[Baron Vo Mandor]

Also don't forget I am a Jedi Knight because I claim to be and I have the force as my ally.

 

[InThatNumber]

InThatNumber, could you please explain to me the following points.

*Why you are considering mascots and logos to be official clubs.
*Why you are claiming a 12 year old club can win 16 premierships.
*Why you are claiming that 3 clubs won the 2010 premiership.
*Why you are claiming that the St George Dragons competed in the 2010 comp.
*Why you are claiming that the Illawarra Steelers competed in the 2010 comp.
*Why you are behaving in a morally reprehensible way.

Okay Baron, of course I will answer the points you have made.. loaded as they are...

*Why you are considering mascots and logos to be official clubs.

Any Australian male knows ( and I am sure you know also) that a club can be referred to in any way, that is immediately obvious to others. For example, Doggies is not official, but I know it is the Canterbury Bankstown Bulldogs (Sydney Bulldogs - Berries whatever).
When I claim premierships for Saints or Dragons or mention the RED V, you know exactly who I am referring to whether it be St George Dragons or St George Illawarra Dragons. In all my years I have never heard any league fan constantly refer to their club by their official title, but by their mascots, colloquial names etc. Whether official or not, they all represent the same club. I suspect that you are only dragging on with this “official” line because you can no longer cling to CHOKE as your main means of denigrating the Saints and their fans.


*Why you are claiming a 12 year old club can win 16 premierships.

I am not claiming this... I am claiming the club I support that has played in the top level of rugby league since 1921, has added their 16th title to the 15 they won prior to 1999.

*Why you are claiming that 3 clubs won the 2010 premiership.

I have never made such a claim and you have no proof to claim otherwise... not that lack of proof stopped you making false claims about others ... do we really need to mention Gasnier again?

*Why you are claiming that the St George Dragons competed in the 2010 comp.

Because they continue to exist as a strong member of the Joint Venture.

*Why you are claiming that the Illawarra Steelers competed in the 2010 comp.

I have never made any such claim for Illawarra Steelers having come from the Dragons side of the JV... but hey they do make up a significant part of the premiership so interpret it in any way you wish.

*Why you are behaving in a morally reprehensible way.

I am simply defending my team from the attacks of others. If that’s morally reprehensible then the Pope is not Catholic. I am not trying to make you agree the Dragons have won 16, believe it to be one if that makes you happy, but I will defy you till the day I die if you continue to try and dictate to me and Dragons fans that our team has not won 16 competitions.

There, I have answered all of your questions in depth Baron. Took a while but it’s done. Now, are you? And don’t get started with all the right thing to do crap.. you got outed on that lie eons ago...

 

[Willow]

Does a Jedi Knight determine that everything starts at ground zero?

Baroness, even the voices in your head will tell you that there is a past, present and future. If there was no St George after 1998, then the NRL records begin in 1998. But that's not the way it is.

I know this is wasted in on softy and baroness, but allow me to attempt a rational discussion. Hopefully you'll learn something.

The Joint Venture of St George Illawarra won it's first NRL grand final in 2010. Despite want you think, the 'official' book keeping is not a revelation. Even with the NRL regularly making errors, and being full of contradiction, and until such time that change occurs, we still have to use the NRL as a yard stick for the national first grade competition.

But regardless of all that, the 2010 premiership is still the 16th overall for St George and the Red V. And we celebrated it as such.

Wayne Bennett agrees and says that it's 16 premierships overall. Is he wrong too?

 

[SoftSydney]

All open to interpretation softy.

I note you ignore part where it says the joint venture as a partnership a 'second phase of St George’s life and that of Illawarra'.

In other words, neither club dies just because of the JV, they continue on in the JV.

Read what you want into it, opinions are free. But I still see dragons.com.au as an NRL website and as such has an NRL-sanctioned version of history. Just to remind you, that's the same NRL that was established in 1998 as a Joint Venture but inherited all the NSWRL records.

Life is full of contradictions, don't you agree?

LOL. Good ol' NRL-sanctioned history.

There's a lot of things you don't know softy. Including the fact that the co-captaincy was a little different that year. Mark Coyne essentially retired earlier in the season. The site also fails to mention the co-coaching in 1999, crediting David Waite as the club coach despite Andrew Farrar 'officially' sharing the duties. But hey, we can't expect the NRL to know everything.

Softy, this is the problem when blow-ins such yourself decide overnight to make it their business. You scratch the surface and them think you know everything.

From the outset you have been trying to 'debate' (I use the term loosely) on something you have no knowledge of. You know nothing of the background to this, you know nothing about the club or its history. You're new to everything, still checking out your chest hairs. All you have are some NRL memos handed out to club websites and you treat this like some relevation.

Three months ago you didn't give a stuff about how many premierships Saints had won. And three months from now you'll find some new paper cause to follow. It's pretty sad really.

awww aww awww you sound like dennis fitzgerald lol

wow the emoticon, the comeback of choice for every Dragon hater hack who is losing the battle at convincing Dragons fans that the team we support hasn't won 16 comps.

Thank you very much, I will keep dreaming about official Dragons premierships... after a glorious 16th this season, I will start dreaming about a 17th title for my Dragons... who knows, 2011 perhaps?

Well apart from my head, 16 exists in history... keep trying to rewrite it if you will... but you will still fail miserably, just as in this argument...

The history only exists in ya head :lol: officially 1 mate check it out, sorry to burst the bubble. Oh by the way santa doesn't exist, nor the easter bunny or the tooth fairy :lol:

You boys keep posting ur deluded opinions and I will post the facts.

 

[juanfarkall]

sixteen premiership wins for the team which wears the Red V.


deal with it.