What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Mergers and Premiership Tallies

How Many GF's have they won


  • Total voters
    228

InThatNumber

Juniors
Messages
417
awww aww awww you sound like dennis fitzgerald lol



The history only exists in ya head :lol: officially 1 mate check it out, sorry to burst the bubble. Oh by the way santa doesn't exist, nor the easter bunny or the tooth fairy :lol:

You boys keep posting ur deluded opinions and I will post the facts.


Facts are teams (known as the Dragons) since 1921 have won 16 comps. Check your precious records at the NRL... they include the NSWRL records... or do you think league started in 1998?

Lightweight...
 

SoftSydney

Juniors
Messages
550
Crisis talks on Dragons feeder team

THE Dragons will this week hold crisis talks with local Illawarra club Shellharbour in a desperate move to organise a NSW Cup team for 2011.
St George Illawarra are hoping to resume their association with the local Carlton League club, but their talks have stalled.
Shellharbour will play only in the local Illawarra Carlton League in 2011 unless the Dragons can dramatically upgrade the financial support they gave the club this year.
Dragons chief executive Peter Doust will meet with Shellharbour in the coming days to negotiate a deal after extensive talks before Christmas proved fruitless.
The breakdown of talks means Wayne Bennett's fringe players will have to drop down to play for various clubs in the Carlton League if they are not selected in the top 17.
Shellharbour, who will play as the Southern Marlins, were named last week in a new NSW Cup fixture for 2011, featuring the return of Manly in a 12-team competition.

However, Shellharbour coach Terry Gilogley said his club were favouring walking away from the NRL feeder competition a few weeks ago.
"It'd be very disappointing if there wasn't a team," he said. "I don't understand how a team, who could be world champions if they win the World Club Challenge, can not have a second team. It's in the realms of ridiculousness."

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sp...gons-feeder-team/story-e6frexnr-1225976430135


***********Intersting.... all SGI juniors teams could be banned if they dont field a feeder team. I wonder if this could lead to STGI merging with the Raiders?

Could be a good thing as STG fans could then claim 19 premierships :lol:
 

SoftSydney

Juniors
Messages
550
Facts are teams (known as the Dragons) since 1921 have won 16 comps. Check your precious records at the NRL:lol:... they include the NSWRL records... or do you think league started in 1998?

Lightweight...

ummm rrrr hmmmm
read my signature taken from the NRL site and STGI site
 

Willow

Assistant Moderator
Messages
110,071
Crisis talks on Dragons feeder team

THE Dragons will this week hold crisis talks with local Illawarra club Shellharbour in a desperate move to organise a NSW Cup team for 2011.
St George Illawarra are hoping to resume their association with the local Carlton League club, but their talks have stalled.
Shellharbour will play only in the local Illawarra Carlton League in 2011 unless the Dragons can dramatically upgrade the financial support they gave the club this year.
Dragons chief executive Peter Doust will meet with Shellharbour in the coming days to negotiate a deal after extensive talks before Christmas proved fruitless.
The breakdown of talks means Wayne Bennett's fringe players will have to drop down to play for various clubs in the Carlton League if they are not selected in the top 17.
Shellharbour, who will play as the Southern Marlins, were named last week in a new NSW Cup fixture for 2011, featuring the return of Manly in a 12-team competition.

However, Shellharbour coach Terry Gilogley said his club were favouring walking away from the NRL feeder competition a few weeks ago.
"It'd be very disappointing if there wasn't a team," he said. "I don't understand how a team, who could be world champions if they win the World Club Challenge, can not have a second team. It's in the realms of ridiculousness."

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sp...gons-feeder-team/story-e6frexnr-1225976430135


***********Intersting.... all SGI juniors teams could be banned if they dont field a feeder team. I wonder if this could lead to STGI merging with the Raiders?

Could be a good thing as STG fans could then claim 19 premierships :lol:

:lol: You've done it again. Posting old news an completely missing the point.

It's the NSW Cup and Carlton League you dope. Learn to tell the difference.
 

SoftSydney

Juniors
Messages
550
:lol: You've done it again. Posting old news an completely missing the point.

It's the NSW Cup and Carlton League you dope. Learn to tell the difference.

I know that mate.... awwww there u go assuming again!

I am just saying it could lead to a merge in FG, it makes sense if both clubs can not afford to field a nsw cup team.
 

Willow

Assistant Moderator
Messages
110,071
I know that mate.... awwww there u go assuming again!
lol. Still slow as a crippled pisspot. Tell me again how I think everyone is a christian.

SoftSydney said:
I am just saying it could lead to a merge in FG, it makes sense if both clubs can not afford to field a nsw cup team.
I know what you're trying to say. It shows that you NFI.

Stick with believing the baroness is being fair dinkum with you. At least then yout thought you had a friend.
 

SoftSydney

Juniors
Messages
550
lol. Still slow as a crippled pisspot. Tell me again how I think everyone is a christian.

I know what you're trying to say. It shows that you NFI.

Stick with believing the baroness is being fair dinkum with you. At least then yout thought you had a friend.


Look on the bright side if you merge yet again with the raiders you can claim 19!
 

Willow

Assistant Moderator
Messages
110,071
You're dumb softy.

Still waiting for your entertaining replies:

What's dennis fitzgerald got to do with it?

And what have you got against Lawn Bowls Clubs?
 

SoftSydney

Juniors
Messages
550
You're dumb softy.

Still waiting for your entertaining replies:

What's dennis fitzgerald got to do with it?

And what have you got against Lawn Bowls Clubs?

Dumb is when the NRL and your own teams web site has a tally of 1 and you claim 16.
Dennis Fitzgerald as you are using his catch phrase, come to think of it your posts and approach of slandering aligns with him.
Lawn bowls + RSL's great places for a drink and a feed but not so good for for providing serious NRL info :lol:
 

innsaneink

Referee
Messages
29,368
Yep.






Yes, you care now - no longer 'commenting' lol.

You denied it. But hey, I already had you picked on that one.

Good to see you've finally admitted how much it grates on you.
LOL
Hook line and sinker

See....you believe what I write when it suits you....

I'd say your 2000 odd posts in this thread alone is more of a reflection on who's being 'grated'
Bet you never thought in your wildest dreams, a premiership would turn you into a petty troll.
 

SoftSydney

Juniors
Messages
550
LOL
Hook line and sinker

See....you believe what I write when it suits you....

I'd say your 2000 odd posts in this thread alone is more of a reflection on who's being 'grated'
Bet you never thought in your wildest dreams, a premiership would turn you into a petty troll.


:lol::lol::lol: nice
 

Willow

Assistant Moderator
Messages
110,071
See....you believe what I write when it suits you....
So you're still just 'commenting'?

innsaneink said:
I'd say your 2000 odd posts in this thread alone is more of a reflection on who's being 'grated'
You're counting? :lol:

Genuine question. Do you actually remember the exact point when I got under your skin? Must have been some years ago now.
 

Willow

Assistant Moderator
Messages
110,071
Dumb is when the NRL and your own teams web site has a tally of 1 and you claim 16.
I'll try again. Read carefully...

I have always supported the St George Dragons. I have continued this support in the Joint Venture known as the St George Illawarra Dragons.

I believe in the proud history that went before and follow the team and club into the future.

St George are part of the St George Illawarra Dragons Joint Venture.

I claim 16 overall...

...and wait for it, this is in line with the Dragons club.

St George Illawarra Dragons may have won one NRL grand final (NRL, est 1998), but the TOTAL premierships are 16 by virtue of the St George Dragons previously winning 15.

The Dragons in 2010 have recorded 16 premierships as TOTAL.

Perhaps you should close you eyes at this point, or maybe refer to the Dragons as some irrelevant RSL - put it down, denigrate RSLs, call it propaganda. You seem to take comfort in that.

The journal, entitled, '1921-2010 Our Proud History' has been published by the Joint Venture.

The '1921-2010 Our Proud History' also include all past record holders including St George and Illawarra Club Life members. Therefore, the clubs are not dead, St George are not dead, despite your attempts to say otherwise.

I am quite happy with the JV winning a first NRL grand final but I claim 16 premierships overall thanks to St George. And the JV agrees with that view.

Did you follow that?

Sorry if that rattles any 'in-depth' research done by the google generation. My only advice is you kids should stop being so lazy, get to a library, make a few phone calls, read journals, and talk to people in the real world.

In other words, take a fair dinkum interest in the subject matter. Not some claytons attempt born out of the desperation of dealing with a Dragons premiership victory.

SoftSydney said:
Dennis Fitzgerald as you are using his catch phrase, come to think of it your posts and approach of slandering aligns with him.
Don't give a stuff about dennis. Looks like he has upset you. Are you one of these kids following with the silly political situation at the Parra club?

Was that your last paper cause?

SoftSydney said:
Lawn bowls + RSL's great places for a drink and a feed but not so good for for providing serious NRL info :lol:
St George Leagues Club is neither bowls or RSL. But it seems to be a put down. So I ask again, what have you got against RSL clubs?

FTR, St George Leagues has Football Club offices and is a rich backer of the Dragons JV. Of course, you just don't know this.

You can't tell the difference. Just like you can't tell the difference between feeder clubs and the NRL.

Tell me, when Newtown were a feeder for Souths, did you immediately think they were combining premierships?
 

Azkatro

First Grade
Messages
6,905
Illawarra Steelers - 0 premierships
St George Dragons - 15 premierships
St George/Illawarra Dragons - 1 premiership

You should be proud that your club has got 1 Willow, I'd be ecstatic if the Cowboys had 1 premiership next to their name :lol:
 

Willow

Assistant Moderator
Messages
110,071
Nice trolling Azkatro, to think some sensitive types accuse me of that. ;-)

Thank you for trying to tell me who my club is, but shame on you too.

Are you able to acknowledge that the Dragons have 16 premierships overall?

Just think about the St George Dragons, 15 premierships. Then think about the St George Illawarra Dragons addition.

Then wonder for a second longer.

If you are fair dinkum about record keeping, you should be able to make the stretch. Otherwise, you're just trying to look for an easy route.

The St George Illawarra journal '1921-2010 Our Proud History' has confirmed the record keeping of the St George Football Club Journal of 2002.

I'm happy to bring you up to speed. Please feel free to PM me.

And sorry, but Clapton is not god. There is no god (don't tell Softy).
 

SoftSydney

Juniors
Messages
550
I'll try again. Read carefully...

I have always supported the St George Dragons. I have continued this support in the Joint Venture known as the St George Illawarra Dragons.

I believe in the proud history that went before and follow the team and club into the future.

St George are part of the St George Illawarra Dragons Joint Venture.

I claim 16 overall...

...and wait for it, this is in line with the Dragons club.

St George Illawarra Dragons may have won one NRL grand final (NRL, est 1998), but the TOTAL premierships are 16 by virtue of the St George Dragons previously winning 15.

The Dragons in 2010 have recorded 16 premierships as TOTAL.

Perhaps you should close you eyes at this point, or maybe refer to the Dragons as some irrelevant RSL - put it down, denigrate RSLs, call it propaganda. You seem to take comfort in that.

The journal, entitled, '1921-2010 Our Proud History' has been published by the Joint Venture.

The '1921-2010 Our Proud History' also include all past record holders including St George and Illawarra Club Life members. Therefore, the clubs are not dead, St George are not dead, despite your attempts to say otherwise.

I am quite happy with the JV winning a first NRL grand final but I claim 16 premierships overall thanks to St George. And the JV agrees with that view.

Did you follow that?

Sorry if that rattles any 'in-depth' research done by the google generation. My only advice is you kids should stop being so lazy, get to a library, make a few phone calls, read journals, and talk to people in the real world.

In other words, take a fair dinkum interest in the subject matter. Not some claytons attempt born out of the desperation of dealing with a Dragons premiership victory.

Don't give a stuff about dennis. Looks like he has upset you. Are you one of these kids following with the silly political situation at the Parra club?

Was that your last paper cause?


St George Leagues Club is neither bowls or RSL. But it seems to be a put down. So I ask again, what have you got against RSL clubs?

FTR, St George Leagues has Football Club offices and is a rich backer of the Dragons JV. Of course, you just don't know this.

You can't tell the difference. Just like you can't tell the difference between feeder clubs and the NRL.

Tell me, when Newtown were a feeder for Souths, did you immediately think they were combining premierships?


So basically some of us are posting facts and others opinion!
Now that we have your thoughts/opinion on the matter can you please advise us of the facts, how many recognised official premierships do STGI have?

I see many similarities in your style with Dennis Fitzgerald willow a credit to you mate, the rest of us are blow in's as you and Dennis would say.

Nothing against RSL clubs go there all the time great places.

I can tell the difference between the nsw cup and the nrl, I was simply speculating that there could be another merge stemming from the nsw cup issues STGI has.

No I didnt think the jets and rabbits were combining premierships lol I dont approach things in the same manner as a STG fan.
 

Willow

Assistant Moderator
Messages
110,071
So basically some of us are posting facts and others opinion!
Try again.
SoftSydney said:
I see many similarities in your style with Dennis Fitzgerald
No one gives a stuff Softy.

Get over dennis.

Are you a Parra supporter?
SoftSydney said:
Nothing against RSL clubs go there all the time great places.
You think RSL clubs are there to denigrate the NSWRL's first ever Leagues Club (yes, St George were the first - something else you don't know). You obviously didn't think it through.

SoftSydney said:
I can tell the difference between the nsw cup and the nrl
Now you can. You must have googled it.

SoftSydney said:
I was simply speculating that there could be another merge stemming
Then you're an idiot.
SoftSydney said:
No I didnt think the jets and rabbits were combining premierships lol I dont approach things in the same manner as a STG fan.
I never said you thought they were combining premierships. I just asked a question. Touched a nerve?

Don't worry Softy, another adult will come to your rescue tomorrow, and you can wave their paper flag.
 

SoftSydney

Juniors
Messages
550
You didn't answer the question mate, how many official recognised premierships have STGI won according to the NRL?
 
Messages
16,034
Does a Jedi Knight determine that everything starts at ground zero?

Baroness, even the voices in your head will tell you that there is a past, present and future. If there was no St George after 1998, then the NRL records begin in 1998. But that's not the way it is.

I know this is wasted in on softy and baroness, but allow me to attempt a rational discussion. Hopefully you'll learn something.

The Joint Venture of St George Illawarra won it's first NRL grand final in 2010. *Despite want you think, the 'official' book keeping is not a revelation. Even with the NRL regularly making errors, and being full of contradiction, and until such time that change occurs, we still have to use the NRL as a yard stick for the national first grade competition.

But regardless of all that, the 2010 premiership is still the 16th overall for St George and the Red V. And we celebrated it as such.

Wayne Bennett agrees and says that it's 16 premierships overall. Is he wrong too? #

* YES!
# Ofcourse the more the tshirts he sells to gullible morally reprehensible people such as yourself the more money he can command from Souths when they go in a bidding war for him in 2012.
*LOL you admitting St George-Illawarra won their first premiership in 2010, ludicrous you claiming that St George won their 16th when they didnt even play in the comp and havent since 1997, complete madness you somehow pretend that Illawarra doesnt exist.
 
Last edited:

Latest posts

Top