New Zealand 2 will deal a massive blow to NZ rugby

[MugaB]

Hilarious, you expect other cities to adopt failed Sydney brands because it’s good for Sydney but cant see that in a world of finite resources, despite mugab’s argument, that reducing an over saturated market to create clear space for new growth could be a good thing.

I never suggested reducing any saturated market, otherwise your mob in Melbourne would be due for some shrinking

 

[Wb1234]

I never suggested reducing any saturated market, otherwise your mob in Melbourne would be due for some shrinking

His mob in hull could do with some shrinkage too

 

[MugaB]

His mob in hull could do with some shrinkage too

Yeah geez not much money, yet still need 2 teams in hull, should one of them relocate to canada??

 

[Get Rid of The Donkeys]

Or both.

western magpies and Brisbane tigers gives you 18 teams with Perth and NZ2 coming in as teams 19&20 by 2030.

That's the best case scenario for NRL expansion.

 

[Get Rid of The Donkeys]

They have full ownership of the club but allow Balmain onto the board as an act of good faith. They need to boot balmain altogether

They should remove the Tigers mascot and rebrand as the Tigers. Focus on Campbelltown.

 

[MugaB]

They should remove the Tigers mascot and rebrand as the Tigers. Focus on Campbelltown.

Aren't they the Wests "Tigers" what a waste of money to rebrand as the tiger they were already.. deerrrrrppppp

You really need to lay off the burbon and cokes, stick to quoting cowboys anecdotes from some old biography from some old flog

 

[Gobsmacked]

Hilarious, you expect other cities to adopt failed Sydney brands because it’s good for Sydney but cant see that in a world of finite resources, despite mugab’s argument, that reducing an over saturated market to create clear space for new growth could be a good thing.

Brisbane Lions

 

[Bukowski]

They should remove the Tigers mascot and rebrand as the Tigers. Focus on Campbelltown.

Hey? Agree on Campbelltown

 

[Perth Red]

They have full ownership of the club but allow Balmain onto the board as an act of good faith. They need to boot balmain altogether

Given the owners have no affiliations with balmain or magpies they’d be better rebranding to Western sydney tigers, moving to commbank or allianz ft and reforming the board without the baggae that’s holding them back.

 

[Perth Red]

I never suggested reducing any saturated market, otherwise your mob in Melbourne would be due for some shrinking

Never said you did, my comment was in regards to your comments on nrl not having a finite amount of licenses. In reality it has and with possibly 5or 6 future nrl viable locations it means the game won’t ever be what it could as long as we insist on maintaining 9 clubs in one city.

 

[Perth Red]

Brisbane Lions

Do you consider them a success?

 

[MugaB]

Never said you did, my comment was in regards to your comments on nrl not having a finite amount of licenses. In reality it has and with possibly 5or 6 future nrl viable locations it means the game won’t ever be what it could as long as we insist on maintaining 9 clubs in one city.

In actual reality there is absolutely not... and they have maintained 9 clubs in one city since the NRLs inception.. again you are not only horribly wrong, you are just pushing a false case, when the AFL already do the exact same thing in Melbourne for their code, and even tho theyve had relocations, we've had mergers...
Your perception on how many licenses are available is diluted... they cost absolutely nothing, its not some empty parking space in some valuable parking lot... as long as there is players to fill the squads then theyll be as many teams as the NRL want

 

[MugaB]

Brisbane Lions

Do you consider them a success?

 

[Perth Red]

In actual reality there is absolutely not... and they have maintained 9 clubs in one city since the NRLs inception.. again you are not only horribly wrong, you are just pushing a false case, when the AFL already do the exact same thing in Melbourne for their code, and even tho theyve had relocations, we've had mergers...
Your perception on how many licenses are available is diluted... they cost absolutely nothing, its not some empty parking space in some valuable parking lot... as long as there is players to fill the squads then theyll be as many teams as the NRL want

In theory theres not, in reality there very much is.
ARL has been trying to reduce the Sydney numbers since they decided to take the comp beyond nsw in the 80’s.

again history would suggest the number is most definitely finite and the factors that create that are both cost to the nrl and depth of playing talent.

but again pointless discussion at the moment as the current arlc have shown the opposite of rationalisation of Sydney, in fact pushing hard to get more Sydney brands back in the nrl lol.

 

[Bukowski]

Given the owners have no affiliations with balmain or magpies they’d be better rebranding to Western sydney tigers, moving to commbank or allianz ft and reforming the board without the baggae that’s holding them back.

The owners are Wests Leagues. They are the magpies!

 

[MugaB]

In theory theres not, in reality there very much is.
ARL has been trying to reduce the Sydney numbers since they decided to take the comp beyond nsw in the 80’s.

again history would suggest the number is most definitely finite and the factors that create that are both cost to the nrl and depth of playing talent.

but again pointless discussion at the moment as the current arlc have shown the opposite of rationalisation of Sydney, in fact pushing hard to get more Sydney brands back in the nrl lol.

Not Pointless, whats pointless is you and that logan deadshit grotd who think that there is only a few spots left... there are an infinite amount as long as there is playing stock.... in reality... your theory is moot

 

[Get Rid of The Donkeys]

Hey? Agree on Campbelltown

I meant they should rebrand as Magpies.

 

[MugaB]

I meant they should rebrand as Magpies.

To suit your narrative of an easts tigers entry... dream on u potato counting hick

 

[Perth Red]

Not Pointless, whats pointless is you and that logan deadshit grotd who think that there is only a few spots left... there are an infinite amount as long as there is playing stock.... in reality... your theory is moot

The history of the game would suggest I’m correct and the reality is very far from your theoretical assumptions.

 

[Brian potter]

Get farked west tigers.