NRL Hall of Fame 2024 + 14th Immortal

[Nutz]

The systematic cheating Smith and co were guilty of is far worse than coke and pingas

Disagree sorry chins.. Role model behaviour should be at the at the top of selection criteria but I can't see it in the Metrics.
There has to be a std that rarely is debated.

 

[Nutz]

Is immortals going to be part of a hall of fame?

Becoming an Immortal

Only players in the rugby league Hall of Fame are able to be honoured as Immortals.

www.nrl.com

 

[Captain Apollo]

Is immortals going to be part of a hall of fame?

You have to be a member of the Hall of Fame first before you can become an Immortal. It says so on the NRL's website (source: https://www.nrl.com/hall-of-fame/induction-process/becoming-an-immortal/)-



As such Cameron Smith won't be immortal no. 14 as he is not a member of the Hall of Fame. Nor is Jonathan Thurston.

That would also mean the immortal is likely to come from someone on this list who isn't already one -

Men's Players

Read about each NRL Hall of Fame players profile, match statistics, and career information on the official NRL website.

www.nrl.com

So I could see guys like Ron Coote, John Sattler, Bob McCarthy, John O'Neill, Peter Sterling, Brett Kenny, Gene Miles, Glen Lazarus, Steve Mortimer, Mark Graham, Stacey Jones, Steve Walters, Brad Clyde amongst the contenders.

 

[AlwaysGreen]

The systematic cheating Smith and co were guilty of is far worse than coke and pingas

Almost as bad as your mate Warner's systematic cheating.

 

[AlwaysGreen]

You have to be a member of the Hall of Fame first before you can become an Immortal. It says so on the NRL's website (source: https://www.nrl.com/hall-of-fame/induction-process/becoming-an-immortal/)-

View attachment 90928

As such Cameron Smith won't be immortal no. 14 as he is not a member of the Hall of Fame. Nor is Jonathan Thurston.

That would also mean the immortal is likely to come from someone on this list who isn't already one -

Men's Players

Read about each NRL Hall of Fame players profile, match statistics, and career information on the official NRL website.

www.nrl.com

So I could see guys like Ron Coote, John Sattler, Bob McCarthy, John O'Neill, Peter Sterling, Brett Kenny, Gene Miles, Glen Lazarus, Steve Mortimer, Mark Graham, Stacey Jones, Steve Walters, Brad Clyde amongst the contenders.

They'll do Smith at the same time. HoF, immortal.

 

[Captain Apollo]

They'll do Smith at the same time. HoF, immortal.

Nope. They can't do that under their own set up.

 

[Bazal]

Nope. They can't do that under their own set up.

Sure they can. If Barb tells them to. Of course she'll get a 10k Wife of Immortal ring too

 

[Nutz]

You have to be a member of the Hall of Fame first before you can become an Immortal. It says so on the NRL's website (source: https://www.nrl.com/hall-of-fame/induction-process/becoming-an-immortal/)-

View attachment 90928

As such Cameron Smith won't be immortal no. 14 as he is not a member of the Hall of Fame. Nor is Jonathan Thurston.

That would also mean the immortal is likely to come from someone on this list who isn't already one -

Men's Players

Read about each NRL Hall of Fame players profile, match statistics, and career information on the official NRL website.

www.nrl.com

So I could see guys like Ron Coote, John Sattler, Bob McCarthy, John O'Neill, Peter Sterling, Brett Kenny, Gene Miles, Glen Lazarus, Steve Mortimer, Mark Graham, Stacey Jones, Steve Walters, Brad Clyde amongst the contenders.

Exactly. Which will slowly bring it back to where we should be and as I said before it gives the immortal status more scrutiny. Once you set the scene there's no going back without harming the system.

 

[Chins get the wins]

Almost as bad as your mate Warner's systematic cheating.

Davey is a hero who took a bullet for the whole side

 

[Nutz]

Davey is a hero who took a bullet for the whole side

Why use sandpaper. Surely modern technology could've come up with a better way. Acetone hanky maybe.

 

[Bazal]

Why use sandpaper. Surely modern technology could've come up with a better way. Acetone hanker maybe.

Dumb Dumb's name isn't Davey Smart Smart

 

[Desert Qlder]

Can we please not have any political/modern selections like Johns to satisfy Sydney journos/drunks?

Duncan Thompson is the man.

 

[Captain Apollo]

Can we please not have any political/modern selections like Johns to satisfy Sydney journos/drunks?

Duncan Thompson is the man.

Andrew Johns is already in the Hall of Fame and an immortal. If you mean Matty, too early for him as a contributor. People like Geoff Prenter, Kevin Arthurson, John Quayle, Wayne Bennett and Warren Ryan would be well ahead of him.

Only issue with Duncan Thompson is, iirc, they more or less said when they did the last lot of inductees, that the group inducted in 2019 would be the last time they would consider anyone who played before WW2. If so, that's why Thompson won't get there.

Finally, and I could be mistaken here, I recall there being a limit on how many times a player can be considered to become an Immortal. So if they get considered twice and don't get it, they never get it.

 

[PARRA_FAN]

Finally, and I could be mistaken here, I recall there being a limit on how many times a player can be considered to become an Immortal. So if they get considered twice and don't get it, they never get it.

That mightve been said by the old leadership or some jurnos making stuff up.

Provan was considered a number of times and finally got inducted.

I think Coote has been nominated a few times too so imagine the uproar if they said he's ineligible

 

[Soren Lorenson]

Why use sandpaper. Surely modern technology could've come up with a better way. Acetone hanky maybe.

Would've frozen their dick off as it evaporated between deliveries

 

[Nutz]

Would've frozen their dick off as it evaporated between deliveries

Adds to the theatre

 

[Captain Apollo]

That mightve been said by the old leadership or some jurnos making stuff up.

Provan was considered a number of times and finally got inducted.

I think Coote has been nominated a few times too so imagine the uproar if they said he's ineligible

The first time "The Immortals" induction was done by Rugby League Week to promote the magazine and a port.

It was only when they did the 2019 induction that they actually published the criteria used for determining Hall of Fame and Immortal inductions.

Additionally, the whole idea of immortals is they are meant to be the pinnacle. If they don't get the votes going by the criteria used after one or two attempts, they aren't going to get there. Otherwise you will wind up devaluing the whole idea of it. Be it Coote or any other player, as they will be considered forever until they get it. Not every Hall of Fame member deserves to be an Immortal.

Further, some are possibly looking at Coote viewing his playing career in addition to his work with Men in League (as it used to be called). Immortal status is reserved solely for players, so off field stuff doesn't really apply per se (e.g. See Andrew Johns and those who argued against his elevation).

 

[Fangs]

Should someone who has admitted using or found guilty of using illicit substances or performance enhancing drugs be exempt for Immortal or HoF status?

In the case of Andrew Johns they were performance dehancing drugs.

The fact he was on the pingas nearly every weekend and still playing God tier football just cements his place as an immortal.

 

[Nutz]

In the case of Andrew Johns they were performance dehancing drugs.

The fact he was on the pingas nearly every weekend and still playing God tier football just cements his place as an immortal.

OMG.

 

[Nutz]

The first time "The Immortals" induction Immortal status is reserved solely for players, so off field stuff doesn't really apply per se

"achieved outstanding feats on and off the field throughout a professional playing career"
Surely this includes being a good role model.