What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

NRL must be very wary of AFL junior development

Delboy

First Grade
Messages
7,651
RM, what NRL team controls the area you teach in, seems to me that they are missing the boat. There is good activity gopng on in the Parra district, but inner city is where the prob appears to be.
 

mickdo

Coach
Messages
17,355
How are the AFL TV ratings going?

Soccer has had more kids playing their sport in Sydney for 30+ years. How are they going? Seriously, I think far too much wanking is going on with this.
 
Last edited:

Western_Eel

Juniors
Messages
1,395
There is not problem, the kids might enjoy the superstars coming to their school, but at the end of the day the game is boring, the kids would already be watching it if it wasn't
 

hineyrulz

Post Whore
Messages
154,500
How are the AFL TV ratings going?

Soccer has had more kids playing their sport in Sydney for 30+ years. How are they going? Seriously, I think far too much wanking is going on with this.
The Swannies and the lions
get flogged in the ratings by replays of the iron chef on SBS every week:lol:
 

Parra Guru

Coach
Messages
14,645
Ignorance is bliss.

If the AFL are prepared to put in the work in Western Sydney, good luck to them, I hope GWS succeeds. God knows union will never give the NRL a run for it's money out here.

IMO Parramatta has been one of the laziest clubs in recent times in terms of promoting the game out here which is why the Tigers p!ssed all over our territory so easily in 05/06.
 

mickdo

Coach
Messages
17,355
The Swannies and the lions
get flogged in the ratings by replays of the iron chef on SBS every week:lol:

But apparently a few kids playing the game in school is going to magically transform that :roll:

AFL is a novelty here, and will remain a novelty as long as the game is run out of Victoria and league has so many teams in Sydney
 

mickdo

Coach
Messages
17,355
Ignorance is bliss

That's just faff

Seriously mate, soccer players outnumber league and AFL players in Sydney combined, and have done for more than a generation. By your logic they should be the 'dominant' code. They're not. It just doesn't work like that, and contorting your mind to think it does is so geniused it's not funny.
 

PJ Marshal

Coach
Messages
13,525
afl offers to stuff for free , rugby league rarely ever does ... bingo theres your problem there
 

TheParraboy

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
69,224
Using the soccer logic of having more juniors is very misleading

A lot of the kids playing soccer havent had a choice as its mum and dads preference, or its convinient to (big in their school). Check the stats when they turn 16 or 17, when they decide for themselves what they want to play. Soccer and Union in australia is nowhere near as appealing as NRL or Cricket in terms of coverage and image, hence many move on to those sports. AFL will be another viable mix for them

As PG rightfully says Ignorance is bliss
 
Last edited:

mickdo

Coach
Messages
17,355
Using the soccer logic of having more juniors is very misleading

Soccer in Australia has higher participation numbers than any other football code in both juniors and seniors. So why isn't soccer the dominant code then? The argument that was being put forward was that AFL is going to get more kids playing it in schools so it will take over league as the dominant code, and with the example of soccer that is just simplistic and silly.
 

bildo

Juniors
Messages
269
I have two boys (2 yrs and 5 months) and I will be encouraging them to play afl. I don't want to see them being smashed by islanders twice their size each week. Afl looks to be a better game for the young ones in my opinion.

You nailed it, mate. I see that as far and away the biggest problem the game has . When i was a kid we used to play in weight divisions. I don't remember exactly how it went, but i recall being in say the 4 stone sevens? then moving into the 5 stone sevens ?etc and only playing against kids a similar size to me.

I have seen mums on TV worried about their kids getting crushed by big Islander kids 3 times their size. Obviously they don't play the kids according to their weight these days. I also wouldn't allow my kid, if i had one, to be Islander fodder.
 

Delboy

First Grade
Messages
7,651
Maroubra, this is funny because I have 2 kids palying league in the Parra juniors, and at U9 and U6 they have a ball. Even at the club when they play the likes of Cabra and Guildfordat the older ages who have some big boys on their teams, it doesn't appear to be a problem.

To be honest I think a lot of this is out of proportion to the actuality, mums will look at it and hear anecdotal tales, but in reality it is not an issue. Even Brandy on 2UE said that at the younger ages it is not an issue with his boys.

I see a lot of junior league every year, and have yet to see the problem that you seem to talk about, if the junior league is run well then I doubt you should worry.
 

Delboy

First Grade
Messages
7,651
I should say they are my grandsons, and that my son played 11 years in the Parra juniors and there was still some big units running around. This is in part a story being promoted by the AFL, in union there are real monsters and yet no one brings that up
 

El Diablo

Post Whore
Messages
94,107
and RL is one of the safest sports according to this from a few years ago

Aussie rules most injury-prone sport

Xavier La Canna
July 06, 2006 10:00



AUSTRALIAN Rules football is the most injury prone sport in the country, a study by a health insurance company has found.


The Medibank Private study looked at people who presented to hospitals and general medical practices and found people who compete in Australian Rules were more likely than any other sport to become injured.

"The speed and full body contact nature of the sport and the constant physical competition for the ball places players at risk of injury," the study found.

It said Australian Rules was one of the most popular participation sports and players may face hamstring, knee, ankle and shoulder strains and finger injuries.

Sportsmen who play at the highest level are constantly at risk of injury. Some of the most recent injuries in the AFL are Dean Cox (broken collar bone), Justin Koschitzke (fractured skull in an accidental head clash) and James Hird (torn calf, possibly out for the rest of the season).

As an example of how injuries can affect a team, the Western Bulldogs are missing five top players, who are out for 12 months with knee reconstructions, including captain Luke Darcy.

Darcy, who has had a second knee reconstruction, broke down at the start of the season after enduring 12-months of rehab from his first knee injury.

The study says the second most injury-prone sport was basketball, followed by netball, running, tennis, cricket, soccer, aerobics, rugby league and rugby union.

The study found back injuries were the most expensive to treat, costing about $15,750 and $22,000.

It also showed people were more likely to become injured in the winter months and said people should devote more time to warming up and remember to keep up fluid intake and to wear sun protection, especially at the snow.

Walking was found to be the most popular sport, followed by aerobics, swimming, golf and tennis.

The study also found more people in the ACT participated in sports than any other part of Australia, with 76.1 per cent physically active, while South Australia recorded the lowest participation rate, at just 57.7 per cent.

Tasmanians had the country's highest body mass index (BMI), at an average of 27.2, while those in Western Australia were the leanest, with a BMI of 24.91, it found.

As television shows such as Dancing with the Stars encourage people to try dancing, the study found the sport was becoming more popular.

http://www.news.com.au/perthnow/story/0,21498,19713693-948,00.html
 

born an eel

Bench
Messages
3,882
I hope all these parents afraid that their kids wll get hurt, also stop their kids playing together (unless they are twins).

I learnt my footy playing against my brothers and their friends in the backyard who were 2 to 3 years older than me. A six year old playing against a 9 year old is a big difference, as such I learnt to tackle properly.
 

bildo

Juniors
Messages
269
.

To be honest I think a lot of this is out of proportion to the actuality, mums will look at it and hear anecdotal tales, but in reality it is not an issue. Even Brandy on 2UE said that at the younger ages it is not an issue with his boys.

.

Would it be a problem to play the kids in weigh divisions to keep the Mums happy? Might it not even be a smart move?

I am not sure that all the people who are happy for kids to play against monsters would not have a problem doing the same themselves. ;-)
 

Latest posts

Top