The differences between market fluctuations, recoup periods and non-payments between stamp duty and land tax probably even out.
And it’s not a forever tax but my rort question was how SHORT a period I could live in a property and not pay the stamp duty? Could I conceivably buy essentially a rental property and forgo stamp duty in favour of paying a land tax and then how long down the track could I move back to my current home (assuming, having paid stamp duty on it, I could return it to land tax exempt)?
As your calculation showed it’s about 10 year recoup period on the one property. Even factoring in the additional land tax now payable on my current home (that I rent out for the period), the recoup is still going to be years. So if the minimum main residence period for the new home is less than that, financially I’m better off. Not even factoring time value of money.
Even just less of a rort through plain hard work, would be moving house within the recoup period. There’s other costs and hassles to factor in, but there’s definite financial benefit.
More info is filtering through..
There will be an owner occupied rate and a investor rate.
The bolded bit is f**kery at it’s finest. If I find a keeper and intend to live there forever, I can’t pay the duty up front because a predecessor in title already opted to an annual tax.
==============================
The proposal would give home buyers the option of paying a large lump sum upfront, similar to stamp duty, or an annual property tax.
The property tax would be a fixed amount plus a rate applied to the unimproved land value of an individual property – similar to that which occurs with council rates.
Under the change, once a property is subject to the tax, subsequent owners must also pay.
The changes would only apply to those buying property. If you’re not moving home and have already paid stamp duty you will not have to pay the tax.
Under Mr Perrottet’s proposal, owner-occupied homes would be liable for lower rates on the property tax than investment properties. However, protections would also be put in place so that the property tax would not result in rent increases without a tenant’s agreement.
First home buyers, who have stamp duty concessions for properties of up to $800,000, would be given a grant of up to $25,000 to go towards the tax or home refurbishing.
The Treasurer says that, in the short term, the property tax proposal would reduce state government revenue but it is expected to be cost-neutral in the long term.
https://www.smh.com.au/politics/nsw/how-nsw-s-proposed-property-tax-would-work-20201117-p56faq.html