Our Worst Ever Thread (AKA Grouch's dumping ground)

[epDragon62]

Only thing I remember about Creagh was he was the first to bail ship, State of Origin Justin Hodges comes to mind. No team mate could trust him to lead the way after that.

Moron

 

[gitano]

Lol some of these responses.
I'm outta here bye Felicia

 

[ouryears]

Only thing I remember about Creagh was he was the first to bail ship, State of Origin Justin Hodges comes to mind. No team mate could trust him to lead the way after that.

It showed character not to engage a wanker and a thug in Hodges, had he done so, the outcome would have been what? More violence, sin bin, judiciary, and for what?

As the Kenny Rogers song goes, “Know when to walk away....know when to fight,....”

Sure, I wanted Creagh to punch Hodges lights out too, but in retrospect, nothing positive would have come of it.

 

[Coffs dragon]

Our worst ever captain had to be Steve Edge (after he left Saints) and went to the Eels and won a couple of premierships.....that hurt!
He was a junior & great for us in the RedV but an enemy in the Eels jersey. That is the only former captain I could possible think to criticise & only because he left.

 

[Crush]

Our worst ever captain had to be Steve Edge (after he left Saints) and went to the Eels and won a couple of premierships.....that hurt!
He was a junior & great for us in the RedV but an enemy in the Eels jersey. That is the only former captain I could possible think to criticise & only because he left.

But he's a dragons man at heart. He bleeds red and white, he runs Kogarah Jubilee oval. Club legend, top bloke. Surely you can't criticise that?

 

[ouryears]

But he's a dragons man at heart. He bleeds red and white, he runs Kogarah Jubilee oval. Club legend, top bloke. Surely you can't criticise that?

Amazed that Edge left us after captaining us to the 1977 grand final win and playing in the 79 grand final. Why would he had left us?
Money?
Or the fact that Craig Young was made captain in 79?

Or the great Jack Gibson whispered into his ear?

Not may captains and entrenched players leave a club.
He played in 11 grand finals in all grades across his career and led the Eels to 3 gf wins.
He played more games for Eels than us by career end.

Damn that hurts. Love to know why he really did leave us.

Ennis was another we should have hung onto, I am not comparing them, just saying.
Ennis was a tough player, we needed someone like him.

 

[Coffs dragon]

But he's a dragons man at heart. He bleeds red and white, he runs Kogarah Jubilee oval. Club legend, top bloke. Surely you can't criticise that?

No Crush I only criticise when he left and had great success at the Eels. I know he came back and is highly respected, but I just wished he never left in the first place....he was a great captain for the RedV and not so good (tongue in cheek) for Parra!

 

[Fire]

John Dorahy.

 

[muzby]

As the Kenny Rogers song goes, “Know when to walk away....know when to fight,....”

Is that song a new release by Mr Rodgers? I’m not familiar with that line.

 

[Old Kogarah Boy 1]

John Dorahy.

Wow, had forgotten all about good old JD.
Did he really wear the big red V?

 

[Fire]

Wow, had forgotten all about good old JD.
Did he really wear the big red V?

Steelers only.

Got a spoon on his watch.

If anything Creagh deserves credit for avoiding the spoon with the coaches and rosters he had.

 

[possm]

Over the years and in particular over recent years, I have seen some very poor decision made by our on-field captains. In particular, decisions made with regard to taking/defending field goals would have to be up there with the worst.

 

[Willow]

Arjuna Ranatunga.

 

[Saint_JimmyG]

But he's a dragons man at heart. He bleeds red and white, he runs Kogarah Jubilee oval. Club legend, top bloke. Surely you can't criticise that?

Is Edge still involved with the Club? I thought he had left...again.

 

[Saint_JimmyG]

Amazed that Edge left us after captaining us to the 1977 grand final win and playing in the 79 grand final. Why would he had left us?
Money?
Or the fact that Craig Young was made captain in 79?

Or the great Jack Gibson whispered into his ear?

Not may captains and entrenched players leave a club.
He played in 11 grand finals in all grades across his career and led the Eels to 3 gf wins.
He played more games for Eels than us by career end.

Damn that hurts. Love to know why he really did leave us.

Ennis was another we should have hung onto, I am not comparing them, just saying.
Ennis was a tough player, we needed someone like him.

Injuries, unwanted by Bath, and John Dowling’s arrival.

 

[Objective View]

Mary.

1999 grand final fade-out mirrors his coaching career.

Straight Shooter

 

[Saint_JimmyG]

No matter what transpires from this point forward, this is the undisputed dumbest thread of 2018,

Criticising Creagh is beyond me pale.

 

[Saint_JimmyG]

Mary.

1999 grand final fade-out mirrors his coaching career.

Straight Shooter

Bill Harrigan’s employment with News Limited didn’t play it’s part?

 

[Crush]

Is Edge still involved with the Club? I thought he had left...again.

Yes, he is in charge of Kogarah Jubilee Oval.

 

[SBD82]

No matter what transpires from this point forward, this is the undisputed dumbest thread of 2018,

Criticising Creagh is beyond me pale.

Come on Jimmy. Don't be so negative.

Every thread that you contribute to is a strong candidate for dumbest thread of 2018.

The field is still wide open