Ownership of being wrong thread 2018

[jane the pain]

He won 3 MP at the Roosters. For one GF win. Sharks went on a streak last year made it too week one only. He'd know what he's talking about

If was a blonde haired. Coke addict that tried to get players sacked... And said it different story

Sounds like the players are glad to see the back of Matt.

 

[Pomoz]

Moyza is simply a better player than Jimmy in almost every aspect of the sport.

When he has won a few premierships and a SOO series, get back to me, otherwise, that is just plain wrong.

 

[BxTom]

BX you need an avatar.

Ok?

Tom

 

[OldPanther]

Matt's attitude changed when he was caught, and was punished, for breaking team rules in Melbourne. The other players copped their punishment like men, and Matt just had a dummy spit.

All the reports were that the rift with Moylan and Griffin went back to the yer before that.

 

[betcats]

Bad couple weeks for the Moylan haters. He carves us the f**k up and then Maloney does too LOL.

Maloney needs to win us a premiership to make us the winners of the Moylan/Maloney swap. In form Moylan shits all over in form Maloney as a player, no contest.

 

[betcats]

Also I have given hook plenty of credit this year but the fact remains his coaching keeps coming up short and the excuses keep coming for him.

 

[TheFrog]

In form Moylan shits all over in form Maloney as a player, no contest.

Disagree over the course of the season, however Matt has been gaining ground recently.

 

[betcats]

Disagree over the course of the season, however Matt has been gaining ground recently.

IF you consider the game Maloney just played then Maloney is behind over the course of the season, he should've lost dally m points for that shit. How many intercepts has James thrown this year??? He throws one a game atm.

Either way Moylan when in form is just flat out better.

 

[franklin2323]

IF you consider the game Maloney just played then Maloney is behind over the course of the season, he should've lost dally m points for that shit. How many intercepts has James thrown this year??? He throws one a game atm.

Either way Moylan when in form is just flat out better.

Do you honestly think we'd be better then we were if Moylan/Peachey were our halves instead of Maloney/Peachey?

 

[franklin2323]

Disagree over the course of the season, however Matt has been gaining ground recently.

Maloney carried us early on. Then of course was a big reason NSW won origin but plenty of big games to go still

 

[betcats]

Do you honestly think we'd be better then we were if Moylan/Peachey were our halves instead of Maloney/Peachey?

If Moylan wasn’t butting heads with the coach yes I do. Moylan was the best player in the game in the 2nd half of 2016.Izmailovskie

He has shown against penrith this year what he can do when motivated.

 

[betcats]

Maloney has thrown intercepts in his last two or three games. If Moylan did that he’d get laughed at.

 

[TheFrog]

He has shown against penrith this year what he can do when motivated.

This is his trouble. He won't be a true champion of the game until he can motivate himself without needing to play against his old club.

Maloney has thrown intercepts in his last two or three games

Without doubt there is a problem to be addressed here. He needs to look at what opposition players are doing because they are starting to sweat on his passes. Every time a player rushes up like this it leaves a hole and Jimmy is smart enough to exploit this. Needs to think on his feet.

 

[betcats]

This is his trouble. He won't be a true champion of the game until he can motivate himself without needing to play against his old club.

I agree. What bugs me is he never had that problem before Hook came along.

 

[OldPanther]

This is his trouble. He won't be a true champion of the game until he can motivate himself without needing to play against his old club.

2016 he carried us into the finals playing as fullback and 5/8 simultaneously.

 

[franklin2323]

If Moylan wasn’t butting heads with the coach yes I do. Moylan was the best player in the game in the 2nd half of 2016.Izmailovskie

He has shown against penrith this year what he can do when motivated.

It's a different style though. He was able to do his job due to having an organiser inside him doing the boring stuff.

Maloney's value is how well Cleary and the other playmakers come along. I have faith in Gus, Brandy and Maloney to make the changes to our attack we need to make

 

[franklin2323]

I agree. What bugs me is he never had that problem before Hook came along.

We are talking 60 odd FG though. Hardly years and years and plenty of guys in that team was his style on and off the field

 

[betcats]

It's a different style though. He was able to do his job due to having an organiser inside him doing the boring stuff.

Maloney's value is how well Cleary and the other playmakers come along. I have faith in Gus, Brandy and Maloney to make the changes to our attack we need to make

Well Cleary isn't coming along at all right now IMO. The sharks are sitting in 5th, they finished last season in 5th. Unless they drop they are at least doing as well as they did with Maloney last season except they have a younger player with more upside and they got him cheaper than Maloney.

 

[franklin2323]

Well Cleary isn't coming along at all right now IMO. The sharks are sitting in 5th, they finished last season in 5th. Unless they drop they are at least doing as well as they did with Maloney last season except they have a younger player with more upside and they got him cheaper than Maloney.

We are 6th as we were last year. This time last year we were 9th. So an improvement so far

Given Cleary missed 9 games out of 19 played. Who is behind our improvement?

 

[betcats]

We are 6th as we were last year. This time last year we were 9th. So an improvement so far

Given Cleary missed 9 games out of 19 played. Who is behind our improvement?

Our massively improved defensive line speed is the main reason we are doing better. Defence and our forwards are the two biggest improvements for us this year. Moylan would be carving teams up every week if we gave him the platform our halves have been getting most weeks.

You have spoken en masse about how disruptive the Moylan/hook beef was as well the carty situation and other things your brought up so that is a loaded question.