What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Panthers All Time Front Row

All Time Front Row


  • Total voters
    42

Chins get the wins

First Grade
Messages
8,422
It’s fine mate. You just keep battling on, it makes for some interesting viewing.
Your argument that it's not an easier job to not have to take hit ups and play behind the best kicking game in the comp is really is wild.
I'm not saying our props aren't good players, I'm saying it's just far easier to only have to tackle.
 

Luke Bowden

First Grade
Messages
7,329
Your argument that it's not an easier job to not have to take hit ups and play behind the best kicking game in the comp is really is wild.
I'm not saying our props aren't good players, I'm saying it's just far easier to only have to tackle.
They don’t just tackle, this is what you’re failing to recognise. They beat the shit out of teams, for long periods.

This in turn makes it easier for our back three to get quick play the balls and field position.

if that was easy, every one do it.
 

Chins get the wins

First Grade
Messages
8,422
They don’t just tackle, this is what you’re failing to recognise. They beat the shit out of teams, for long periods.

This in turn makes it easier for our back three to get quick play the balls and field position.

if that was easy, every one do it.
Everyone is trying to do it but they don't have To'o or Dyl........you are almost joining the dots! Come on Lukey!
 
Messages
4,313
What I think is most amazing about our defensive displays over the past five years (and this goes for Martin and Kenny as well as the front rowers) is that they hit so hard and smash players, but give away so few penalties and rarely get sin binned/suspended.
 

MugaB

Coach
Messages
15,184
What I think is most amazing about our defensive displays over the past five years (and this goes for Martin and Kenny as well as the front rowers) is that they hit so hard and smash players, but give away so few penalties and rarely get sin binned/suspended.
Check out the stat's on each of our pack, no one under 90% tackle efficiency, yeo is on 98%, that's f**kn unbelievable,
let that sink in league fans,
defence wins premierships, those who want flair can settle for mediocrity at the mid table, and maybe make the 8
 
Last edited:

Chins get the wins

First Grade
Messages
8,422
Check out the stat's on each of our pack, no one under 90% tackle efficiency, yeo is on 98%, that's f**kn unbelievable,
let that sink in league fans,
defence wins premierships, those who want flair can settle for mediocrity at the mid table, and maybe make the 8
We don't want or need flair from our middles. They just tackle.

We'll apart from Yeo
 

Pomoz

Bench
Messages
2,991
Ben Ross, Nobby Clarke and Joel Clinton were all fine players. Petero delivered workmanlike solid performances, but he was a shadow of the rep player he was at the Broncos when he played for us. The rumours about his negative impact on team culture are hard to ignore.

I love Martin Lang and Paul Dunn and they stand out from the other props. They were excellent warriors for us. The trouble is, they only did it briefly. The body of work laid down by Moses and Fish was built over five years. Five years of sustained toughness and defence the likes of Dunn and Lang could only dream of.

To be honest, if any of our other props in their prime were packed down against Moses and Fish, they would come off second best by a long way. I include Petero in that. He was more of a KPI guy in the mould of Hass. Our boys are warriors to the core. No retreat, no surrender. I am really going to miss Fish. Sob....
 

JJ

Immortal
Messages
32,536
Hard to argue with the current two, but Dunn imo was a great forward

also, Kelly, Dunn, and Mortimer as I recall were incredibly influential in supporting the younger players in 89-91 as to what a winning team /culture looks like… now of course that comes from within, and Gould part of both

Clarke was hugely underrated too, and Barry Walker who filled in in the middle or the back row , including in the 91 grand final
 

soc123_au

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
19,849
Pretty ridiculous in my opinion to have Lang near our best Props. He was a kamikaze style forward but not much ball skill really. I’d have 3 or 4 in front of him easily. Can’t deny his toughness though.
He did get a try assist once. I think he was more shocked than anyone.
 

MugaB

Coach
Messages
15,184
Pretty ridiculous in my opinion to have Lang near our best Props. He was a kamikaze style forward but not much ball skill really. I’d have 3 or 4 in front of him easily. Can’t deny his toughness though.
Prop that have those silky skills,hey? Is this why you like takagi?, the silky ball skills?
Probably the worst attribute you'd want a prop to have, tuck the ball under you arm and run straight FFS
 

Latest posts

Top