What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

parra vs manly rnd 3

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,092
Last night on Matty Johns show, Hindy showed the two manly tries being scored off crooked play the balls and then rolled back earlier to Gower and how he was penalized.

The evidence was indisputable. Either very sloppy or one sided reffing. Take your pick.

I think it's now official - we wuz robbed.
 
Messages
19,342
Last night on Matty Johns show, Hindy showed the two manly tries being scored off crooked play the balls and then rolled back earlier to Gower and how he was penalized.

The evidence was indisputable. Either very sloppy or one sided reffing. Take your pick.

I think it's now official - we wuz robbed.

Yeh, I guess with the first Manly try, if he didn't allow their play the ball he'd have been very likely to penalise us for holding down / interference with the tackled player. Would still have been a better result for us.
 

Freak2

Juniors
Messages
1,444
It was either very poor officiating or controvercial.

For those with good memories you will recall hiney's 300th NRL game at Penrith Park where Jared Maxwell stopped the clock for a change over which gave Penrith the opportunity to level up the game and go on and win in Golden Point!

He clearly is a poor referee when it comes to close games. This is not of NRL standard and he needs to be dropped.
 

strider

Post Whore
Messages
78,929
Yeh, I guess with the first Manly try, if he didn't allow their play the ball he'd have been very likely to penalise us for holding down / interference with the tackled player. Would still have been a better result for us.

well even the Gower one was brought about cos watmough hooked gower's foot with his own foot when he was preparing to play the ball and dragged him off balance - maybe we should have got a penalty instead?

evidence stands - refs robbed us! :fist:
 

eel01s

Bench
Messages
3,401
It was either very poor officiating or controvercial.

For those with good memories you will recall hiney's 300th NRL game at Penrith Park where Jared Maxwell stopped the clock for a change over which gave Penrith the opportunity to level up the game and go on and win in Golden Point!

He clearly is a poor referee when it comes to close games. This is not of NRL standard and he needs to be dropped.

I remember that! Clearly Maxwell panics in the last few minutes of a tight game.
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,092
Manly game the worst loss of my life: Tonga

Veteran Parramatta centre Willie Tonga has revealed that last Sunday's loss to Manly drove him to tears, describing the defeat as the worst of his life.
In what could've been the upset of the season, the Eels led last year's grand finalists 18-16 with a minute left on the clock but conceded a try on the final play of the game.
"I was shattered. I honestly never felt like that after a loss in my life," he on Tuesday. "I got really mad about it, and I was tearing up in the sheds. To be so close and put in so much effort and to get that result is heartbreaking."
Tonga said his emotional outburst was a culmination of a difficult two years with the club that has left the Eels with two wooden spoons. Since moving to the club from Townsville in 2012, the Eels have won just 12 of a possible 40 games.
"It is [a build up]. It gets tough and I guess people out there that don't go through this wouldn't realise. We're out there busting ourselves, trying to do our best every week," he said.
"It just wasn't meant to be. I've moved on from that, all the boys have moved on. And we're just looking forward to Penrith this week."
Tonga, 30, paid tribute to coach Brad Arthur for helping the team's younger players move on from a heartbreaking loss that extended their losing streak on the road to a staggering 17 games.
"A lot of heads [were] down, but Brad's been so positive and he's handled it as a positive step from where we were last week, considering they were the grand finalists as well," he said.
"The game was there to be won for us, and we didn't take our opportunities. But we've got a young squad and we're still learning. We can take a lot from that.
"Our boys are young and raw. They're still learning the game. I don't think people realise how raw these boys are. But as soon as they realise their potential and what we can do, the belief that the boys within themselves can have, and we'll surprise some teams and a lot of people."
Tonga said he was confident in the ability of his team to turn it around in front of their home fans against an in-form Panthers side that was on the opposite scale of a last-minute result last week.
"Every week that we come in, Brad's a big part of that, we can dwell on the last [game] for that 24 hours and then that's it. It's gone now," he said.
"We've got another challenge ahead of us. Penrith are doing really well at the moment, it's another game that we need to lift for."
http://www.nrl.com/worst-loss-of-my-life-tonga/tabid/10874/newsid/77116/default.aspx
 

IFR33K

Coach
Messages
17,043
Spoke to one of the officals that was officiating the eels manly game.

Called the referring an absolute disgrace, the play the balls and the high shot on DCE were the wrong call.
 

Gronk

Moderator
Staff member
Messages
77,092
Geoff Toovey said last night on NRL 360 that he was very happy with the ref on Sunday.
 
Top