Peek or Cannings??

[Jake the snake]

Who will take Fui's spot Peek or Cannings.

IMO Peek is more reliable than Cannings an can last abit longer. Cannings agression is dissapointing if he fires up he could be more devestating infact more devestating than Fui but he doesn't. Peek for me.

 

[The Colonel]

Depends on Vella IMO.

 

[shiftysmith]

no one fui will get off

 

[Eels Fan]

I'd like to see Peek get a run.

 

[Phillips]

Cannings

 

[mickdo]

I think Smithy will bring in Cannings for Fui, Wags for Hindy and Peek for Vella if required.

 

[The Colonel]

Peek will come in for Fui if Vella plays.

 

[Twizzle]

Peek would replace Vella, but Cannings would replace Fui

one is there to be the workhorse and the other spot is the impact players spot

 

[The_Coach]

Peek would replace Vella, but Cannings would replace Fui

one is there to be the workhorse and the other spot is the impact players spot

The only problem is Cannings doesn't fulfill his job as the impact player.

Jaffa was going pretty hard on friday night. If he played like Fui he'd be just as good.

 

[parraitdoesmatta]

Cannings For Sure

 

[Belly in Brisvegas]

I'm with Twizzle and Mickdo....but Cannings needs to unload in a big way.

 

[parraitdoesmatta]

well he is playing against his old club

 

[Jake the snake]

Cannings has been dissapointing this year. If only he had some aggro about him.

 

[Belly in Brisvegas]

The only problem is Cannings doesn't fulfill his job as the impact player.

Jaffa was going pretty hard on friday night. If he played like Fui he'd be just as good.

jaffas last game in first grade was terrible (round 5 shocker v broncos)...I'd say he would have wanted to be killing them in premmies to get though of again but then again Ash Graham has had a game since.

 

[fish eel]

Vella and Peek are to alike.

I'd say Cannings play should Fui or Cayless ever be out.

Peek comes in as cover for Stringer and Vella (who I thought was terrific on friday night)

 

[Agent Mulder]

Peek.

 

[PB]

Peek still has a rib injury as far as i know, so Cannings would get the start.

Smith also likes to give guys a go against their old clubs...

 

[The_Coach]

jaffas last game in first grade was terrible (round 5 shocker v broncos)...I'd say he would have wanted to be killing them in premmies to get though of again but then again Ash Graham has had a game since.

Yeah but was Jaffa to blame for any of that game? How much game time did he even get?

I just think Jaffa has more fire in the belly then Cannings.

Cordoba was 18th man ahead of Cannings a week ago, i'd even give him a go ahead of Cannings.

 

[PARRA_FAN]

To give Cordoba a go in finals football is risky, I'd say bring in Peek if Cannings doesnt do a good job. Cannings has the sort of impact like Fui's, but not as good. Peek is more like Cayless, workhorse prop and can carry the forwards when needed.

 

[mickdo]

To give Cordoba a go in finals football is risky, I'd say bring in Peek if Cannings doesnt do a good job. Cannings has the sort of impact like Fui's, but not as good. Peek is more like Cayless, workhorse prop and can carry the forwards when needed.

This is definitely not the time to bring in a rookie.