Penrith Panthers V the lot that stole our song, & claimed it as their own (bulldogs)

[franklin2323]

Looking at tonight and our next few games. I can't see us winning any more.
May as well book in mad monday

I tipped us to get 10 wins... Seems so

 

[Dave's mate]

If Luai plays instead do we win?

Probably the same result except we a have about a mil more in the cap spent elsewhere. The merkin straight up doesn't give a f**k

 

[Pomoz]

Most if not all of this might and probably is true but whats Maloney's excuse? What an awful buy hes been

We will have to agree to disagree. We would have lost a lot more games without him. There is a reason he has been in SOO 5 times out of 6 games since he played for the Panthers. Plenty of better judges than me rate him. Cleary on the other hand, has shown in every arena, finals, SOO he just isn't good enough in that position. He might be a great hooker.

 

[chrisD]

Bring back Matty, make him captain coach. Only person in a decade and a half who made our attack look premiership worthy, and watchable.

 

[Flashstep]

Nathan Cleary is just not a halfback. That game was made for him. Dominant field position and possession and he couldn't find a hole in a swiss cheese factory. What a terrible, awful game he had. He couldn't find a gap if it was lit with lasers and had a neon arrow sign six feet high, pointing at the spot.

Just dreadful, I have seen enough of this type of display now to know that we are going nowhere with him as halfback. Maloney might make mistakes but he does so trying to make things happen. Cleary just shovelled the ball out the back, repeatedly. Brandy must be crying into his beer to think that this bloke has the same number 7 on his back that he wore with distinction.

We dominated in every stat except where it matters, on the scoreboard. Yes, even in effective tackle percentage. Dave's mate showed exactly why he the lowest winning percentage of any coach over 300 games. He cannot coach attack to save himself. What was Wayde Egan doing? Does he still have that scrotum problem that stops him opening his legs and running? Who is coaching him to do that? FFS run you muppet!!

I once had root canal on a molar and it it was so painful I thought I would rather they just tore the thing out. I was thinking something similar with this game except this time it was my eyeballs that were in pain. How bad are we to watch?

Yep Cleary just hasn’t kicked on unfortunately and we’re going to pay the price for it for the next few years, was a massive gamble giving him so much money early on and it’s backfired big time by the looks of things. I still think there’s a halfback in there somewhere but I’m probably just an idiot for thinking that. He has to many performances where he can’t even perform basic halfback skills consistently, the fact he’s played origin is truly mind blowing.

 

[TheFrog]

He has consistently been great for Bulldogs too. Not just against us.

Not that great. I haven't seen him play with such passion, well, ever.

 

[franklin2323]

Probably the same result except we a have about a mil more in the cap spent elsewhere. The merkin straight up doesn't give a f**k

We will see next year but same coaching will be same result

 

[Exsilium]

If Luai plays instead do we win?

Short answer, no.

 

[franklin2323]

Short answer, no.

And there lies the problem...I would love it to be as easy as blame x player.

 

[TheFrog]

Villy was sadly missed.

 

[chrisD]

Cleary inside ball to Yeo, the new Walsh inside ball to Newton.

 

[Dave's mate]

And there lies the problem...I would love it to be as easy as blame x player.

BuT jiMmy WinS derp

 

[OldPanther]

Nathan Cleary is just not a halfback. That game was made for him. Dominant field position and possession and he couldn't find a hole in a swiss cheese factory. What a terrible, awful game he had. He couldn't find a gap if it was lit with lasers and had a neon arrow sign six feet high, pointing at the spot.

Just dreadful, I have seen enough of this type of display now to know that we are going nowhere with him as halfback. Maloney might make mistakes but he does so trying to make things happen. Cleary just shovelled the ball out the back, repeatedly. Brandy must be crying into his beer to think that this bloke has the same number 7 on his back that he wore with distinction.

We dominated in every stat except where it matters, on the scoreboard. Yes, even in effective tackle percentage. Dave's mate showed exactly why he the lowest winning percentage of any coach over 300 games. He cannot coach attack to save himself. What was Wayde Egan doing? Does he still have that scrotum problem that stops him opening his legs and running? Who is coaching him to do that? FFS run you muppet!!

I once had root canal on a molar and it it was so painful I thought I would rather they just tore the thing out. I was thinking something similar with this game except this time it was my eyeballs that were in pain. How bad are we to watch?

You insult Egan yet Kenny played double his minutes with 8 metres gained. Like I said people here don't actually understand football. When both your hookers don't run it's the coaching.

 

[mxlegend99]

Not that great. I haven't seen him play with such passion, well, ever.

Then you've never seen him play. Ffs. That's how he always played.

Look at most of his negative moments and it was quiet often being too passionate. That was exactly what he did for us and NZ last year.

 

[Dave's mate]

Then you've never seen him play. Ffs. That's how he always played.

Look at most of his negative moments and it was quiet often being too passionate. That was exactly what he did for us and NZ last year.

The only time he didn't was in his final game for us and if you're honest you forgive him for that one. Brain the size of a pea but ALWAYS ripped in

 

[franklin2323]

BuT jiMmy WinS derp

Has he played in a worst team than this? There is the problem

 

[TheFrog]

Then you've never seen him play. Ffs. That's how he always played.

Look at most of his negative moments and it was quiet often being too passionate. That was exactly what he did for us and NZ last year.

I've seen him play. He ran with twice as much venom tonight as he did for us, even last year.

 

[franklin2323]

You insult Egan yet Kenny played double his minutes with 8 metres gained. Like I said people here don't actually understand football. When both your hookers don't run it's the coaching.

Our biggest issue is the coaching. Tackles inside 20 tonight was 47-16. One player alone can't fix it

 

[Dave's mate]

I've seen him play. He ran with twice as much venom tonight as he did for us, even last year.

What crap

 

[OldPanther]

I've seen him play. He ran with twice as much venom tonight as he did for us, even last year.

Demonstrably false.

Our biggest issue is the coaching. Tackles inside 20 tonight was 47-16. One player alone can't fix it

Couldn't agree more. It's very obvious a coaching issue.