Luke Rooney, this bloke could've been anything, he should've been a 20 tests veteran, but now at 28 years of age, when he should be at his peak he's instead disappeared off the face of the earth. Rooney was the prototypical modern day winger, he was big and tall, fast and great under the high ball, this bloke cracked 1st grade at 18, won his 1st premiership at 21, played for NSW and Australia before his 22nd birthday and then just kind of slowly started disappearing off the radar until he left for French Union in 2008, has since signed for the rebels but remains unseen.
Denan Kemp, one of the quickest players in the comp at one stage and a prolific try scorer, had a terrible year at the warriors and it's looking like that year has almost killed his career
Frank Pritchard, he's a good player but he should be the best forward in the game, he's absolutely unstoppable on his day, problem is his day comes once a month
Tony Williams, he's still got alot of time to achieve great things but seriously how can someone so big, so fast be so terrible so often
Pat Richards, I know he has been awesome in ESL but he should've achieved so much more in the NRL. Burst on to the scene as a tearaway 18 year old in 2000, and unfortunately did his knee, I reckon if he didn't do his knee he could played for Australia without a doubt. Also left the NRL way too early
Ali Lauitiiti, had enough talent to become a once in a generation type player, big, mobile and one of the best offloaders I've ever seen, was unstoppable in 2002, hasn't really lived up to his potential