What's new
The Front Row Forums

Register a free account today to become a member of the world's largest Rugby League discussion forum! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!

Random Tigers articles from the media

WA Tiger

Bench
Messages
4,713
www.msn.com/en-au/sport/news/nrl-2023-wests-tigers-season-review/ar-AA1gbAQA

NRL 2023: Wests Tigers season review​

Story by Kye Kuncoro • 7h


Just when the Tigers fans thought things couldn’t get any worse, somehow it did.


Following a 2022 season where they finished last and sacked Michael Maguire, Wests have picked up their second consecutive wooden spoon this campaign and have moved on from yet another coach prematurely.


The struggling Tigers managed to break all the wrong records in 2023, going on one of the worst losing stretches in NRL history.


The marquee signings made over the off-season had many experts predicting at least an improvement in the sides' form, but they for the most part were unable to fire on a consistent basis.


A lack of creativity in attack and poor goal-line defence plagued the Tigers all season, ultimately resulting in the firing of Tim Sheens - their sixth coaching change in the past decade.


Unfortunately, all the optimism that followed the Tigers into this season quickly diminished as the club found itself at rock bottom and it will be up to Benji Marshall to turn things around.

Did the Tigers over-deliver or under-deliver in 2023?


The expectations on the Tigers this season were simply to avoid the spoon and to be competitive. It’s safe to say the Tigers have accomplished neither and have UNDER- DELIVERED in 2023.







Just when the Tigers fans thought things couldn’t get any worse, somehow it did.

Following a 2022 season where they finished last and sacked Michael Maguire, Wests have picked up their second consecutive wooden spoon this campaign and have moved on from yet another coach prematurely.

The struggling Tigers managed to break all the wrong records in 2023, going on one of the worst losing stretches in NRL history.

The marquee signings made over the off-season had many experts predicting at least an improvement in the sides' form, but they for the most part were unable to fire on a consistent basis.

A lack of creativity in attack and poor goal-line defence plagued the Tigers all season, ultimately resulting in the firing of Tim Sheens - their sixth coaching change in the past decade.

Unfortunately, all the optimism that followed the Tigers into this season quickly diminished as the club found itself at rock bottom and it will be up to Benji Marshall to turn things around.

The Sporting News reviews the Wests Tigers season below.




Did the Tigers over-deliver or under-deliver in 2023?


The expectations on the Tigers this season were simply to avoid the spoon and to be competitive. It’s safe to say the Tigers have accomplished neither and have UNDER- DELIVERED in 2023.


The acquisitions of Isaiah Papali’i, John Bateman, Apisai Koroisau and David Klemmer were supposed to at the very least push the Tigers off the bottom and towards a finals finish.

The standout from those signings has to be Api Koroisau who was arguably the side’s best, showcasing elite leadership and craftiness.

The other aforementioned signings were okay but not spectacular, with the emergence of talented youngster Jahream Bula the Tigers' unexpected hero in 2023.

A lack of cohesion stung the Tigers to start 2023 as the new signings struggled to mesh, resulting in the clunkiest attack in the NRL.

Nothing ever seemed to fall into place for a side that often showed heart but consistently failed to find a way to win.

When did it fall apart for the Wests Tigers?


From Round 1 it seemed the Tigers were on the back foot as they failed to find any success in their first eight matches, going 0-7.

In particular, Rounds 1-3 were extremely poor as the Tigers dropped points to the Titans, Knights and Bulldogs - all clubs who were either struggling at the time or have finished the season outside the top-eight.

Their seven-game losing streak is officially the fourth-longest winless run to start an NRL season.

The Tigers' woeful 2023 was typified by their Round 18 performance against the Cowboys where they conceded 74 points, the largest losing margin in the competition’s history.

The Tigers from Round 14 to Round 24 would lose 10 straight games - their second-longest losing streak only behind their 12-game losing streak which continued from 2022 into the 2023 season.

An inability to execute when they found themselves in their opponent's redzone was the Tigers' glaring issue this season as they finished with the least points scored.


This firing of Tim Sheens who was only appointed 12 months earlier would exemplify the instability at the club with the Tigers seemingly always in a state of flux.

The best period to be a Wests Tigers fan


In terms of great wins for the Tigers this year, there was no greater than the 66-18 demolition of the Cowboys at Leichhardt Oval in Luke Brooks’ 200th game.

A special moment for both Brooks who has been a loyal servant of the club and the fans that got to experience their side triumph emphatically at their spiritual home.

The period between Round 9-12 was the club’s best they went 3-1 with the remarkable upset victory over the back-to-back premiers, the Panthers, and the Dragons.

At the time it looked like the Tigers had turned a corner. Brooks, Koroisau and Bula were firing in the spine whilst newcomers Bateman, Papali’i and Klemmer had adapted and were dominating the middle.

The Round 13 bye would kill all momentum though, as the Raiders' one point victory in the final moments would be the beginning of the end for Wests’ season.

Shining light: Jahream Bula


The emergence of Bula came absolutely out of left field as the unknown fullback quickly rose to prominence.

One of the club's best performers in 2023, his introduction into the side correlated directly with their success in the middle of this season.

Bula is a frontrunner for the Dally M Rookie of the Year award and has been integral in the limited success his side has found this season.

The 21-year-old finished the year with five tries, 59 tackle breaks, seven try assists, and 159 average run metres per game, single-handedly sparking the Tigers' sluggish attack.

It was his inspired defence that really stood out, as Bula was amongst the best defensive fullbacks in the NRL.

Bula made eight try-saving tackles across the season, with two of those directly impacting their Round 9 and 10 wins.

Will the Tigers improve in 2024?


Yes – it is almost impossible for the Tigers to fall any further.

Benji Marshall will take complete control in 2024 and will be expected to at the very least elevate the Tigers outside the bottom four.

Wests showed that they could win the field position battle on multiple occasions, it was just their inability to turn their field position into points that haunted them.

These graphs from The Rugby League Eye Test showcase the inefficiency that the Tigers had trying to score points.

They were elite at getting into the right positions but were unable to convert opportunities into points, resulting in losing winnable games.

These statistics do show that the Tigers are capable of being competitive and just need more polish to match their ability to gain metres.

The Brooks and Laurie combination between Rounds 22-24 showed the side can put on points with the Tigers scoring 18 or more against three top-eight sides.

That combination will be gone by 2024, and the Tigers will be hoping that they can find joy with the new partnership between expected signing Aidan Sezer and confirmed acquisition Jayden Sullivan.

Koroisau needs to be healthy for all of 2024 - the attack flows through his creativity around the ruck and it was clear he was sorely missed when he was unavailable through injury.

The duo of Stefano Utoikamanu and Klemmer did relatively well up front whilst a bit more attacking flair will hopefully allow the star edge pairing of Bateman and Papali’i to flourish.

The constant altering of the centre and wing pairings highlighted the uncertainty the coaching team felt in that area of the squad, which might need reinforcements.

The lack of depth in the halves was the Tigers' other glaring issue in 2023 which will hopefully be resolved by both Sezer and Sullivan, as well as young prodigy Latu Fainu.

Wests Tigers player movements 2024


Gains:

Latu Fainu, Samuela Fainu, Jayden Sullivan, Aidan Sezer

Losses:

Luke Brooks, Tommy Talau, Daine Laurie

Unsigned

Alex Seyfarth, Apisalome Saukuru, Brandon Wakeham, Charlie Staines, Tukimihia Simpkins
Not sure which I’m more happy about, the gains or losses..
 
Last edited:

Nutz

First Grade
Messages
5,212

IMAGINE Adam Reynolds running out to play alongside Benji Marshall in the halves for Wests Tigers on Sunday, ready to take down South Sydney.
The Bunnies No.7 has revealed that the first jumper he played in was a Tigers one.

He spent his first five years with Leichhardt Juniors, who are deep in Tiger territory. He even lost two grand finals with Tigers prop Aaron Woods.
"I did play with Leichhardt from about under-7s to under-12s. I played with 'Woodsy', who was always a bigger kid, and he loved picking on the smaller blokes."
 

Nutz

First Grade
Messages
5,212
Has anyone got access to a google news article on "IOC Vice-President John Coates rejects Wests Tigers plea for help"
 

Fordy20

Juniors
Messages
2,283
Has anyone got access to a google news article on "IOC Vice-President John Coates rejects Wests Tigers plea for help"
There was a similar article posted to the DT. I quoted the whole thing including the stuff on Coates here:

 

Nutz

First Grade
Messages
5,212
There was a similar article posted to the DT. I quoted the whole thing including the stuff on Coates here:

Cheers Fordy.
What did Wayde do, send the board a photo that said your all knobs ha ha.
Coates stating that “The club is my pleasure and I don’t want to mix my team with business.’’
What's he seeing that we're not seeing. The place is a rock show, maybe that is it, he doesn't want to ruin his reputation.
Anyway, soldier on, we will be a good club in one millennium surely.
 

Fordy20

Juniors
Messages
2,283
What did Wayde do, send the board a photo that said your all knobs ha ha.

Who knows? I would have loved to see the contents of that email.

As much as I rag on the board, sook about Sheens and lament our lack of success over the years, Coates has got a point. It's much more interesting being a fan of this club than some boring team like the Storm.
 

Nutz

First Grade
Messages
5,212
Who knows? I would have loved to see the contents of that email.

As much as I rag on the board, sook about Sheens and lament our lack of success over the years, Coates has got a point. It's much more interesting being a fan of this club than some boring team like the Storm.
I'd love to be a fly on the wall listening to some of the meetings and conversations that have resulted in monumental stuff ups so I could force their hand to stop the rubbish that's served up over and over.
The problem exists where there seems to be a brotherhood amongst them where the shite sticks together.
I really would do anything to help this club succeed and that's why I renew my membership every year but gee... I often feel that I/we aren't respected or considered.
Off topic a little. I think one way to help mend the scars a little is to have more meet and greet BBQs for members...FREE.
In the big scheme of things this wouldn't break the bank and the return would be huge. I'm interstate and meet and greet functions should be free for members once a year. This makes up for the fact that it's hard for us to attend most games and interact with players.
I would really appreciate you guys making a comment about this before I email the club about it.
 

Nutz

First Grade
Messages
5,212
Isn't this similar to another WT player a couple of years ago...who was that?
Just remembered it was Zane Musgrove who was charged for driving with a suspended licence.
It seems you don't have to have a reasonable IQ these days to play footy.
All the other serious crimes that are popping up appear to be a blight on pathways and our club.
It's not even full on off season yet for heaven's sake.
I think these young fellas need to have some decent role models and minders to guide them thru footy life.
On a whole though, there are a lot of registered players that are doing the right thing and are fine upstanding citizens... it's just a handful of morons that spoil it for everyone, including us fans.
 
Messages
3,307
The old school teacher, teaches other 'sports journalist' how to !

Roy Masters from SMH

It is almost impossible for an NRL club to go broke today, given the ARL Commission effectively pays the players’ salaries and provides $5 million to each club for administration expenses, but Wests Tigers have finished the 2023 season $1.4 million in debt.

It won’t push the wooden spooners into bankruptcy, especially not while they are backed by the rich Wests Ashfield licensed club, which can fund any deficit.

But if the ARLC was to suddenly reduce the annual grants to NRL clubs or the Wests Ashfield directors were to lose control of the board and the money dried up, the football club would retreat to where it was nearly 50 years ago.
Back then, when the Magpies played at Lidcombe Oval and club president Bill “The King” Carson was at war with the Wests Ashfield board, the annual grant from the licensed club would have funded the salary of just one top player.

The discord was such that when the Magpies secured a major sponsor from lawnmower company Victa in the late 1970s, the Wests Ashfield board cut the annual grant by the amount of the sponsorship.
The arguments over funding continued when Wests merged with Balmain to form Wests Tigers in 1999, with the two foundation clubs having equal numbers on the then 10-director board of the NRL’s new joint venture. Any call for cash to meet a shortfall required Balmain and Wests to contribute equally.

However, Balmain resisted this because they were broke. They were able to stall the inevitable because they dominated the Wests Tigers board via the representative of Wests League Club at Campbelltown, who traditionally voted with the Tigers.

So, Wests Tigers operated with fewer funds than other NRL clubs because Balmain couldn’t contribute.

The Tigers were coached by Tim Sheens from 2005-11 and though he may have worked for less back then, he received a reasonable payout when he left this year after a second stint as head coach.

His $1 million settlement is the major contributor to the Wests Tigers’ $1.4 million deficit, along with termination payments to his partner, who worked in administration, and the club’s former recruitment manager, Warren McDonnell.

Those payments are unusual and Wests Tigers, like all NRL clubs, are expected to post a surplus next season. That, however, assumes club grants remain the same and projects such as the Las Vegas extravaganza remain cost-revenue neutral.
This brings us to Tuesday night’s Wests Ashfield board meeting, which followed fan dissatisfaction that culminated in an online petition calling for an independent review of Wests Tigers.

The Wests Ashfield-commissioned report, prepared by former NRL chief financial officer Tony Crawford and businessman Gary Barnier, is near completion, with Crawford saying: “We took the board of Wests Ashfield through the process, explaining our thinking, and will then move to other key stakeholders, such as Balmain and Wests Magpies. The final report should be completed inside a month.”

It is likely the report will recommend the addition of independent directors to the present seven-person board, which Wests Ashfield currently dominates via an entity known as the Holman-Barnes
Group.

However, there will need to be safeguards to ensure Wests Ashfield doesn’t cede control and, therefore, refuse to fund future deficits in the event of the ARLC cutting back on grants.
One director, speaking anonymously because discussions had been confidential, said Wests Ashfield would never “sell off the farm” but could choose to carve out essential reserve powers, take a back seat and allow directors with specialist skills to make football decisions.

To be fair, Wests Tigers would have broken even this year if they reduced their ramped-up spending in the south-west of Sydney, but this region is their long-term source of players and fans. It is, therefore, their future, especially if the mega-rich Wests club at Campbelltown rejoins the Wests Tigers board.

Thank you Roy Masters.
 

Tigerm

Coach
Messages
10,704
The old school teacher, teaches other 'sports journalist' how to !

Roy Masters from SMH

It is almost impossible for an NRL club to go broke today, given the ARL Commission effectively pays the players’ salaries and provides $5 million to each club for administration expenses, but Wests Tigers have finished the 2023 season $1.4 million in debt.

It won’t push the wooden spooners into bankruptcy, especially not while they are backed by the rich Wests Ashfield licensed club, which can fund any deficit.

But if the ARLC was to suddenly reduce the annual grants to NRL clubs or the Wests Ashfield directors were to lose control of the board and the money dried up, the football club would retreat to where it was nearly 50 years ago.
Back then, when the Magpies played at Lidcombe Oval and club president Bill “The King” Carson was at war with the Wests Ashfield board, the annual grant from the licensed club would have funded the salary of just one top player.

The discord was such that when the Magpies secured a major sponsor from lawnmower company Victa in the late 1970s, the Wests Ashfield board cut the annual grant by the amount of the sponsorship.
The arguments over funding continued when Wests merged with Balmain to form Wests Tigers in 1999, with the two foundation clubs having equal numbers on the then 10-director board of the NRL’s new joint venture. Any call for cash to meet a shortfall required Balmain and Wests to contribute equally.

However, Balmain resisted this because they were broke. They were able to stall the inevitable because they dominated the Wests Tigers board via the representative of Wests League Club at Campbelltown, who traditionally voted with the Tigers.

So, Wests Tigers operated with fewer funds than other NRL clubs because Balmain couldn’t contribute.

The Tigers were coached by Tim Sheens from 2005-11 and though he may have worked for less back then, he received a reasonable payout when he left this year after a second stint as head coach.

His $1 million settlement is the major contributor to the Wests Tigers’ $1.4 million deficit, along with termination payments to his partner, who worked in administration, and the club’s former recruitment manager, Warren McDonnell.

Those payments are unusual and Wests Tigers, like all NRL clubs, are expected to post a surplus next season. That, however, assumes club grants remain the same and projects such as the Las Vegas extravaganza remain cost-revenue neutral.
This brings us to Tuesday night’s Wests Ashfield board meeting, which followed fan dissatisfaction that culminated in an online petition calling for an independent review of Wests Tigers.

The Wests Ashfield-commissioned report, prepared by former NRL chief financial officer Tony Crawford and businessman Gary Barnier, is near completion, with Crawford saying: “We took the board of Wests Ashfield through the process, explaining our thinking, and will then move to other key stakeholders, such as Balmain and Wests Magpies. The final report should be completed inside a month.”

It is likely the report will recommend the addition of independent directors to the present seven-person board, which Wests Ashfield currently dominates via an entity known as the Holman-Barnes
Group.

However, there will need to be safeguards to ensure Wests Ashfield doesn’t cede control and, therefore, refuse to fund future deficits in the event of the ARLC cutting back on grants.
One director, speaking anonymously because discussions had been confidential, said Wests Ashfield would never “sell off the farm” but could choose to carve out essential reserve powers, take a back seat and allow directors with specialist skills to make football decisions.

To be fair, Wests Tigers would have broken even this year if they reduced their ramped-up spending in the south-west of Sydney, but this region is their long-term source of players and fans. It is, therefore, their future, especially if the mega-rich Wests club at Campbelltown rejoins the Wests Tigers board.

Thank you Roy Masters.
Another good post OTT, cheers.
 

Nutz

First Grade
Messages
5,212
But if the ARLC was to suddenly reduce the annual grants to NRL clubs or the Wests Ashfield directors were to lose control of the board and the money dried up, the football club would retreat to where it was nearly 50 years ago.
Lets hope this doesn't happen.
It sort of emphasises the need for the club to stop making dumb decisions that result in unnecessary payouts too.
 

Fordy20

Juniors
Messages
2,283
The old school teacher, teaches other 'sports journalist' how to !

Roy Masters from SMH

It is almost impossible for an NRL club to go broke today, given the ARL Commission effectively pays the players’ salaries and provides $5 million to each club for administration expenses, but Wests Tigers have finished the 2023 season $1.4 million in debt.

It won’t push the wooden spooners into bankruptcy, especially not while they are backed by the rich Wests Ashfield licensed club, which can fund any deficit.

But if the ARLC was to suddenly reduce the annual grants to NRL clubs or the Wests Ashfield directors were to lose control of the board and the money dried up, the football club would retreat to where it was nearly 50 years ago.
Back then, when the Magpies played at Lidcombe Oval and club president Bill “The King” Carson was at war with the Wests Ashfield board, the annual grant from the licensed club would have funded the salary of just one top player.

The discord was such that when the Magpies secured a major sponsor from lawnmower company Victa in the late 1970s, the Wests Ashfield board cut the annual grant by the amount of the sponsorship.
The arguments over funding continued when Wests merged with Balmain to form Wests Tigers in 1999, with the two foundation clubs having equal numbers on the then 10-director board of the NRL’s new joint venture. Any call for cash to meet a shortfall required Balmain and Wests to contribute equally.

However, Balmain resisted this because they were broke. They were able to stall the inevitable because they dominated the Wests Tigers board via the representative of Wests League Club at Campbelltown, who traditionally voted with the Tigers.

So, Wests Tigers operated with fewer funds than other NRL clubs because Balmain couldn’t contribute.

The Tigers were coached by Tim Sheens from 2005-11 and though he may have worked for less back then, he received a reasonable payout when he left this year after a second stint as head coach.

His $1 million settlement is the major contributor to the Wests Tigers’ $1.4 million deficit, along with termination payments to his partner, who worked in administration, and the club’s former recruitment manager, Warren McDonnell.

Those payments are unusual and Wests Tigers, like all NRL clubs, are expected to post a surplus next season. That, however, assumes club grants remain the same and projects such as the Las Vegas extravaganza remain cost-revenue neutral.
This brings us to Tuesday night’s Wests Ashfield board meeting, which followed fan dissatisfaction that culminated in an online petition calling for an independent review of Wests Tigers.

The Wests Ashfield-commissioned report, prepared by former NRL chief financial officer Tony Crawford and businessman Gary Barnier, is near completion, with Crawford saying: “We took the board of Wests Ashfield through the process, explaining our thinking, and will then move to other key stakeholders, such as Balmain and Wests Magpies. The final report should be completed inside a month.”

It is likely the report will recommend the addition of independent directors to the present seven-person board, which Wests Ashfield currently dominates via an entity known as the Holman-Barnes
Group.

However, there will need to be safeguards to ensure Wests Ashfield doesn’t cede control and, therefore, refuse to fund future deficits in the event of the ARLC cutting back on grants.
One director, speaking anonymously because discussions had been confidential, said Wests Ashfield would never “sell off the farm” but could choose to carve out essential reserve powers, take a back seat and allow directors with specialist skills to make football decisions.

To be fair, Wests Tigers would have broken even this year if they reduced their ramped-up spending in the south-west of Sydney, but this region is their long-term source of players and fans. It is, therefore, their future, especially if the mega-rich Wests club at Campbelltown rejoins the Wests Tigers board.

Thank you Roy Masters.

Typical. The club wouldn’t have needed a top up from it’s owners Wests Ashfield if the board hadn’t brought back Sheens in the first place.

I find it farcical that the Wests Ashfield directors release this article, threatening that they could withdraw funding if they don’t get to continue to call the shots, when it’s the geniused decisions of those same Wests Ashfield directors that have lead to the club being a clusterf**k for over a decade.

What Tony and his cronies need to realise is that the only reason they have an NRL licence at the moment is because the ARLC haven’t taken it off them yet. This review needs to be more than just window dressing. They need to prove they want to keep the NRL licence and willing to make the changes necessary to be successful.

Sydney is a saturated market and if the current owners don’t want to own an NRL club, there are plenty of other organisations that will step in and take up a licence, just is there are plenty of clubs like the Bulldogs, Roosters, Souths and Parramatta who would be more than happy to add our territory to their junior pathways.
 

gordsy

Juniors
Messages
2,118
Typical. The club wouldn’t have needed a top up from it’s owners Wests Ashfield if the board hadn’t brought back Sheens in the first place.

I find it farcical that the Wests Ashfield directors release this article, threatening that they could withdraw funding if they don’t get to continue to call the shots, when it’s the geniused decisions of those same Wests Ashfield directors that have lead to the club being a clusterf**k for over a decade.

What Tony and his cronies need to realise is that the only reason they have an NRL licence at the moment is because the ARLC haven’t taken it off them yet. This review needs to be more than just window dressing. They need to prove they want to keep the NRL licence and willing to make the changes necessary to be successful.

Sydney is a saturated market and if the current owners don’t want to own an NRL club, there are plenty of other organisations that will step in and take up a licence, just is there are plenty of clubs like the Bulldogs, Roosters, Souths and Parramatta who would be more than happy to add our territory to their junior pathways.
I would love to see the Nrl step in and put people with brains in charge of this club even if it means moving us to WA. I'd rather a well run WA Tigers then more of the same shit we've had to cop the past 10 years.
 

Similar threads

Latest posts

Top