Rd.3 v Broncos

[Red&BlackBear]

G

Why does everyone think tripping is a sin bin and suspension?

For years it has been a penalty and fine. Josh Reynolds IIRC did it regularly and only got fined for it.

Not sure how Romey will go with the high tackle charge. The player was falling. Id be happy for him to be suspended for that. While his second half was better. He was the Eels best that first half. 3 penalties and a 6 again. All their points came off the back of his discipline.

Got a monetary charge for both as per Panthers website.

 

[Luke Bowden]

Why is no one talking about the hip drop that nearly ended Tito’s season?

 

[Fangs]

Gonna be a ripper.

Both grand finalists haven't been too great to start the season. But glimpses of best form returning. They will both go up a gear for this match.

 

[betcats]

Why does everyone think tripping is a sin bin and suspension?

For years it has been a penalty and fine. Josh Reynolds IIRC did it regularly and only got fined for it.

Not sure how Romey will go with the high tackle charge. The player was falling. Id be happy for him to be suspended for that. While his second half was better. He was the Eels best that first half. 3 penalties and a 6 again. All their points came off the back of his discipline.

Going back a bit but it used to be straight send off no questions asked

 

[Iamback]

Going back a bit but it used to be straight send off no questions asked

Game was slower then. Most of the recent ones are after a defender is off balance.

Last night perfect example, Moses uses footworks Laui off balance

 

[Girds89]

Why is no one talking about the hip drop that nearly ended Tito’s season?

Or fish getting absolutely belted off the ball which looks to have busted his shoulder.

Hopefully not to serious and just a real bad burner but still concerning.

Ive noticed the broncs have already provided an update on Reynolds scans. Low grade medial.

The club took forever last year to orovide updates on any sort of significant injury. If we dont hear anything about fish in the coming days ill be worried its bad.

 

[Girds89]

Game was slower then. Most of the recent ones are after a defender is off balance.

Last night perfect example, Moses uses footworks Laui off balance

Yep you could see luai slip and slip 20 odd cms before like automatic reaction to put the foot out.

Not a lot in it.

The highshot obviously saved by the fact both is arms were down and not to much force and player was not far off the ground.

Money for both seems about right.

 

[Iamback]

Or fish getting absolutely belted off the ball which looks to have busted his shoulder.

Hopefully not to serious and just a real bad burner but still concerning.

Ive noticed the broncs have already provided an update on Reynolds scans. Low grade medial.

The club took forever last year to orovide updates on any sort of significant injury. If we dont hear anything about fish in the coming days ill be worried its bad.

We saw in the undisputed doco Cleary rocking up and randoms in the same waiting room.

A bad injury is hard to hide as stuff like ops are booked

 

[Chins get the wins]

Yep you could see luai slip and slip 20 odd cms before like automatic reaction to put the foot out.

Not a lot in it.

The highshot obviously saved by the fact both is arms were down and not to much force and player was not far off the ground.

Money for both seems about right.

Any highshot that takes a player out of the game probably deserves a suspension

 

[Iamback]

Any highshot that takes a player out of the game probably deserves a suspension

It is a hard one. They are strict on Head injuries now, Not sure you can suspend for accidents in a lot of cases.

Like this one. Luai stayed on the ground, Didn't have a swinging arm. It became an issue because he was falling as opposed to a dog shot

 

[Bred not Bought]

Any highshot that takes a player out of the game probably deserves a suspension

Not if the player is falling. Right decision.

I would give a week to tripping for any player though.

 

[hindy111]

I watched NSW CUP. The halfback looked very good.

 

[Red&BlackBear]

Unless you write certain words on social media then you have to kill someone on field to get suspended

RCG didn’t even get cited.

 

[age.s]

I'm happy Luai is playing. He was better in the second half and I'd like to see if he carries that through to his next game.

At the end of the day we're a much better chance of a fourpeat with him playing well, so him getting into a rhythm is what we should want to see.

 

[WestyLife]

RCG didn’t even get cited.

Because he missed.

 

[Iamback]

6-12 weeks for Fish

 

[hindy111]

6-12 weeks for Fish

Ouch....Hopefully only 6.

 

[Girds89]

6-12 weeks for Fish

Whats the injury?

 

[Iamback]

Ouch....Hopefully only 6.

AC Joint. So it is more pain than doing more damage

 

[Iamback]

Whats the injury?

AC Joint. Hurt ligaments and bruising around it