TRANSLATION
Juniors
- Messages
- 1,910
Firstly I want to point out that Ricky stuart is a good coach, but he is NOT the best man for the job.
He has a good record of making 4 Grand finals. But he also has a Squad of 25 or 35 that are possibly the best in the game for talent and depth.
Then you can add the most expensive Flegg players in history ( as Fletcher stated in a interview when he moved to the rabbits).
They are continually coming through, the best of the best talented 15 year olds poached from all over Australia.
Good Luck to the roosters, Good management, Lots of $$$$$$.
BUT,
The Roosters are sitting on 8 points after 9 Rounds. Luckily beat the rabbits after souths lost 3 blokes for the second half, got beaten by a Dragons team that played well below their best.
Beat the panthers through intercepts. Just got ontop of the Newcastle reserve grade side today took 40 mins ??.. Inept.
Stuarts use of the bench is the worst in the NRL, he continually changes halfbacks during a game. plays 4 blokes at 5/8 per game ??.
This is not a Roosters bashing thread, I have praised their management , It's about Ricky Stuart.
Fitler and Finch where together for a couple of seasons, always played together, The roosters harldy had major injuries for long periods to more than 1 or 2 quality players.
Being able to play your halves on a weekly basis, especially having someone like Brad Fitler there, is going to set your team up well, And you should be looking to win a competition on the back of that.
Stuart against everyones wishes at the Roosters kept playing Walker for some reason. When it was clear their were better players to use. Why ?
He may go on and win the SOO, with all the talent he will have at his disposal, But if he losses, he should be tossed out.
How was the position given ?. Why was the position given to another Roosters coach ?. Who makes these rules? Who ?
Stuarts stats this season without Brad Fitler are less than 50%, Mind you with a full squad of players, no major injuries. Only Finch has been missing a few games, yet they won 3 of their 4, without him.
Soliola has missed a couple of games, and is a great talent, But he has played what 4 games? Harldy someone they would miss immensely.
THe Dogs who are missing, Sonny, O'Mealey, Mason, Reni, hughes, Perry, are on the same points as the Roosters.
The Dragons who were missing Barrett, Ryles, Gasnier, Cooper , head are also on the same points.
This makes you wonder?. How would the roosters go, if they all of a sudden had some long term injuries to key players?
If you have a full compliment of players, you should be firing.
Even the Raiders, who have lost a stack of players recently are in Position number 1. Why ?.. Good coach who achieved plenty last season, and more so this season.
The best coach at the moment for NSW is a proven one.
Graham Murray or Matty Elliott.
Ricky Win it or stand down.
This is My opinion. Like it or not.
Even Melon agrees Stuart has little clue at the moment. See threads below.
http://forums.leagueunlimited.com/viewtopic.php?t=58280
Over to you.!
He has a good record of making 4 Grand finals. But he also has a Squad of 25 or 35 that are possibly the best in the game for talent and depth.
Then you can add the most expensive Flegg players in history ( as Fletcher stated in a interview when he moved to the rabbits).
They are continually coming through, the best of the best talented 15 year olds poached from all over Australia.
Good Luck to the roosters, Good management, Lots of $$$$$$.
BUT,
The Roosters are sitting on 8 points after 9 Rounds. Luckily beat the rabbits after souths lost 3 blokes for the second half, got beaten by a Dragons team that played well below their best.
Beat the panthers through intercepts. Just got ontop of the Newcastle reserve grade side today took 40 mins ??.. Inept.
Stuarts use of the bench is the worst in the NRL, he continually changes halfbacks during a game. plays 4 blokes at 5/8 per game ??.
This is not a Roosters bashing thread, I have praised their management , It's about Ricky Stuart.
Fitler and Finch where together for a couple of seasons, always played together, The roosters harldy had major injuries for long periods to more than 1 or 2 quality players.
Being able to play your halves on a weekly basis, especially having someone like Brad Fitler there, is going to set your team up well, And you should be looking to win a competition on the back of that.
Stuart against everyones wishes at the Roosters kept playing Walker for some reason. When it was clear their were better players to use. Why ?
He may go on and win the SOO, with all the talent he will have at his disposal, But if he losses, he should be tossed out.
How was the position given ?. Why was the position given to another Roosters coach ?. Who makes these rules? Who ?
Stuarts stats this season without Brad Fitler are less than 50%, Mind you with a full squad of players, no major injuries. Only Finch has been missing a few games, yet they won 3 of their 4, without him.
Soliola has missed a couple of games, and is a great talent, But he has played what 4 games? Harldy someone they would miss immensely.
THe Dogs who are missing, Sonny, O'Mealey, Mason, Reni, hughes, Perry, are on the same points as the Roosters.
The Dragons who were missing Barrett, Ryles, Gasnier, Cooper , head are also on the same points.
This makes you wonder?. How would the roosters go, if they all of a sudden had some long term injuries to key players?
If you have a full compliment of players, you should be firing.
Even the Raiders, who have lost a stack of players recently are in Position number 1. Why ?.. Good coach who achieved plenty last season, and more so this season.
The best coach at the moment for NSW is a proven one.
Graham Murray or Matty Elliott.
Ricky Win it or stand down.
This is My opinion. Like it or not.
Even Melon agrees Stuart has little clue at the moment. See threads below.
http://forums.leagueunlimited.com/viewtopic.php?t=58280
Over to you.!
